Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Chain eatery specializing in thick-crust pizzas, also offering sides & desserts.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5719 Yellowstone Rd #1, Cheyenne, WY 82009
Phone: (307) 634-5222
Website: http://godfathers.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Godfather’s Pizza: Home
It’s not just pizza, it’s a meal! Our pies are piled high with quality ingredients and topped with heaping layers of perfectly melted cheese, so you enjoy a …
Godfather’s Pizza Cheyenne – Facebook
Godfather’s Pizza Cheyenne, Cheyenne. 1463 likes · 3 talking about this · 1069 were here. We’ve been serving A Pizza You Can’t Refuse since 1973 with…
Cheyenne’s Godfather’s Pizza to close permanently after 40 years
Godfather’s Pizza announced Thursday it will permanently close its 5719 Yellowstone Road location Jan. 31. The decision follows the October 2025 …
Reviews
callie
genuinely disgusted almost half of the stuff in the salad bar is past their serving date and i didn’t see it because u didn’t wear my glasses today. but my boyfriend saw it AFTER i ate my salad and he made me another one. also like half of the pizzas were old on the buffet too and the monkey bread was raw and had dough in the center pls contact me so i can get a refund because why would you think it’s okay to serve this ?
… moreBecky K
Had lunch there and ordered 2 pizzas for pickup later that day. I ordered a super supreme taco with toppings on the side as it had to travel 70 miles and even though my husband isn’t allergic to raw tomatoes, I am highly allergic to them. When I picked up the pizzas, the super supreme taco had all the toppings on the pizza. BIG DISAPPOINTMENT as I now have no pizza to eat and my husband has to eat 2 large pizzas before they spoil. No discount was given for the huge error. I have ordered this pizza this way for a long time. This particular order is under my phone number on their computer.
… moreEducated Dude2021
We ordered 3 large pizzas, taco pie, cheese, and all meat-combo. We also ordered a mediam cheese sticks, 2 orderers of cheese garlic bread, 3 small deserts oreo, cherry, and blue berry. He had forgot the oreo on our order so he put one through, It was getting late so we were about to leave when the other girl working there had bring one ou6t and she said the upgraded it to anmedium for making us wait.
THINGS HAPPEN but they made it right!
THIS is EXACLY what they should do!
YOU are (((A_OK)) !!!
Everything was GREAT, thanks much. That oreo was SUPER GOOD. I would have it again this month!
… moreTHINGS HAPPEN but they made it right!
THIS is EXACLY what they should do!
YOU are (((A_OK)) !!!
Everything was GREAT, thanks much. That oreo was SUPER GOOD. I would have it again this month!
Jake Camargo
Great local pizza place. Amazing tasting pizza. Their dessert cinnamon pizza is my favorite for sure. The service has always been good when I went. It’s a great place for a family get-together as well. I’ve always liked the little gaming area they got. It definitely keeps kids and even adults entertained while waiting for the food or after the meal. I don’t think this place gets it proper due because it gets overshadowed by the bigger mainstream pizza places in town. I just have to make it a point to dine here more often.
… moreCadillac Chad
Haven’t had in years. Food was amazing. Wish staff was a little more fun. But food just stands out
… moreR ??
I heard this place was closing and while it deeply saddens me, I have so many amazing memories from this place. I wish I could upload the pictures from all the family meetups where everyone came from different states just to eat her because it was our grandfathers favorite place. Thank you, Godfather’s, for giving us a place to rejoin with our loved ones, and I’ll keep a special place in my heart for you.
… moreJake from Real Estate
Was a tradition to come here with the family during Cheyenne Frontier Days and get the taco pizza! Only thing missing is the salad bar – no longer available at night…too bad was good! Pizza is yummy.
… moreAvatar Productions
Godfather Pizza
Is the Best
Friendly welcoming staff that aren’t overbearing
Their pizza is the Prefect blend of flavors and chewy crunch
Pizza size cheese bread! And orders of crunchy tater wedges fresh crisp salad
Arcade games and merch on site!
Awesome lunch buffet
Fantastic overall
5 out of 5
… moreIs the Best
Friendly welcoming staff that aren’t overbearing
Their pizza is the Prefect blend of flavors and chewy crunch
Pizza size cheese bread! And orders of crunchy tater wedges fresh crisp salad
Arcade games and merch on site!
Awesome lunch buffet
Fantastic overall
5 out of 5
Sabrina Schossow
I have incredibly great service every time I have been here. I drive 90 miles just to get this pizza! 10/10 recommend!
… moreFran Bender
Really good pizza. Fun atmosphere. Helpful and friendly staff. There was a birthday party going on when we were there so there’s that too. Overall a fabulous establishment
… more