Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Chain eatery specializing in thick-crust pizzas, also offering sides & desserts.
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 624 US-30, Carroll, IA 51401
Phone: (712) 792-5470
Website: http://godfathers.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Godfather’s Pizza: Home
It’s not just pizza, it’s a meal! Our pies are piled high with quality ingredients and topped with heaping layers of perfectly melted cheese, so you enjoy a …
Godfather’s Pizza – Carroll IA – Facebook
Get a Large Cheese Pizza with Breadsticks for $17.99 Get just the Large Cheese Pie for $12.99 And a Large Veggie Pie with a Small Cheesesticks is just $25.99 …
Godfather’s Pizza-Carroll, IA
Taco Sauce, Beef, Black Olives, Lettuce, Onions, Tomatoes, Sour Cream, Cheddar & Mozzarella Cheese, Extra Cheddar. Includes 1 Taco packet per slice. $17.79 – …
Reviews
Jessica Arriaga
This place is partial self service. You order and pay at the counter. Your pizza is brought to you but you gather your plates, utensils, and drinks.
I had their taco pizza on thin crust and it was good.
I would come here again to try their other pies.
… moreI had their taco pizza on thin crust and it was good.
I would come here again to try their other pies.
Todd Eichmann
Once upon a time, we had Godfather’s Pizza in Minnesota. That was 15 years ago. Sure, we’ve come across a few gas stations where Godfather’s had a store, it wasn’t the same. So when we saw that Caroll had a Godfather’s Pizza restaurant – and it was dine-in – we were thrilled. And it was just like we remembered, with a crispy, buttery crust and loaded with toppings. It’s still the best pizza ever. And in the course of chatting with the staff, we learned they make the pizza dough by hand and the store was bought from the original owners of 40 years by three employees who wanted to keep this restaurant around. We’re completely happy they did!
… moreCat K
Is a bit prices for only 3 pizzas and 1 salad was over $80 for three people. BUT the atmosphere and food make up for that instantly. The pizza was so flavorful and cooked to perfection. Crust was crispy and great. Salad bar was fresh and I LOVE that the eggs were dices to perfect pieces. The games there are good for limited option. The lady who assisted us was super nice. Wish I could remember her name. But smiling and positive attitude. Honestly recommend for everyone to try. And 10/10
… moreTammie
We were so excited to find a dine in Godfather’s Pizza! The food and service were amazing and brought back so many wonderful memories for us. Looking forward to visiting again!
… moreChristine H
It is like stepping into an older Godfathers Pizza. Salad bar is simple and just salad and a few veggies. Pizza is great, hot and comes out to table fast. Staff were very nice and explained things.
… moreMike Salati
Lunch after church with friends. Pizza was excellent! Service prompt and friendly! Thank you!
… moreScooter51301 Anderson
Just got back from my honeymoon and we decided to have some godfather’s for pizza. We ordered two small taco pizza but as a good hostess and sales person at the counter so it should’ve said it would be cheaper if you go with a large and you’ll get more food. I know that because I used to work at a godfather‘s, but we changed it to a large without her saying anything then we order soda bar, but we were very, very disappointed on the service by her the cashier person. She was very rude towards us, throwing the pizza onto our table lost some of the lettuce and tomato off the pizza. Then when we asked for a home box, she just throws the box right at My wife, we will not go back to this place when she is working
… moreCindy Poggie
Nice and clean. Had salad bar and mini pizzas. Delicious!
… moreLezlie Ramsey
Nice little pizzeria serving the famous Godfather’s pizzas! We did pick up and we’re very happy with the thin crust and the golden (pan style) crust as well as the toppings- tasty! Cashier was really pleasant and out pizzas were hot when we picked them up. Plenty of parking in their lot.
… morekrystal zier
The first time I ordered a medium pizza with the beat the clock deal I asked for 1/2 olives 1/2 cheese, got home it was all olives no big deal, but it had barely any cheese like not enough to cover the dough/sauce. I thought maybe it was just that one time, cooks having an off night, it happens. Ordered again this last Wednesday 1/2 cheese 1/2 pepperoni. Got home it was 1/2 beef 1/2 pepperoni, the beef again I didn’t mind and in hindsight I did think they were saying cheese weird so I probably should have confirmed but again hardly any cheese on it. And this time I did thin crust thinking maybe there is a difference but no this time again hardly any cheese and it wasn’t burnt but it over cooked to where the cheese isn’t cheesy anymore, just really cooked to the color of brown. Frustrating. I have not ordered from them
When it’s not beat the clock deal so maybe the the regular priced pizzas are better and they skimp on the discounted ones idk but if that’s the case maybe not do discounts if you’re just going skimp on ingredient?
… moreWhen it’s not beat the clock deal so maybe the the regular priced pizzas are better and they skimp on the discounted ones idk but if that’s the case maybe not do discounts if you’re just going skimp on ingredient?