Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 217 Washington St, Menasha, WI 54952
Phone: (920) 840-1333
Website: https://www.glassnickelpizza.com/location/neenah-menasha/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Neenah – Menasha | Hours + Location – Glass Nickel Pizza
Menasha, WI 54952 · (920) 840-1333. Due to weather conditions, we are CLOSED Monday, March 16th. Thank you for your understanding. Stay safe, Neenah-Menasha!
Menasha Menus | Glass Nickel Pizza Co
Glass Nickel Pizza – Award Winning Pizza, Salads, Subs, Pasta, & more! Located in Wisconsin … Stay safe, Neenah-Menasha! Specialty Pizzas; Build Your Own Pizza …
Glass Nickel Pizza Co Menu and Online Ordering
From a late night craving to a large event, we’ve got you covered! Find us in Appleton, Brookfield, Fitchburg, Green Bay, Madison, Neenah/Menasha, Sun Prairie, …
Last Updates
Reviews
Ryan Rothe
Ordered a medium cheese, large cordon bleu and nickel nuggets for delivery. With tip came to almost 65 bucks. Pizza was lukewarm, cordon bleu pizza had no ham. Called and got a credit for our next order but for what we paid and the quality of food I don’t know the next time we’d order again.
… moreJennifer Mueller
Super easy to order online for delivery next day. The driver was super friendly and gracious. And the pizzas were delish!
… moreBreanna Plach
Pretty good. But a bit pricey. Paid $25 for a 14″ pepperoni and sausage pizza, and a can of Pepsi to be delivered with a 3.00 tip. Website is a bit tricky to navigate to order on mobile. Pizza was here in about an hour from when I ordered. Delivery instructions were followed which is always nice. Next time I’d be willing to order again with coupons which I didn’t see until after I ordered. So if you’re going to order, check the coupons first 🙂 overall, it was pretty good pizza. Well made.
… moreGenevieve Pell
Moving from Madison 11yrs ago, we were thrilled when Glass Nickel opened in Appleton. Awesome food. Always delicious.
… moreLeetaMaybe
Edited to change from 1 star to 5. Now, the food is delivered fast, fresh, well-made, and 100% right-side-up. We’ve had the same young lady as our delivery driver the past few times, and the delivery is consistently excellent now!
Just kidding! Edited again because we got another crumpled pizza. Note the lack of grease stains on the empty side; this was stored vertically IMMEDIATELY after being cut. Don’t order from here unless you want a pizza taco.
… moreJust kidding! Edited again because we got another crumpled pizza. Note the lack of grease stains on the empty side; this was stored vertically IMMEDIATELY after being cut. Don’t order from here unless you want a pizza taco.
Brian Boettcher
Everytime we order from here, the food is hot and delicious, the service is fast, and the person who takes our order is always friendly and courteous. Thank you Glass Nickel of Neenah/Menasha!!!!!
… moreLaura Garcia
every time my husband buys from there when I tell you the food never disappoints delicious food great service.love love love
… moremitchell deniswicz
Heard great things about glass nickel pizza so thought we’d give it a try. Ordered a taco pizza from there, unfortunately it did not come with any sauce actually ON the pizza. Made the pizza very hard to eat, and was not tasteful at all.
Also not very good quality customer service either.
… moreAlso not very good quality customer service either.
cory Kraft
Poor management. Ordered delivery 6 day’s ago and was told 35-45 minutes after a 1 hour and 10 minutes I called and asked where my food was and was told they had the wrong address and phone number and told me they would remake my pizza and deliver it. When I received the pizza it was ice cold. Called management the next and was told I would receive a total refund when they talk to the general manager. Have yet to hear from them after multiple calls asking to speak to the manager and them telling me they will be in the next day and will call me back. Definitely will not be spending anymore money at this location.
… more