Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
A Madison pizza treasure serving unique, award winning pies with renowned salads, subs, homemade lasagna, pasta and more. Offering delivery, carryout, catering and dine-in. Dedicated to local ingredients, sustainable practices and community service. Join us for Glass Nickel Pizza. In Pizza We Trust®!
Informal, eco-minded chain serving creative pizzas & classic pastas, plus wings, fish & shrimp.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5003 University Ave, Madison, WI 53705
Phone: (608) 218-9000
Website: https://glassnickelpizza.com/location/madison-west/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Madison West | Hours + Location – Glass Nickel Pizza
Informal, eco-minded chain serving creative pizzas & classic pastas, plus wings, salads, and more..
Madison West Menus | Glass Nickel Pizza Co
Glass Nickel Pizza – Award Winning Pizza, Salads, Subs, Pasta, & more! Located in Wisconsin.
Glass Nickel Pizza Co Menu and Online Ordering
Order online, delivery, lunch, late night or catering! 22 years of award winning pizza, salads, subs, wings, pasta, and more!
Last Updates
Reviews
stacylaughs
5 stars for the lunch special (one topping pizza and drink).
I also ordered a cobb salad that was half cheddar cheese, but I liked it because it really felt like I was in Wisconsin haha
… moreI also ordered a cobb salad that was half cheddar cheese, but I liked it because it really felt like I was in Wisconsin haha
Scott Kimsey
Look. It’s a small joint with alot of Togo action, but we sat down, ate pizza and drank free refills on pop. The pizza is definitely better than your average pie place. Crust is good, larges are large! Toppings are generous! Depend on how you like it might ask for extra sauce or maybe extra cheese, but our table devoured it. I think its great pizza and I feel like the University small store might be better pizza than the Atwood store but maybe its just the type. The deluxe was solid and we enjoyed the boris k. The ladies at the counter were super nice. We will be back. Glass Nickel or nothing from now on.
… moreViridiana Reyes
We received our pizza quite a bit burnt, but when we called, they immediately offered a refund or to remake it and deliver it for free, no hesitation at all. We really appreciated how quickly and kindly they handled the situation. Great customer service like that definitely keeps us coming back. Thank you!
… moreBee Xiong
Just tried their pizza for the first time after my friend’s kept insisting it was really good. I can now say that I will probably purchase more pizzas from here. Delicious pizza, cheese was great and pepperoni was evenly topped on the pizza. 10/10 nice texture, flavor and generously topped with cheese and pepperoni.
… moreWhole
I wouldn’t consider this restaurant a sit-down restaurant, it was obviously made to be more of a takeout restaurant but they were very kind and accommodating, even admitting that dine in wasn’t the most popular option. It was delicious, portions are large, pictured is a medium Hawaiian-Pie-O pizza which was larger than we expected. My group members were also shocked by how massive the salads were! They pack a large in a small box. It was a pleasure to visit here and I would highly recommend.
… moreAlicia Ramirez
GNP on University goes above and beyond to make great food and create a welcoming environment for staff and customers! Really great people and food at this location. My favorite pizza is their pizza of the month which is the special sauce pizza but ask for the pickles on top after it’s cooked-you’ll thank me later!
… moreHeather Sims
While the pizza was good enough, it would have been considerably better if it had been hot vs cold. I definitely will think twice about ordering again for delivery because of the cold food. It may have been due to the email I got about it being started at 2:53 pm and the driver arrived at about 3:50 (within the delivery estimate) I know drivers are required to take multiple orders at once and I get that preparation takes time too. Like I said, I would have preferred a hot or at least not cold pizza, but the pizza tasted like it would have been great as a hot pizza.
… moreMatthew Zander
The food is pretty good for the most part, however I ordered garlic breadsticks expecting garlic breadsticks. There’s no mention of any sort of parmesan topping them, but there was definitely cheese on them. They have all kinds of cheese breads and such, so I was definitely expecting the garlic breadsticks to JUST have garlic and maybe butter. My girlfriend wanted pizza, and I’m not a fan of cheese, and I just wanted something small to eat. Looking back at the website, there’s a total lack of any allergen information or detailed ingredient list for most of the menu. A more detailed description of menu items seems necessary for lots of the menu items.
… moreDanKrisTeddyKillianThorne Powers
Food seems to have gone *way* downhill. Picked up a larger order (6-7 pizzas with varying crust thicknesses) for a family party (something we have done twice before in past). These pizzas were pretty unappetizing and greasy, even the thin crust was floppy with it. Flavor was mediocre, not the freshness and great flavors we have experienced in the past. We will not be back. Service was fine, was ready when we arrived at appointed time. We did not dine in to have any opinion on atmosphere.
… moreDaniel Jakubczak
Haven’t eaten in yet but the pickup was fast and the food was hot. I liked the posters for the specialty pizzas, they definitely make me want to try them all.
… more