Brookfield’s finest pizza delivery and carryout serving 11 years of unique, award winning pies with renowned salads, subs, homemade lasagna, pasta and more. We have dine-in and cater as well! Dedicated to local ingredients, sustainable practices and community service. Call us for Glass Nickel Pizza. In Pizza We Trust®!
Informal, eco-minded chain serving creative pizzas & classic pastas, plus wings, fish & shrimp.
Sabrina Bryan
I’ve been getting pizza from Glass Nickel Pizza Co. since I was pregnant with my son, and let me tell you, the pizza hits the same every single time! The quality, the flavor, the consistency… always on point.
I don’t even live in the area anymore, but I still make a 30–40 minute drive just to get it. That says a lot!
The customer service is always friendly and welcoming, and on my birthday they even gave me a free pizza. I truly appreciate companies that take care of their customers and make you feel valued.
Forever a loyal customer!
… moreBreeAnn Bowman
I had such a great experience here! From the moment we walked in, the customer service was absolutely top tier. The staff was friendly, welcoming, and genuinely made us feel valued the entire time.
The food was amazing, fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. You can really tell they care about quality. Every bite was worth it! My favorite thing we ordered was the Nickel Nuggets and will definitely be ordering them again!
On top of that, the atmosphere was great. It was clean, comfortable, and had a vibe that made you want to stay and enjoy your time.
Definitely one of the best pizza spots I’ve been to. I’ll 100% be coming back!
… moreMark Clementi
Just a quick shout out to all the hard working folks at Glass Nickel in Brookfield. I have been ordering from them for many years. The food is always delicious. It’s always hot, and always on time, and my order is always correct. They also have gluten free pizza, and my daughter in law is very happy about that. In this day and age where many places can’t get it right, Glass Nickel in Brookfield does.
… moreSara Waldner
Ordered delivery for a girls night. We ordered the specialty of the month which was the Special Sauce. Tasted just like a Big Mac!! We also got some salads and chicken strips. Absolutely worth it! The delivery driver was extremely friendly and called letting me know that she would be there within five minutes. It was really easy to order over the phone and the staff was very pleasant and took time to answer my questions about my order.
I will absolutely be ordering more from Glass Nickel in Brookfield again! Definitely recommend!!
… moreJustin
Brother and I wanted to try a new pizza place so we decided to try here. Saw all the rave reviews and had high hopes that we finally found a solid pizza place. The pizza arrived promptly and it looked good so we were stoked. We got a 16 inch hand tossed pepperoni with black olives. Unfortunately the good reviews and good looks didn’t align with what we got. Flavor across the board was mid. Lacking in flavor and depth anywhere. The only thing above mid I could give it was the texture of the dough. The sauce did have some flavor but still wouldn’t rate it above just mid. Dough and toppings next to no flavor mid. Out of 5 stars I’d give it a 2.5. On Dave Portnoy’s pizza scale I’d say its around a 6.5.
… moreKaci Smith
It just wasn’t good. We ordered wings, fries, and onion rings which we assumed would be a little soggy given we worded for delivery, but they were really just mush by the time we got it. Tried to put them in the over, bit that didn’t help much. The fries and wings just tasted old and not good. The cheese pizza was okay. Not much flavor to the sauce. We did get a piece of cake, too. Was okay. By the time we got it, it was warm and it was a really small piece. Wouldn’t have cared about size, but $8.50 was way too much for what was delivered. Like I said…it just wasn’t good. Probably will avoid ordering again.
… moreTammy “Lil’ Marzipan” B
Some of the best pizzas in the city.
I love that you can get half and half specialty pizzas for those days when you’re just indecisive or greedy.
We’ve tried the cheeseasaurus, macaroni and cheese, veggie, and spinach garlic bread.
Everything was absolutely delicious!
… moreJulie Fliss
We order from Glass Nickel every week as part of our family night. We love it and the delivery drivers are so reliable and friendly!!
… moreMatt
Ordered delivery for a large cracker crust and it did not disappoint! Great amount of sausage and was plump and flavorful. Delivery driver was great. He was early greeted me with a smile and thanked me for my order. Will order in the future. Ordered again in December and added pictures for breaded mushrooms, portabella Legosi, and acropolis salad and added pictures, order arrived within 35 minutes no complaints very good.
… moreJames Madrich
I have been a customer of Glass Nickel Pizza for many years. Ryan and his staff are very efficient and do check to make sure the orders are right before the customer or delivery driver leaves the premises. The food is of excellent quality and made to order. The staff is very friendly and helpful. If there is a problem with an order the management team will do all they can to resolve the situation.
… more