Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Step into a world of timeless tradition at Giuseppi’s Pizzeria, where the rich history of a family recipe comes alive. Since 1951, we have been crafting authentic pizzas, each made with a passion for quality and a commitment to flavor. Giuseppi’s is a true Milwaukee staple, offering a taste of classic Italian-American cuisine. Join us at our New Berlin location and experience the legacy that has been satisfying cravings for decades.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 14185 W Greenfield Ave, New Berlin, WI 53151
Phone: (262) 641-5490
Website: http://giuseppispizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: giuseppispizzeria.com
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Giuseppis Pizzeria: Best pizza in New Berlin, WI | Giuseppi’s …
Giuseppi’s Pizzeria in New Berlin serves authentic pizza, pasta, and Italian favorites. Family-owned restaurant with dine-in, takeout, and delivery.
Giuseppi’s Pizzeria – New Berlin, WI – 14185 W Greenfield Ave …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Giuseppi’s Pizzeria in New Berlin, WI. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Giuseppi’s Pizzeria – 14185 W Greenfield Ave, New Berlin, WI 53151
Order online at one of the best restaurants in New Berlin, WI! Giuseppi’s Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
Reviews
Kathleen Curiale
This is an amazing hidden secret. I just love everything on their menu. It’s so amazing. The pizza arrives pipe and hot. The ingredients are authentic and generous and it’s the best meatball sandwich I’ve ever had in my life and Pizza go check it out. You won’t be sorry.
… moreDana Smith
I’m sorry because I don’t like to post negativity but this pizza was awful. We got a large pepperoni with meatballs for 3 of us. All 3 of us thought it tasted off. From the first bite it tasted bad. There was hardly any sauce, burnt crust and space on toppings but it was the flavor that turned us off. We are from Rockford, Il where we have numerous great pizza places. Sorry but not a fan
… moreDan D
Order pizzas here for my kids birthday party. Staff was very friendly and helpful with my questions. Pizza was ready on time. Several kids and their parents complimented how great the pizza was and asked where it was from. Pizza was crispy and had great flavor. Definitely will order here again!
… moreQuincy Moore
I had higher expectations based on the reviews, however my pizza was just eh. Not bad priced, the sausage is good. Lacking alot of flavor in the sauce and crust, the most important part of a good pie. Owner seems like a good guy.
… moreSentinel Nation
I ordered two pizzas for dinner this evening. We’re in town because my mother is in the hospital, and she recommended we try this place, she even gave me the phone number from her contacts, which she had saved on her phone. We ordered a Giuseppi Special and a Pepperoni with extra toppings.
When I arrived to pick up the order, the Pepperoni had just come out of the oven, but the Giuseppi Special was still baking. I watched the staff member open the oven and inspect and rotate it, and from the looks of it (which I clearly while saw standing at the counter) the pizza still had a ways to go. I paid at the counter, and the woman there told me we were still waiting on the second pizza… I even said, “take your time,” expecting like a 10 minute wait.
To my surprise, after only 2–3 minutes, she called out that the pizza was ready. I was happy to have a short wait, until we got home.
The Pepperoni looked great and was cooked nicely. The Giuseppi Special, however, was SEVERELY undercooked. The dough was pale, raw, and floppy… more like a wet flabby noodle than a pizza crust. All the sloppy toppings had slid to one side of the gooey base. Trying to pick up a slice was pointless; everything just slid off into puddle of goo on your plate, leaving a square of raw dough in your hand. We each took one bite and threw it in the trash. Total waste of time, money, and food. Whole pizza… in the garbage.
Thankfully, we had the second pizza, but even that left us disappointed. It looked great, but had almost no flavor. I genuinely wondered if it even had sauce, it was that bland. I told my wife it felt like eating pizza with a head cold… you can chew it, but you can’t taste anything.
I’m sure this place can make great pizzas when the effort is there, but when the effort and care aren’t, the result is pretty awful. This was the worst pizza experience I’ve ever had… I mean they screwed up their “Giuseppi Special” pizza… of all the stuff you should nail on your own menu, the “Giuseppi Special” should be high on that list. Honestly, I’d take a frozen pizza or even a Kwik Trip take-and-bake over this any day.
… moreWhen I arrived to pick up the order, the Pepperoni had just come out of the oven, but the Giuseppi Special was still baking. I watched the staff member open the oven and inspect and rotate it, and from the looks of it (which I clearly while saw standing at the counter) the pizza still had a ways to go. I paid at the counter, and the woman there told me we were still waiting on the second pizza… I even said, “take your time,” expecting like a 10 minute wait.
To my surprise, after only 2–3 minutes, she called out that the pizza was ready. I was happy to have a short wait, until we got home.
The Pepperoni looked great and was cooked nicely. The Giuseppi Special, however, was SEVERELY undercooked. The dough was pale, raw, and floppy… more like a wet flabby noodle than a pizza crust. All the sloppy toppings had slid to one side of the gooey base. Trying to pick up a slice was pointless; everything just slid off into puddle of goo on your plate, leaving a square of raw dough in your hand. We each took one bite and threw it in the trash. Total waste of time, money, and food. Whole pizza… in the garbage.
Thankfully, we had the second pizza, but even that left us disappointed. It looked great, but had almost no flavor. I genuinely wondered if it even had sauce, it was that bland. I told my wife it felt like eating pizza with a head cold… you can chew it, but you can’t taste anything.
I’m sure this place can make great pizzas when the effort is there, but when the effort and care aren’t, the result is pretty awful. This was the worst pizza experience I’ve ever had… I mean they screwed up their “Giuseppi Special” pizza… of all the stuff you should nail on your own menu, the “Giuseppi Special” should be high on that list. Honestly, I’d take a frozen pizza or even a Kwik Trip take-and-bake over this any day.
Jessica Reynolds
I have gotten taken twice and will never order there again. The first time both of my pizzas were undercooked with raw dough. This last time I became violently ill with stomach cramps, diarrhea and chills. They need to pay attention to the quality of their food and get a pizza cook that knows when the pizza is actually cooked.
… moreRachael Hardy
Tried for the first time tonight. Won’t be trying again. Garlic bread was soggy, we had to put it in the air fryer to make it edible. Margherita pizza tasted like tomato paste no flavor whatsoever. Pepperoni pizza was decent.
… moreRon Zalewski
Excellent “Milwaukee Style” pizza that was shared by my family. Thin crust with a perfect crunch on the outside and on the inside, the crust was thin but strong enough to hold onto a generous serving of toppings. I had the Supreme and recommend it. At $27 for the large, it was reasonable.
Only a pick-up counter.
… moreOnly a pick-up counter.
Kurt Hardly
Pizza was great. We are from out of town and went for dinner. Its carry our/delivery only. We were disappointed, but order 2 pies to go. Ate the back at our hotel. Really glad we placed the order. Excellent pizza.
… moreWeebl Turk
Stopped in to grab a pizza after giving up on finding a decent pizza in the area. Have tried everywhere else in the area like Glass Nickel, Marcos, Jets. Alphonsos, etc, and all were disappointing, to say the least. This place brings back memories of the old pizzerias rather than all of the corporate, cookie cutter places with bad crust. Price was reasonable and the service was great. Will definitely be getting pizza from here again in the future.
… more