Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Giovanni’s has been around for over 35 years. It is well known and back even better with premium quality toppings for all the pizza subs with number one rated Premium Cheese Grande. We’re also introducing new stuff like 1/4 lb All Beef Hot dogs and Chicken and Steak Quesadillas. All with competitive prices. We will be offering and honoring 10% off to all veteran’s, men in blue, and all first responders year around.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 134 Eagle School Rd, Martinsburg, WV 25404
Phone: (304) 263-6995
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Giovanni’s New York Pizza | Martinsburg WV – Facebook
Giovanni’s New York Pizza, Martinsburg. 1256 likes · 476 were here. Pick-up, delivery or dine-in.
Giovanni’s New York Pizza Delivery Menu – Martinsburg – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Giovanni’s New York Pizza in Martinsburg! View Giovanni’s New York Pizza’s March 2026 deals and menus.
Order Giovanni’s New York Pizza | Martinsburg – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Giovanni’s New York Pizza at 134 Eagle School Road in Martinsburg. Order online and track your order live.
Reviews
Mike Dougherty
This place is a favorite for whenever I’m visiting family in Martinsburg. The pizza never disappoints and punches way over its weight. Definitely seems to use quality ingredients for the pizza and I think the owner told me he even uses Grande brand cheese which is some of the best. Also the steak and cheese has always been solid, love their rolls and they don’t skimp you on the steak.
… moreHarrison Nelms
First time here and dig the TMNT and Coke theme, feels very classically American. They weren’t happy with how my pizza cooked ( I was very happy with it, so delicious!) so I get to take this one home. Sweet tea here is superb and the hot dogs were loved by my kids, and my wife polished off her meatball sub. Everything we got we loved and we were treated extremely well!
… morePaige Shane
The staff here were the absolute nicest — truly went above and beyond. One of the ladies even gave my daughter eight quarters so she could get something from the gumball machines, which completely made her day. The food was great, but the customer service is what really stood out. It’s rare to find a place where people genuinely care like that. We will definitely be back!
… moreKayla Martin
I haven’t been here in about 20 years. It was a family favorite when I was growing up, so today I decided to take our kids in and carry on the tradition. Everything was amazing, and even better than I remember. The woman working was so sweet. She noticed me giving the kids quarters for the gumball machine, and when I ran out, she came over and gave me $5 in quarters to give to the kids. An all around great experience, and we will be back soon!
… moreJR “Wyldman” Wyldman
Always good , very friendly, respectful and food never disappoints. Weve become a regular customer now and they appreciate that…veteran owned and applies discount to the order.
… moreJeff Reynolds
Overall I’d say it’s unremarkable. I’ve rated pizza in SC, CT, MD, etc, and I was extremely underwhelmed here.
I ordered this months ago, but noticed that the owner had an excuse for every poor review. I do appreciate his willingness to try and rectify a bad review.
I travel for work and eat pizza from Connecticut to Florida. Id give a dominos pizza 2.5/5. It satisfies, fills you up and the price isn’t bad for the price.
This pizza I requested well done. Arrived at the pick up time to find that they hadn’t started the pizza. They made several comments through out that they had to run the pizza longer since it was requested well done. Prior to removing it from the oven, the gentleman said he had to pull it or it’d be burnt up on the bottom.
Brought it home, about 5 mins drive off of Queen St. and the dough was still undercooked, under carriage was cooked well done and had a nice crust (lacked any real flavor), cheese hadn’t even really cooked through and just mostly released a lot of grease. I suspect the oven wasn’t to temp and they tried to heat it up faster which caused the bottom to crust up faster.
Atmosphere was fine, was the only customer and the place was kid friendly as they had kids there drawing. The gentleman stepped past the counter a time or two and spoke with them which was great to see.
Service I left at 5/5 as I wasn’t dining in. Wish it had a N/A.
Wasn’t expecting New York style pizza, but also would’ve expected a touch more pepperoni, evenly well done pizza, and just more flavor in general for the price point. I hope that I was an exception to the norm, as this was highly unremarkable.
… moreI ordered this months ago, but noticed that the owner had an excuse for every poor review. I do appreciate his willingness to try and rectify a bad review.
I travel for work and eat pizza from Connecticut to Florida. Id give a dominos pizza 2.5/5. It satisfies, fills you up and the price isn’t bad for the price.
This pizza I requested well done. Arrived at the pick up time to find that they hadn’t started the pizza. They made several comments through out that they had to run the pizza longer since it was requested well done. Prior to removing it from the oven, the gentleman said he had to pull it or it’d be burnt up on the bottom.
Brought it home, about 5 mins drive off of Queen St. and the dough was still undercooked, under carriage was cooked well done and had a nice crust (lacked any real flavor), cheese hadn’t even really cooked through and just mostly released a lot of grease. I suspect the oven wasn’t to temp and they tried to heat it up faster which caused the bottom to crust up faster.
Atmosphere was fine, was the only customer and the place was kid friendly as they had kids there drawing. The gentleman stepped past the counter a time or two and spoke with them which was great to see.
Service I left at 5/5 as I wasn’t dining in. Wish it had a N/A.
Wasn’t expecting New York style pizza, but also would’ve expected a touch more pepperoni, evenly well done pizza, and just more flavor in general for the price point. I hope that I was an exception to the norm, as this was highly unremarkable.
Lori Breeden
On a whim, a friend and I came in for a slice. I told my husband about it as soon as I got home and we went a couple days later to prove to him just how good this pizza is. The perfectly crisp fold, the cheese pull, the authentic sauce, it’s truly the best pizza around! Had the chance to talk to the owner and his passion for perfection is real!! Looking forward to our next visit for the steak and cheese and calzone!! Take all my monies!!
… moreJosh Flesher
I was a long time customer and really loved coming here, but now it seems they dont care about the business anymore, anytime ive tried to call during business hours they never awnser. Shame to see such a decline on a place I loved coming to. Either they dont awnser the phone, or they close not sure what happened in the last few months
… moreLady Jays Catering Service, LLC
I ordered the Meatlovers Cauliflower Crust Pizza and it is the BEST pizza I’ve ever had! OH MY GOODNESS! So so good, didn’t spike my blood sugar, super fresh and super delicious! So happy to have found a place where I can enjoy pizza while being diabetic! Thank you so much, also my mom raves about your chicken cheesesteak sub! We will definitely be back! God bless and I wish you a successful and prosperous 2024!
… moreOwryen Interiors
Found this place randomly while we had a one night layover on a trip. Got the order in just before closing and the pie was delicious. Certainly couldn’t beat it for the price and convenience.
… more