Social Profile: 
… View more
Casual, family-owned eatery serving wood-fired pizzas, hearty pastas & a selection of wines.
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Gerardo’s closes doors after 18 years | Business | paysonroundup.com
The walls of Gerardo’s Firewood Café are lined with beloved family pictures … Payson, AZ 85541. Phone: 928-474-5251. Email: classads …
Gerardo’s Firewood Cafe (@gerardosfirewoodcafe) – Facebook
Gerardo’s Firewood Cafe. 1201 likes. Gerardo Moceri worked in restaurants all over Italy and has brought what he learned to Payson. His use of organic…
Gerardo’s Pizzeria
Our family-owned pizzeria and cucina in the heart of beautiful Sedona, Arizona. Since 2016, we’ve been proud to serve wood-fired pizzas and Italian-inspired …
Reviews
Phia Velasquez
I think is one of local restaurant here in payson. …
The ambiance was solemn and very clean. …
The food is great specially the pizza. … Price is also good. …
We had a great dinner. …
… moreThe ambiance was solemn and very clean. …
The food is great specially the pizza. … Price is also good. …
We had a great dinner. …
Mike Richardson
Some of the best Italian food I’ve ever had, and I come from a line of Italian restaurateurs. Had the ravioli, lasagna and Bianca pizza with artichoke hearts. I can’t say enough about the staff, we’ve had the pleasure of being waited on by Elizabeth and Nicki. We were lucky enough to eat at both locations, Sedona and Payson and both were equally superb.
… morecandy weinberg
The food was amazing! I don’t like fish and had a bite of my husband’s salmon and I loved it! Great atmosphere and the waitress was wonderful! It was a little expensive but worth it!! I will definitely be going back!
… moreHannah Ashby
Awesome family Italian place. The Italian Mac is pictured below – super cheesy and absolutely delicious. I only wish straws didn’t automatically come in the drinks (to reduce plastic waste) and that the to – go boxes weren’t Styrofoam (something that could be recycled instead).
… moreCecilia Labariega
Absolutely love this place and will be going back. I think my significant other and I got the most expensive plates they were serving that evening because our tab was over $100 with one appetizer, two entrees, and 2 glasses of wine. So if you are price concise there are more affordable things to order. The food was completely worth it. No complaints.
… moreRustic Nation Outfitters
My husband and I decided to give this place a try for lunch today; and we both were extremely pleased with our meals. I had the Smoked Bacon Macaroni, and my goodness was it delicious! My husband had the Eggplant Parmesan and said it was the best he’d ever had. The lunch portions were dinner sized, in my opinion…. However, we’re not complaining because we have leftovers for tomorrow. The prices were decent and the atmosphere was enjoyable. When it cools off a bit more we will enjoy ourselves out on their patio dinning area.
… moreDanielle Lloyd
Really lovely ownership and very friendly staff. The food has never disappointed– but you’ve got to be in the mood for stodgy, saucy food– as that’s what you’ll get! The lobster mac and cheese is a dream. Environment is also quite nice and prices are decent. This place is usually busy, which I take as a good sign.
… moreOscar Cortez
My family and I went here during a trip to Payson. When I walked in what first impressed me was how clean the dinning area and bathrooms were.
The staff was courteous and helpful. The owners wife talked with us and made us feel welcome.
We had mac & cheese, chicken fettuccine, meat lovers pizza and an appetizer. Great tasting food. A little to much butter but overall good. This is one place you don’t want to pass up.
… moreThe staff was courteous and helpful. The owners wife talked with us and made us feel welcome.
We had mac & cheese, chicken fettuccine, meat lovers pizza and an appetizer. Great tasting food. A little to much butter but overall good. This is one place you don’t want to pass up.
kelsey cooper
There was practically a line at the door when we showed up for lunch on Sunday (opens at 12 not 11 fyi), and it’s because this place is Amazing. Dinner rolls are hot and fresh, the spicy calamari is not very spicy but still delicious and tender, and the bruchetta was also very fresh and flavorful. The pizza was good, and again the toppings were fresh. The portions are rather large, and it was all very good.
… moreMarla Hackett
Service is wonderful and the lasagna was pretty good although theres a lot of wine flavor in the sauce and no veggies in this dish. The menu is limited and the place shows its age. I suggest a small side salad be served with a heavy dish like the lasagna or veggies and dip.
… more