Suga Ransom
Omg this place is the bomb the best Sicilian pizza the best Sicilian sauce you ever tasted in your life. I love the meatballs. The people are friendly the managers the owner I got a gallon of marinara Sicilian sauce the pizza taste delicious. The wings are delicious. Everything is homemade fresh and from Sicily Italy I will never go nowhere else to eat again for Sicilian food. I love this place. It’s my first time coming here. I was driving past it. It’s very clean they’re very generous kind and friendly. They even have diet A&W soda and no Restaurant has that I love this place. I definitely will be back.
… moreKent Wannebo
Nobody does pizza like Genoa’s pizza. Nobody. Sausage, Mushroom, and Onion , extra sauce . Yummy yummy for your tummy. Don’t be a dummy, play Rummy, and order a Genoas pizza. No commission for this. You don’t try it you don’t know.
… moreRudy Knaflic
Good pizza and people are always friendly. East Troy on a Monday. Not much is open in regards to food. The rib place is closed. Sushi place closed, Chinese food closed, even the fast food drive-in that sells custard and hamburgers is closed. Nobody opens until Tuesday. Too bad. Pizza it is…I always enjoy the pizza deals at Genoa Pizza they have to offer. Their sausage on the CSMO is always tasty. It’s a go-to pizza place. Limited dining space but you can dine in and have a beer.
… moreSkyler Donner
Basic pizza, sausage and pepperoni.
Crust 5-10
Sauce 6-10
Meat 8-10
Cheese 7-10
It was a fair pizza, I’d have it again but not my 1st choice. The crust was the downfall for me. It had no real bite to it and no flavor. A nice cornmeal would probably help out significantly.
… moreMelanie Mattes
Order for the 1st time from here as we just moved to the surrounding areas. I was looking for a new pizza joint, something similar to the pizza napolis pizza and this IS the place. It’s was absolutely delicious! 1000% going to order from here again!
… morePeter Kesselhon
I have been a long time customer of Genoa’s Pizza and never had any complaints or issues. Always pleased. But recently, on June 9th 2025, I encountered a dismissive attitude / rudeness from the girls at the counter who take the orders. I am a 68 year old who had a few simple questions, and I was treated like an imbecile. The girls gave me a blank look as if I wasn’t there. Not once did they give heed to what I was saying. I have never been treated with such disregard or lack of respect in my life. Sad!
Genoa: I love your pizza but the girls behavior at the counter cost you a customer. I will buy my pizza elsewhere.
… moreKrystal
Best pizza in East Troy by far. I love the crust on this pizza. Ask for the specials when you order you could get a cheeper price.
… moreDebbie “bitsyland” K
Im not a fan of parmesan cheese on my pizza. Other love it.
… morekris k
Pretty good pizza. Highly recommended. Prices are maybe a bit higher than average, but I still drive 30 minutes for it as it is one of the better pizza places I’ve had in the area.
… moreChris S
Pizza is always excellent. Original Sin is our favorite. Staff is always friendly. They do have delivery if needed, dine in option is very limited. Best for carry out or delivery.
… more