Gatsby’s Landing

  4.4 – 306 reviews   • New American restaurant

Social Profile:

✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out Gatsby's Landing 10036

Address and Contact Information

Address: 120 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036

Phone: (212) 597-2850

Website: http://gatsbyslanding.com/

Menu Photos

gatsbyslanding.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Gatsby’s Landing Times Square | New American Cuisine | NYC

Experience our elegant ambiance and gracious service. Our expertly executed and globally-inspired menu features New American cuisine created from the finest …

Gatsby’s Landing | New American Cuisine | Fine Dining | Catering …

Gatsby’s Landing Restaurant in Roslyn, NY and Times Square, NYC. Our New American cuisine is created from the finest seasonal ingredients.

Times Square Menu – Gatsby’s Landing

… Brunch: 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM. TIMES SQUARE, NYC. 120 West 44th St. New York, NY 10036. [email protected]. ​. 212.597.2850. ONLINE DELIVERY. TIMES SQUARE …

Reviews

Meghan McNicholl
This is such a convenient location if you are seeing a show nearby or at a hotel nearby. We needed something close to our hotel and this was right next door. The food was excellent! The servers were all extremely friendly and helpful. Our server answered all our questions with a smile. Everyone greeted us when we came in and thanked us when we left. The drink menu was great and I loved that they had mocktails listed as well (they are not pictured, but some of my family had them.) The pasta is made in house. The quality was excellent. Highly recommend!
… more
Russell Emery
We saw this place as we were leaving the theater. It was right across the street so we decided to try it.

Wow! So glad we did. Nice, quiet, intimate place to have some world class food. The service was impeccable. The food was even better. We had the ravoil and pork chop. Both were just perfect. The on bone pork chop was HUGE. The cocktails were expertly prepared too.

For a spur of the moment decision, this was definitely a great choice.
… more
C Hill
I ate here before Maybe Happy Endings. The eggplant appetizer was fantastic. The caccio e Pepe was undercooked. The non cash charge for using my credit card was rude. I hope other restaurants don’t follow them.
… more
Marie Taylor-Morrison
Nice place to go for a drink and meet friendly bar staff, whoever the dish I ordered wasn’t great. And as I had a show to get to I didn’t have time to sample something else. I ordered the meatballs. The marinara sauce was watery and the bite on the meat balls was inconsistent. One was so dense I couldn’t eat it.
… more
Lamoore
Okay, so I see that this restaurant has great reviews and even the staff at our hotel lobby recomnended it.

However, we had a totally different experience. It was practically empty, and yet the service was poor and slow. They certainly didn’t deserve the tip we gave.

Took photos of the food a bit late but I can say that it was tasteless, uninspiring, and not worth the pricey costs. Worst food on our holiday so far. Couldn’t wait to be out of there. Lovely decor, though.

Perhaps it was a bad day for them.
… more
Jason Mienscow
MUST GO.
Gatsby’s Landing is an absolute VIBE from the second you walk in. The atmosphere is classy, warm, and feels like you accidentally stumbled into one of those spots in NYC that people gatekeep.

The drinks were insane — like legit crafted, balanced, and beautiful. Not just “good for a restaurant”… I’m talking best cocktail vibes.

Huge shoutout to Ricky, our waiter — seriously one of the best I’ve had anywhere. Super polite, knew the menu inside and out, and his recommendations were on point. You can tell he actually cares about the experience and not just rushing you through.

If you’re trying to impress someone, celebrate, or just want a night out that feels special… this place is the move.
We’ll 100% be back.
… more
Alexis Pevy
I had such a great experience at Gatsby’s Landing in Times Square! Our waiter, Remi, went above and beyond—she was so helpful, made sure everything was perfect, and had the best sense of humor. Her recommendations were spot-on, and her service made the whole night even better.

The atmosphere was lively with amazing music that set the tone for a fun evening. Food-wise, the duck pasta and the salmon were both delicious, and we finished with the crème brûlée, which was the perfect sweet ending.

Between the great food, fantastic service, and upbeat vibe, this is definitely a spot I’d come back to and recommend to anyone visiting Times Square!
… more
Cassidy
This place was cool. It was pretty quiet and laid back for such a bustling part of the city. I liked the ambient lights and calm atmosphere. The food was absolutely incredible too. The pork chop was cooked to perfection with the most delicious apple cranberry sauce. The drinks were on the pricy side, but much needed for the experience. We ate here before our Broadway show and it really sealed the evening.
… more
Carol S Texas
We had our Thanksgiving meal here. There were 10 of us (7 adults and 3 children). Everyone found something on the menu to satisfy their appetite. Each of the entrées were outstanding. The dessert menu was amazing and fun. We tried the Gatsby‘s banana split, chocolate s’mores, and trio sorbet – all were delicious and “gobbled” up. You won’t be disappointed when you dine here.
… more
Tricia G
I’ve enjoyed several meals at Gatsby’s Landing over the past couple of years, usually when heading into the city to see a Broadway show. Its location near so many theaters makes it incredibly convenient. I really enjoy the atmosphere, and despite having read some mixed reviews, my companions and I have consistently had positive experiences. The service has always been attentive, the food enjoyable, and the drinks well made. It’s become a reliable pre-theater spot that I’m always happy to return to
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment