Unpretentious bar & grill featuring a large menu of classic American dishes, beers & mixed drinks.
Craig Bibeau
Food was good, they have some fun with the relish tray – wasn’t expecting one of the items (but don’t want to ruin the surprise)
Had ribeye done properly with an add-on lobster tail cooked better than any other. The sesred tuna salad was good. Service was excellent. Good drinks smoked old fashioned and the passionfruit martini. Also a generous wine pour with our meal.
… moreJim Blackwood
Busy restaurant with good range of dishes on the menu. Gary’s Prime Rib was solid. Popovers to start our meal were a treat, too.
They put a small plate of nuts, pickle slices, and gummy bears on the table when you arrive. The gummy bears were surprisingly good. Soft chewy sweet. Delectable!
… moreWes Fields
Gary’s has been one of our favorite places to grab a nicer dinner. The service has always been wonderful, but the food last night was not up to the typical standard. I have gotten their Ruben on multiple occasions and loved it, however last nights was not close to my historic experience. Different and smaller bread, almost no kraut, and the corned beef was no even close to as tender, in fact it was rather chewy. Hopefully this is not how things will be in the future. It’s a great place, I just hope the food doesn’t continue to slip. I’ve added a couple pics of my take home box.
… moreJared Tripp
Excellent evening at Gary’s. Has an old world steakhouse feel, but still modern and fresh. Lovely atmosphere. The menu made chosing difficult as everything looked great. My table had prime rib, Parmesan crusted walleye and a cape cod style lobster roll, along with the short rib nachos and crab dip. I left stuffed and satisfied. Service was spot on, even with a large crowd.
… moreMichael Stiel
First time in, very inviting and old school atmosphere. Maddie waited on us. She was super friendly and made our experience very enjoyable. Food was “Oh gosh fantastic.”
Service was very good, short wait times between drinks, apps and main course. Over all great experience.
… moreSrikanth Narayanan
Stopped by Gary’s Supper Club and had a great experience. The Smoked Manhattan was excellent—smooth, well balanced, and easily one of the highlights of the night. The food was very tasty, and everything we tried was well prepared and flavorful.
Service was awesome as well—friendly, attentive, and made the evening even better.
Definitely planning to go back and try some of the other options on the menu. Highly recommend if you’re looking for a great supper club experience. ️
… moreDavid HUDGENS
First time here based on a friend’s recommendation, and we were not disappointed. From the time we sat down until we left, our waitress Maddie was incredible with her humor and attention to detail. She never rushed us and had so much to tell us about the food in the menu. The dinner was amazing and so tasty. King Crab legs, shrimp scampi, lobster tails, lobster bisque, champagne mussels, salmon Oscar, and drunk coconut shrimp were all very tasty. The desserts were also great enough to order extra to take home. Thank you to Maddie for a wonderful experience for a birthday celebration. We are coming back for dinner again!
… moreJeff Brinkman
Took wife out for her birthday and Gary’s did not disappoint. Great food and great atmosphere! Definitely will be back.
… moreWalter Wettschreck (Walt)
First time here for my birthday. Party of 6. We all loved our food. Portions are huge! I tried the short rib pasta – was excellent. Complimentary birthday desert was great too!
… moreWilliam Bishop
Everything was pretty good the service and atmosphere were exactly what we were looking for our food was delicious! Our waitress was top notch!
… more