Regional chain outpost supplying standard Mexican meals in a colorful, family-friendly setting.
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
360 Broad Street Waverly, NY 14845 607-249-6297 Dine in and …
Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant. Jul 29, 2025 . . TACO TUESDAY all day at Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant, stop in for some delicious TACOS.
Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant – CLOSED, 358 Broad St, Waverly, NY …
Get more information for Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant in Waverly, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant opens in Waverly – morning-times.com
Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant finally opened its doors on Monday to share authentic Mexican cuisine and culture with the Valley community.
Reviews
Eve Vanshire
I tried the Garcias in the Elmira area years ago and didn’t love it. I really wanted Mexican food for my birthday so we gave the waverly location a try and it was amazing. I’ll definitely be back many more times. I saw the bad reviews and I’m confused by most but I do agree the prices are high. Especially compared to places I’d go to in Texas but prices have gone up everywhere. It also doesn’t have any competition really like the ones in Texas so I guess it’s to be expected. The host and server were really nice and the foods presentation was really pretty.
… moreAgnes Griffin
Ordered two margaritas…when they were served they were in huge..huge glasses. We each (2 people) ordered a different lunch. One was $18 and the other was $17. I was surprised at the bill ….just under $100. Usually you are asked if there are different sizes of drinks. This was not done. Also Mexican food has rice and beans on plate …about half or more of the food. Why was the bill so large???? Will never go there again!!!!!
…
… more…
Janan Jem
AMAZING. Super excited this place is here in town now. We were pleasantly surprised. Growing up in LA around Mexican food we are pretty hard to please, but Garcia’s hit the spot. We will definitely be coming back. Our servers though new were on top of everything and very personable. Please bring Mezcal cocktails. Can’t wait to come back and try everything else. We had the Street Tacos and Burro. Everything was tasty. I would like to see the Burro wrapped up better so it can be held in the hands to eat. I wasn’t too keen on using cutlery – haha! The torta is probably next on the must try list.
… moreJanice Erickson
The only reason for 4 stars was the on street parking. Coming thru the area, I Googled restaurants and was surprised to see one in Waverly? Could it be the same? It was! Great food, waitress helped me find what I had liked at other Garcia’s. Nice friendly staff. Price was affordable.
… moreRANDALL HILL
While I was visiting my brother in Waverly I noticed Garcia’s Mexican Restaurant and decided we should try it. The service was excellent considering they were very busy. I ordered for both of us the Chimichangas and an extra side of Gucamole. We never received the Gucamole, which I was glad after I tasted it. All of the ingredients used to prepare our food was either boxed or canned. The Chimichangas were made with plain ground beef –vs- shredded beef. The refried beans were a poor excuse for canned beans. The entire meal was so bad, I didn’t finish mine. I want to add that the prices being charged are the same that I pay in Baltimore Maryland for quality Mexican food.
All in all, a sad excuse for a Mexican Restaurant.
… moreAll in all, a sad excuse for a Mexican Restaurant.
Jeffrey Singer
When we arrived, the place was packed, so we sat at the bar. Service was awesome. I had Bandera, a couple of enchaladas. I liked the chicken one with the green sauce a little more than the beef one w red sauce. My wife had the chimichanga which was huge. Excellent food, lovely servers, Id like to return for lunch soon.
… moreBethann Schumacher
Our excitement quickly turned to disappointment. My friend and I made a special trip to Waverly to try the new Garcia’s since our favorite one in Cortland closed a few months ago after a terrible fire. We absolutely loved the Cortland restaurant and I have to say the food at the Waverly location was just as phenomenal! The margs, salsa, Chile rellano, rice, and beans tasted exactly how they did at the Cortland location. However, we were very disappointed when the waitress/staff would not honor a gift certificate from the Cortland location that my friend had received as a gift prior to the fire. We understand it’s a new business, but from what we learned, the cook came from Cortland and the owner is the same. The waitress was not very friendly from the get-go and she seemed very unsympathetic about our predicament. I wish Carlos would have been there because he would have recognized us and honored it for us. Not sure if we will be making the trip to Waverly again.
… moreJeanettee Weaver
Not crazy about the Day of the Dead mural, but highly impressed with everything else. HUGE portions, fair prices, delicious food. Worth every penny.
… moreMisty Austin
Food was pretty good. Service was awful. No one even greets you when you walk in the door then you wait forever to be served. The place is small and stuffy.
… moreWalter Sparbanie
Over priced, below average food. $60 for 3 small steak tacos a burrito and pepsi bottle of water.. won’t be back
… more