Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1323 NY-52, Carmel Hamlet, NY 10512
Phone: (845) 878-0800
Website: http://www.gappyspizza.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Gappy’s Pizza: Home
… pizza shop to visit in Putnam county by New York Upstate. … We are conveniently located off I-84, exit 17 in Lake Carmel and invite you to stop by and “Get …
Gappys Pizza – Experience Authentic NY Style Pizza in Carmel Hamlet
Visit Gappys Pizza at 1323 NY-52 for delectable, authentic New York style pizza. Enjoy a welcoming atmosphere, friendly service, and a menu that promises …
Gappy’s Pizza | Carmel NY – Facebook
Gappy’s Pizza ; Details. . 94% recommend (211 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . 1323 Route 52, Carmel, NY, United States, 10512 ; Links. . gappyspizza.com …
Reviews
JERRY taddeo
Two guys walk into Gappy’s Pizza in Carmel sometime in the summer of 2025 and order a normal large pizza.
At the register: two female employees take the order. The pizza comes out heart-shaped, handed over by the guy cooking (Mexican dude in the back) with what felt like a smirk—because apparently two male friends sharing a table means we must be a couple.
We specifically asked for a standard round pie. No jokes, no special requests. They still did it anyway.
That’s not harmless fun.
That’s deliberate homophobic harassment—using our food to mock what they assumed was our sexuality.
They looked at two straight men hanging out and decided it was okay to turn our order into a bigoted “joke.”
In 2025/2026, staff humiliating customers like this isn’t banter.
It’s targeted discrimination. It’s bullying. And it’s disgusting—especially from a place that markets itself as treating people “like family.”
Gappy’s Pizza thinks this is fine?
It’s not.
One star.
Owners (George or management): If this sounds familiar, check your summer 2025 shifts—two women on register, guy in the kitchen prepping. Verify it happened, or discuss how to make this right before more people see it and decide to avoid you. Reach out directly if you want my side or to resolve this. I’m open to talking—otherwise, share this so no one else gets treated the same way.
… moreAt the register: two female employees take the order. The pizza comes out heart-shaped, handed over by the guy cooking (Mexican dude in the back) with what felt like a smirk—because apparently two male friends sharing a table means we must be a couple.
We specifically asked for a standard round pie. No jokes, no special requests. They still did it anyway.
That’s not harmless fun.
That’s deliberate homophobic harassment—using our food to mock what they assumed was our sexuality.
They looked at two straight men hanging out and decided it was okay to turn our order into a bigoted “joke.”
In 2025/2026, staff humiliating customers like this isn’t banter.
It’s targeted discrimination. It’s bullying. And it’s disgusting—especially from a place that markets itself as treating people “like family.”
Gappy’s Pizza thinks this is fine?
It’s not.
One star.
Owners (George or management): If this sounds familiar, check your summer 2025 shifts—two women on register, guy in the kitchen prepping. Verify it happened, or discuss how to make this right before more people see it and decide to avoid you. Reach out directly if you want my side or to resolve this. I’m open to talking—otherwise, share this so no one else gets treated the same way.
Eric Stone
Went in for a slice of pizza while my dad filled up his car across the street. Was immediately greeted by Gappy. Ended up hanging out for longer than planned.
Pizza was great — crispy crust on both Sicilian and regular slice — and the people elevated the short time I spent there even more.
Strongly recommend for a good time and good food.
… morePizza was great — crispy crust on both Sicilian and regular slice — and the people elevated the short time I spent there even more.
Strongly recommend for a good time and good food.
Charlotte Oglesby
The staff here are wonderful. We ended up stopping here after breaking down & they went above & beyond to support. Incredibly generous people.
Thank you again! & my daughter loved the pizza!!
… moreThank you again! & my daughter loved the pizza!!
John schlick
A night out with friend was an excellent experience as we watched our waitress Hailey keep us well served for food and beverage and always with a smile.
The food is mediocre but plentiful. Portions are large and good value. BUT we will be back just because the service this person gave us was memorable!
… moreThe food is mediocre but plentiful. Portions are large and good value. BUT we will be back just because the service this person gave us was memorable!
Emily Suzanne
Gappys has become our go to stop, when heading home from trips! Ordered a cheese Sicilian, it was amazing! Cannolis are amazing as well. Great employees, fast service!
… moreA NON
We came here based on the great reviews. But it’s most likely not based on the service you receive here.
The ambiance looked nice and there was both outdoor and indoor seating.
We walked in and were told to sit anywhere. We sat there at the table looking at each other for 10 minutes and still no one came to us. The server was busy filling sauces behind the counter. There was also another table just sitting there as well.
We just got up and left.
2 stars for the ambiance.
… moreThe ambiance looked nice and there was both outdoor and indoor seating.
We walked in and were told to sit anywhere. We sat there at the table looking at each other for 10 minutes and still no one came to us. The server was busy filling sauces behind the counter. There was also another table just sitting there as well.
We just got up and left.
2 stars for the ambiance.
Rosey Day
Been here twice. First time, a while back, maybe a little less than a year ago, great food- shrimp scampi pizza was knock it out of the park good. Server was young but OK. Had to get going, went to the counter to find our server and saw a bunch of people doing shots with one of the cooks! Yeah, not cool.
Gave them another chance, did take out. Meat pizza was loaded with all of.the meats! It was full, tasty, marinara was good, crust had flavor. The Wings were $$$ and not good at all. Small, hardly any meat, Breaded- who breads Buffalo wings? Whatever breading they used made the wing sauce gloppy and pasty. Unpleasantness….
We like to patronize local, family owned spots but can’t afford to waste money on inconsistent food and service. That’s why we left our last local spot after decades.
I really wish I could give Gappy’s an excellent review 🙁
… moreGave them another chance, did take out. Meat pizza was loaded with all of.the meats! It was full, tasty, marinara was good, crust had flavor. The Wings were $$$ and not good at all. Small, hardly any meat, Breaded- who breads Buffalo wings? Whatever breading they used made the wing sauce gloppy and pasty. Unpleasantness….
We like to patronize local, family owned spots but can’t afford to waste money on inconsistent food and service. That’s why we left our last local spot after decades.
I really wish I could give Gappy’s an excellent review 🙁
390fordgalaxie
Food EXCELLENT, PRICE EXCELLENT SERVICE EXCELLENT
But… soda was FLAT as a tire on a winter day lol
And TRY PUTTING THE HEAT ON in the WINTER ( MOST EVERYONE WEARING JACKETS) INSIDE IT WAS 14 ° OUTSIDE N PROBABLY 50° inside… u lost 1 overall star for LACK of spending $ on heat and 3 stars only for atmosphere because ur to cheap to put heat on in winter
… moreBut… soda was FLAT as a tire on a winter day lol
And TRY PUTTING THE HEAT ON in the WINTER ( MOST EVERYONE WEARING JACKETS) INSIDE IT WAS 14 ° OUTSIDE N PROBABLY 50° inside… u lost 1 overall star for LACK of spending $ on heat and 3 stars only for atmosphere because ur to cheap to put heat on in winter
Kim Blacklock
Voted Best Sauce in Hudson Valley! Menu of deliciousness! Friendly staff! Big portions, great pricing! The Best! Fun times, always ☀️
Quick i84 highway access (exit 58) & near Taconic Parkway, with ample parking – even for trucks with trailers! We had an impromptu early birthday lunch with my older brother Doug & my nephew Doug here from Schenectady!! Yummmm white bean & escarole soup as starter! Doug had the burger, the other Doug had a small pizza (that’s 6 slices!) – guess who had what?
… moreQuick i84 highway access (exit 58) & near Taconic Parkway, with ample parking – even for trucks with trailers! We had an impromptu early birthday lunch with my older brother Doug & my nephew Doug here from Schenectady!! Yummmm white bean & escarole soup as starter! Doug had the burger, the other Doug had a small pizza (that’s 6 slices!) – guess who had what?
Brian Abrams
Best pizza I’ve had in the Carmel area. Your classic thin NY slice. Very friendly staff. Always very cordial and offer you paper plates with your pizza. Always seems to be a good vibe going on in the restaurant among both staff and patrons
… more