Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Nestled in Caldwell, Idaho, Gandolfo’s Deli is your go-to spot for mouthwatering New York-style deli sandwiches, hearty soups, fresh salads, and homemade sides. Our specialty? The iconic Reuben, made with your choice of savory pastrami or tender corned beef, all piled high on freshly baked bread. But that’s just the beginning! At Gandolfo’s, we believe in using the finest ingredients to create unforgettable flavors. Enjoy our classic potato salad, creamy macaroni salad, and indulgent banana pudding as the perfect complements to your meal. Whether you’re dining in, taking out, or ordering catering for your next event, our friendly staff is dedicated to providing an exceptional experience. Join us for lunch or dinner!
NYC-style deli serving sandwiches on housemade bread, plus salads, hot dogs & bagels.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 712 Arthur St, Caldwell, ID 83605
Phone: (208) 402-5563
Website: https://order.toasttab.com/online/gandolfos-caldwell
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Gandolfo’s Deli
Gandolfo’s New York Deli serves giant, stacked sandwiches, homemade sides & soups in Meridian, right in front of Schools! Order online, dine in, …
Home | Gandolfos Deli We’re more than a sandwich shop we’re a …
We’re a DELI! Order Online, Order Catering, Find the store nearest to you, and learn about our deli. Est. 1989, We’re more than a sandwich shop…
Gandolfo’s New York Deli, 712 Arthur St, Ste C, Caldwell, ID 83605 …
Get more information for Gandolfo’s New York Deli in Caldwell, ID. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Melinda McAlister
Ordered via the Toast App and sandwiches were done on time. Ladies working behind the counter were very friendly which is wonderful for just a to-go order. I got the Bridge Hampton, modified to sourdough bread instead of a roll, and Wall Street Club sandwiches with a side of 2 pickles. The pickle is big and cut into 4 spears, and is $2 each. Good sandwiches but not great.
… moreJenn
Best Pastrami I’ve had in years! Ordered takeout, a Rockefeller Ruben and NY Liberty. Ruben was loaded with the perfect amount of meat delicious! Liberty bread was very soft and pillowy. Seating in the covered patio and atmosphere in the area is unique. Definitely recommend and we will be back.
… moreJon boy
I would honestly say the food was lackluster. It was just alright! There is nothing special about it. Especially with it being 20 dollars for a sandwich,side, and drink i expected more.
The bread was dry, but the meat was good.
It wasn’t gross. It wasn’t spectacular
… moreThe bread was dry, but the meat was good.
It wasn’t gross. It wasn’t spectacular
Cory Sousa
Cashier was nice but was untruthful or untrained. We were told the combo was 3.99 more. However, when we received the receipt we were charged an extra dollar for each mac and cheese. When asked all we were told was sorry. Instead of saving money we spent more. Tables were a little dirty as well and the place was not busy. Sandwiches are always good but please clean the tables. Last time I tip before the service is complete.
… moreKJ7Element2
What the heck!? I got all the way home and opened my sandwich to find that my sandwich is mainly bread with a couple slices of meat. I have ordered this sandwich before and had a more generous portion of meat. What a waste of money since I can get more at Port of Subs or even Subway. Very disappointing.
… moreCaitlin Miller
Quiet & cute little spot. Staff was super friendly. Both sandwiches we had were delicious! Same with the cookie.
… moreThao Ha
Loved it the moment I walked in. The New York decor was so creative and everything was clean. I got the Big Apple which was delicious! It was a big sandwich so I didn’t think I’d finish it but I kept wanting more even after I was full. I can’t wait to try some of their other specialty sandwiches. I also didn’t realize they had other options outside of sandwiches so that was a nice surprise. They also have gluten free which was another nice surprise as my daughter is sensitive. Great, friendly staff. Quick and professional.
… moreIsaac Hall
Overall, pretty good, but nothing to quite rave about.
Fiancé and I got a couple sandwiches (a 6” and a 12”) with a side pickle and a side of mac. About $36. Sandwiches were pretty good, but nothing to quite rave about for the price. Pickle was good, cold and crispy! Mac was the biggest disappointment. Flavor wasn’t bad but noodles were very overcooked and more like a mush.
… moreFiancé and I got a couple sandwiches (a 6” and a 12”) with a side pickle and a side of mac. About $36. Sandwiches were pretty good, but nothing to quite rave about for the price. Pickle was good, cold and crispy! Mac was the biggest disappointment. Flavor wasn’t bad but noodles were very overcooked and more like a mush.
Donna Mckahan
1st time trying Gandalfos in Caldwell. I had ordered online. I ordered 2 sandwiches and coleslaw. When I got home I had a note that said the don’t sell Coleslaw at that location and they gave me a container of lettuce, container of I think ranch dressing and a container of pepper. All they had to do was let me know when I got there they don’t carry coleslaw and refund my money or offer me another option. That would have been acceptable. They didn’t say anything to me when I picked up the order. Instead I paid $3.49 for ingredients that do not make coleslaw. Our sandwiches were also labeled wrong as well. I was so excited to try them but I will not be going back.
… moreShelly Henry
This is Gandolfo’s version of a Philly cheesesteak sandwich… It was the worst sandwich I have ever had.
Disappointment doesn’t even begin to describe my experience with Gandolfo’s New York Deli’s version of a Philly cheesesteak. Having dreamt of a hot, juicy, savory classic, I was met with a cold sandwich that would make Rocky Balboa weep.
Sadly, It fell so far short of a true Philly cheesesteak that it should be renamed the “Philly Phlop.”
I did ask the staff if the sandwich was made correctly and they confirmed that it was their version of a Philly cheesesteak. However, I do want to add everyone there was very kind but offered no solutions.
The sandwich ended up in the trash.
… moreDisappointment doesn’t even begin to describe my experience with Gandolfo’s New York Deli’s version of a Philly cheesesteak. Having dreamt of a hot, juicy, savory classic, I was met with a cold sandwich that would make Rocky Balboa weep.
Sadly, It fell so far short of a true Philly cheesesteak that it should be renamed the “Philly Phlop.”
I did ask the staff if the sandwich was made correctly and they confirmed that it was their version of a Philly cheesesteak. However, I do want to add everyone there was very kind but offered no solutions.
The sandwich ended up in the trash.