SR
I have really mixed feelings about my visit to Game Over in West Bend, WI.
First impression upon walking in was great — the place looked fun, with games everywhere and a lively atmosphere. The bartenders were friendly, and even though we arrived right during a shift change, our drinks came out quickly.
I started with the Princess Peach cocktail (dragonberry rum, pineapple rum, lime juice, cranberry juice, and club soda). There was nothing wrong with the drink itself — it just wasn’t my taste, so I switched to my usual after one.
For food, I ordered the Garlic Bread Patty Melt with a black bean patty instead of beef (their menu says you can substitute chicken or a black bean patty for any burger). Unfortunately, when my order came out, it was the regular beef patty, which I don’t eat. Mistakes happen, so I let the bartender know. She was very apologetic and had the kitchen fix it.
The second attempt came out quickly, but it was just the black bean patty by itself — not the full sandwich. So, back it went again. Third time was the charm — the sandwich finally came out right, and it was decent.
Overall, the staff was kind and apologetic, and I could tell they were trying. But the repeated mix-ups made the experience less enjoyable. I’d give it another try in the future, hoping for a smoother experience next time.
… moreRebecca Knox Captain Save A Home (Captain Save A Home)
We came here to try the burger of the week which had marshmallow fluff. It was amazing and their fries are #1 in WI. The woman working was cheerful and helpful. We will definitely be back.
… moreChristina Johnson
Fun atmosphere with tons of games to play. Service was very impressive! Went for the fish fry. It has a cornmeal breading. Not my favorite but it was still good. The loaded smashed potato is amazing. We will definitely be back.
… morePaula Norkofski
What a great experience, from the minute we walked in the bartender welcomed us.
We sat at bar and had drinks and appetizers. The cauliflower with bbq sauce and ranch on the side were amazing. Very clean, family friendly. Thank you
… moreRis G
I had The Frenchie and it was so good!!! The meat was tender and juicy, the bun was soft, and the melted cheese made everything even better. I highly recommend it! The fries are petty great too! The atmosphere is chill and fun. Stop on out, you’ll be glad you did!
… moreJustice Timblin
Went here on Friday night and had such a great experience! Even though they were really busy, the service was still fantastic. The “Frick Yeahs” deep-fried pickles were incredible — you can tell they take the time to hand-make them. I had the Fiesta Chicken Sandwich and it was SO good. The chicken wasn’t overcooked for once, which always seems to be an issue at other places.
Absolutely will be returning!
… moreDonna Robinson
I was pleasantly surprised at how good my Cowabunga burger was! The top part of it was like a mini half bun pizza with marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese and mini pepperoni slices. Underneath was a very delicious smash burger cooked to perfection and more mozzarella. If you like French fries that are tasty crisp on the outside and soft on the inside you’ll love these. We will be back to try other interesting choices on the menu. Hats off to the owner this establishment . You’ve got a good thing going!
… moreMatt Krueger
Interesting place. I had the cowabunga. Wish i would have went with build your own burger. The smash burger was pretty good when i had some without the pizza toppings. The chips were ok did not seem fresh but my mom really liked them. Great ascetic for 80s 90s vibe.
… moreJenni Thompson
Game Over is one of our favorite places in town! The food is so good! The Chef is very creative and blends flavors together I would never think of. Drinks are always on point (I’m very particular of how my Old Fashioned is made and they do it right!). The staff is always attentive and extremely friendly. My 80year old mother requests eating here weekly due to all the reasons I listed above. Highly recommend The Homie, Hot Chicks and Fish Fry!
… moreC. N.
Finally was able to make it out and try this place. Definitely one of the best smash burgers in the area that I’ve had in quite awhile. We will for sure be back sooner than later!
… more