Deb
I recently moved here from Illinois and in Illinois I had my favorite pizza place that know where has compared to.. until my sister-in-law Cindy took me here to Gallagher’s! This pizza was fantastic! Our waitress was wonderful and the ambiance was just right. Has Arnold said; “I’ll be back”! Excellent pizza
… moreTed
Ordered online for pickup to this location tonight. Food was ready when it said it would be, so there’s a plus but thats about where it ends. The pizza was burnt, the veggie sandwich was missing added items and the broccoli wasnt even cooked so it was overly crunchy. The meatball sandwich had everything that was added but somehow was missing the marinara and the additional marinara side that was ordered was missed completely.
When I called to try and get a refund for some of the food I was told it was either store credit or they could remake the food. The employee got their manager but the manager refused to talk on the phone.
Why would I drive 30 minutes to get food thats remade, or in store credit for a place that could only make bread right? This is for sure the last time going.
… moreJacy Sterling
I have loved Gallagher’s for years! Last 3 times have been disappointing. Forgot the cheese bread twice. When I called to let them know they made it seem like it was a huge inconvenience. I’m sorry, I just spent nearly $50, I want the food I ordered. And would be nice to have it all at once. The receipt clearly shows garlic cheese bread on it each time. So it was missed leaving the kitchen, missed leaving the restaurant, and missed again when being delivered. The meals are never consistent anymore. What was great last time is made completely different the next time.
… moreMargie Rodriguez
This pizza place has several locations in Green Bay. They offer many different types of pizza, but the calzone is my favorite—so tasty and delicious! Prices are very reasonable too. Highly recommended!
… moreJudith Tyni
We had dinner here last night, Dec 23rd. The pizza was so tasty, beers were cold. We left well satisfied and very happy with our waitress as she was so attentive and so sweet! Thanks Gallaghers for such an awesome meal and dining experience!
… moreMelissa “Lis” Williams
This place has the nicest people and food!! I ordered in a third party app and they immediately called to ask a couple questions about my order! This antipasto salad is incredible with the Greek dressing too! Perfect keto friendly sub salad!!
… moreMel B
So many Italian options of pastas, pizzas and more! Wonderful and attentive staff. The food was absolutely delicious! I would absolutely recommend to friends and come again!
… moreDave Koury
2 of us ordered a 2 person Calzone. Canzone was large enough that we brought some home. I’m my opinion.. one of the best Calzones I’ve enjoyed.. Will have to come back at try another item on their menu..
… moreTed Miller
This place has been on a steady decline for years. Last few orders over the years have been bad, their sandwiches are scant and not to order. My wife and I became ill the evening of our last pizza order and she was briefly hospitalized with dehydration. I called to inform them that we had gotten sick on their food and they need to rotate stock and/or check the temp of their coolers, but I got silence from the female who took my call, then she hung up on me. It’s been reported, hopefully that will change for anyone who makes the poor decision to order food from this place. Horrible customer service and bad food means that will never be us again.
… moreNancy Selinsky
Came for the buffet at 11:15. The pizzas were not hot. Not even close. They would’ve been great if they were hot, but they were lukewarm. The shield by the salad bar was so cloudy you couldn’t see into it. I won’t be going back
… more