Gaetano's Pizzeria & Creamery - Jenks, OK 74037 - Menu, Reviews, Hours & Contact

• Jenks, OK 74037. HOME · ABOUT · MENU · ICE CREAM · CATERING · SPECIALS · APPLY · CONTACT · Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery. Jenks. 12141 South Elm St Ste #105

Gaetano’s Pizzeria and Creamery | Jenks OK – Facebook

Unfortunately, we remain closed today (2/19) due to road conditions and the safety of our team and customers. Please stay safe and warm. We’ll try again …

Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery | TravelOK.com – Oklahoma’s Official …

Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery. 12141 S Elm St Ste 105. Jenks, OK 74037.

Reviews

Melani Jones

We highly recommend everything Gaetanos! From the salad, to the wings, to the calzone and pizza, everything we ordered was beyond fantastic! The prices are too low for the quality of food and service we experienced! 5 stars is not enough. They earned and deserve much more!

… more

Misty Lassley

Jenks Gaetano’s is truly a hidden gem for those in Bixby . We don’t have to battle traffic on Memorial Rd and their pizza is spot on every time. The pizza rolls as an appetizer also comes in clutch.

… more

Addison Baker

The best part of the menu was the dessert. Some of the meals we received seemed to be microwaved while others seemed fresh. The dry pasta was served at the same time as the one with sauce. Appetizers came after the meal, and some of our group waited 45+ for appetizers. Server was super sweet but the food just seemed be reheated and not homemade.

… more

Asia black

This was our first time eating here, and most likely be a one time. The Alfredo sauce was the only good thing. The dough for the calzone and the pizza was pretty raw. I mean it was still completely stretchy. The chicken for the Alfredo was grayish in color and very rubbery. The fried ravioli tasted the exact same as the great value brand ones in the freezer section of Walmart.

… more

Margie Young

We love this pizzeria! We have always had good experience in ordering out or dining in!

… more

corrado lvr92 (Corradolvr92)

Ok first time visit, I should have gotten the name of the woman at the counter, she’s a delight! Not only was she super pleasant but she 1000% was trying to get what I ordered put on the menu! So what we ordered was the bacon cheeseburger calzone but as a pizza. If you want to do this here’s my suggestion take the 1000 island dressing from their salads use as sauce base add meats and cheese and cook, maybe butter the crust and add sesame seeds at end of bake.
Seriously those pizza rolls are KILLER, nice size, full of flavor and pepperoni and dusted with delicious Italian seasonings!
We both ate 2 rolls and 2 slices, went home with leftovers and don’t even need dinner tonight.
The service is so GOOD HERE.
Please forgive my photos I remembered to take them after I had already snatched a couple rolls and the pizza slices but seriously don’t sleep on this place. Their menu is limited but very well executed and they also have ICE CREAM!!!!
Clean space, clean restrooms, plenty of seating and more than ample parking!
We will definitely be back!!!

… more

Robyn York

The individual who helped us on Tuesday 12/30/25 was Great. Made recommendations for our LG pepperoni pizza, Lasagna & “love” caramel ice cream & all were so tasty. He was great, too.

… more

B&W2Color (Stephanie)

Wonderful, friendly service. Best pizza, calzones and lasagna price-value-taste in the Tulsa area.

… more

lynn beaird

Our favorite pizza! Friends and family all loke it so much, they come over from Sand Springs and Tulsa to get it. Cozy and quiet and family oriented.

… more

Lashawn Webb

Came here with my classmates after a fieldtrip. The staff were kind, attentive, the food was good, restaurant was clean, and the atmosphere was amazing. Would eat here again!

… more

… View more

Gaetano’s Pizzeria & Creamery

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results