Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Gaetano’s Pizza – Jim Thorpe, PA – 200 North St – Hours, Menu, Order
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-8:30 PM; Shop address is 200 North St, Jim Thorpe, PA 18229200 North St, Jim Thorpe, PA 18229; (570) 325-9411.
Gaetano’s Pizza – 200 North St, Jim Thorpe, PA 18229 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Jim Thorpe, PA! Gaetano’s Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
Review of Gaetano’s pizza in Jim Thorpe, PA – Facebook
Gaetano’s Pizza in Jim Thorpe, PA. Solid 8.5. Both round and Sicilian were super crispy with almost no flop. Little too much sauce on the …
Last Updates
Reviews
Kimberly Leshak
My husband and I were in Jim Thorpe for the first time today traveling from Harrisburg for a marketplace find. I’ve always wanted to visit Jim Thorpe and although we could’ve ate on Broadway we really just wanted a sub. Gaetano’s is delicious! The fries were probably the best we’ve had in a long long time and our subs were fresh and so good! Let’s also talk about the garlic knots!!! They were AWESOME! Thank you so much for wonderful food and service. We can’t wait to come back.
… moreTami Peak
Food
We savored a delightful assortment of menu items, which included fried mushrooms, fried cauliflower, a slice of thin Neapolitan pizza, a slice of Sicilian cheese pizza, meatballs, and an eggplant Parmesan sandwich. Each dish was freshly prepared to order, and we unanimously agreed that the Neapolitan pizza was the highlight of the meal.
Service
Despite the bustling atmosphere of the Fall Festival, the staff was attentive and accommodating. They provided excellent recommendations as we aimed to sample a variety of menu options.
Atmosphere
The dining space is charmingly simple yet cozy, perfect for a quick meal. We appreciated the availability of customer restrooms, which were clean, well-appointed, and well-stocked.
… moreWe savored a delightful assortment of menu items, which included fried mushrooms, fried cauliflower, a slice of thin Neapolitan pizza, a slice of Sicilian cheese pizza, meatballs, and an eggplant Parmesan sandwich. Each dish was freshly prepared to order, and we unanimously agreed that the Neapolitan pizza was the highlight of the meal.
Service
Despite the bustling atmosphere of the Fall Festival, the staff was attentive and accommodating. They provided excellent recommendations as we aimed to sample a variety of menu options.
Atmosphere
The dining space is charmingly simple yet cozy, perfect for a quick meal. We appreciated the availability of customer restrooms, which were clean, well-appointed, and well-stocked.
Lea Morgan
DoorDash them a few times now, and sometimes I worry about DoorDash because it can take a little while so you worry about the freshness of your food, but this pizza always shows up absolutely amazing, the cheese fries are one of my favorites, definitely going to be a staple
… moreJeanne Kluck
We were working Construction. We googled Pizza places near our location. We could this Restaurant and the Pizza was so perfect. It was the best we ever had. The Owner, Cashier, was great. We did order 4 large they were totally delicious. Thank you all so much.
… moreRuth Whitlock
Just traveling thru, wanted to check out the town of Jim Thorpe but not F250 friendly. Just outside the over crowded city found this place with ample parking and it made the stop to Jim Thorpe worth it. Loved the garlic knots and the pizza was one of the best we’ve had. So fresh and tasty! Large pizza so big we have plenty for tonite with a cold beer!
… moreMichael Velez
We ordered a half cheese, half pepperoni pie from Gaetano’s and it was absolutely amazing! The thin crust was perfect—crispy with no flop—and every bite was packed with flavor. You can really tell they use top-quality ingredients, from the sauce to the cheese to the pepperoni. Hands down one of the best pizzas I’ve had, I’d give it a solid 9.2/10. Highly recommend!
… moreMook reed
Got a special cheese steak it was really good ,also got a sausage and pep slice made with the bottom crispy I would definitely eat there again next time I’m in Jim Thorpe
… moreNikki Bull
Owner is uncaring and very unfriendly.
My mom really needed a bathroom. The owner was rude and said it wasn’t his problem, she needed to buy something. She agreed, said her daughter, me, would come in. He said “show me the money first ” This man is a jerk.
… moreMy mom really needed a bathroom. The owner was rude and said it wasn’t his problem, she needed to buy something. She agreed, said her daughter, me, would come in. He said “show me the money first ” This man is a jerk.
Angelo Τ. Sirepisios
Food was delicious and we enjoyed everything we ate; pizza was amazing, burger and pasta as well. Furthermore, this store was not expensive at all and had respect to their customers!
We are visiting from New Jersey area and was a good choise.
… moreWe are visiting from New Jersey area and was a good choise.
Luke
After a day trip to Jim Thorpe, the fam and I wanted some pizza. Quick trip across the river, we came across Gaetano’s Pizza. We love these little authentic pizzeria shops. The pizza was pretty good, too. Nice charred bottom, minimum flop, and the cheese was just right.
… more