Gaetano Pizza & Cafe

Order online at one of the best restaurants in Brewster, NY! Gaetano Pizza & Cafe is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …

Gaetano Pizza Cafe: Experience the Best New York Style Pizza in …

Discover Gaetano Pizza Cafe in Brewster, NY, where crispy thin-crust pizza, delicious pasta, and a welcoming atmosphere await. Enjoy customer favorites like …

Last Updates

Reviews

The food tasted okay, but it was very salty. I would give it one star for that. However, I gave it three stars just in case the saltiness was a mistake.

… more

Nick M

I’ve been coming here for 10 years now and it’s our go-to pizza spot. Besides having good pizza we also order their buffalo chicken wrap, wings, chicken parm hero with vodka sauce and their tuscanero salad with chicken cutlet. Their chicken cutlets are the best I’ve had! We’ve ordered trays of food for parties as well. The staff is very friendly and I enjoy going there for take out or dining in!

… more

John K

I would definitely come back here again. Have a wide variety of pizza, soups pastas, calzones, etc. It’s very popular with the locals. They also offer various desserts. I knocked down a star because the bathroom can use increased cleaning. I feel like those pizzas be a little less crunchy.

… more

lbjm02

Too bad my phone tries to make the pizza look good. If this is the quality of pizza you are selling your customers at 6:15 pm on a Saturday you will find yourself out of business very quickly. The pizza looks like it’s been sitting there since 12:00. I use to get pizza from this place but no more. I see why it’s not busy on a Saturday. It’s sad that a grocery store right next to you makes better quality pizza. This should not cost 12 dollars. You should have given it away.

… more

Chris Charbonneau

Stopped in after a 14 hour drive. Picked up a meatball Parm and a chicken Parm plus 2 Cokes. Total was $27, which to me seems a little high, but it was pretty good. I would probably do it again…

… more

Taylor Gillmeister

Great pizza and really nice people working there. We travel to this area once or twice a year and come here every time for lunch and also bring pizza home.

… more

Monte Holt

Food was excellent and service was top notch. New York style pizza with a good, floppy cheesy middle and a nice crunch crust around the outside. Delicious

… more

James Gagliardo

Food is great. One of our favorite lunch spots!

… more

Kate Johnston

Gaetanos has the best pizza around! We moved to CT, and what they call pizza in CT could be more accurately described as a tragedy. When we want good pizza we drive all the way back to Gaetanos. Every pizza they have is worth the drive, but our favorites are buffalo chicken and sesame chicken. If you think your pizza place has the best buffalo chicken slice then do yourself a favor, and swing by Gaetanos for an upgraded version of your fav. You won’t be disappointed.

… more

Keegan Bluegrass

Very good NY Style Cheese Pizza for a more than reasonable price!

… more

… View more

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results