Rafael Espinal
What a way to warm up on a freezing Florida
Day With a cozy warm pizzeria. Service is quick and friendly. Atmosphere is warm and welcoming. The pizza is great 8/10. Hot fresh no flop IYKYK.
… moreD
Ordered a plain pizza for the family. From NJ, living in Florida now ~9 years, this pizza brought the family back in discussion ❤️ of how simply delicious. Thank you for the great memories and God bless on your future one(s) for the hard working mother.
… moreJennifer Cappetta
Gabbie’s eggplant rollatini is legit! Seasoned ricotta cheese makes it truly like my mom used to make it! Their sauce is so flavorful that it brings back the best memories growing up Italian. Dawn is high energy and you can see the passion she has in every dish she prepares! What a great find! Another restaurant on our list to make a staple!
… moreBrian Murray
Take a look at that pie, would ya?!?!? Our server, Denise took great care of us. We asked on FB for suggestions for a great NY/Jersey pie and after 200 comments one of the consistent recommendations was Gabbie’s Pizza so off we went for Sunday lunch. We showed Denise a photo of a pie we saw on a Google review but asked if she could request the crust to be thinner. Mission accomplished! The pizzamaker did a perfect job with the pie all the way around (no pun intended!). Next how about a side with 1 meatball and 1 sausage? Again, Denise pulled some strings and made that happen too!!! Woot woot! Yuengling brew to go with a northeast pie? No problem! So we had a Yuengling $5.25, Garden Salad $6.95, Meatball/Sausage side $5, and our 18″ white/red pie with half pepperoni $23. Just a heads up but you get a discount if you pay cash. There was also a .40 “Pavillion Fee” whatever that is?!?!?
… moreDanielle Seeley
Tonight we ordered for the first time. WOW-this is the most impressive takeout we’ve had since moving from NY 18 months ago. We got wings-BEST, most like wings up north. The Italian Mix sub was great. The Chicken Francese, unbelievable!! Well Done!! We will be back!!!
… moreTony Giese
We love their Campagnola Pizza! Always get a large for leftovers. Crust is nice and crunchy reheated. Best Pizza in town!
… moreChristina Sortor
The waitress could have used some help. Especially, during The 500 weekend…. The wait time for our food was over an HOUR, all be it a fantastic stromboli and the perfect crust of the 18″ supreme pizza was crisp all the way to the middle!!
They also have in house delivery. NOT Uber…. Great folks, and fun environment. Good food must take time because, DAMN it took a HOT minute for us to get our food … Maybe try on a less busy night?? We went Friday 2/13/26… ✌️
… moreRobin Strickland
Was shopping with my friend Ronnie in the plaza and noticed Gabbie’s Pizza so we popped in for lunch. I am a New Yorker and heard familiar accents so I knew the pizza would be delicious! When we left we took home a menu and went back tĥe same evening with more people to enjoy more pizza and wings. Dawn and Denise were welcoming and funny. It felt like family, can’t wait to go back
… moreTeresa Pezzulo
Italian sub . The meat and cheese on the sub was great but the sub roll was awful. The roll is as important as the rest of the sub. Hope you consider this and maybe make a change… the raviolis were delish . My husband enjoyed them.
… moreYvonne
Ordered a buffalo chicken pizza. When we got home found a cheese pizza with chicken chunks on top and no buffalo sauce. When we called the manager stated that they usually give you a cup of buffalo sauce but she forgot. She said she’d make sure that she gave us one next time. Really?! There won’t be a next time don’t have to worry about the buffalo sauce.
Update: please do not try to make yourself look better by saying you offered a refund. My husband brought the pizza back to show you that there was nothing on the pizza other than cheese and some chunks of chicken. He was given a container of buffalo sauce. There was no mention of refund, there wasn’t even an offer to possibly remake the pizza. Please do not try to make yourself look good. This review very much stays as it was written.
… more