Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
We specialize in NY style Deli sandwiches. Our go to’s are the simple bacon, egg, and cheese on a NY style Kaiser roll for breakfast, and for lunch our pride lies in the breaded chicken cutlet(which we freshly bread daily and make to order), of which we have a well variety of signature sandwiches. As for the morning crowd, the strongest running contender is the Tusker (a classic Bacon, egg and cheese topped with a hash-brown, and drizzled with hot sauce). A simple concoction, but made to perfection ?.. as for a hearty lunch sandwich, the younger crowd loves our self titled Froggy. Seemingly, a bit decadent, but sometimes you have give the people what they want.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1620 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509
Phone: (845) 490-4013
Website: https://www.myfroggys.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Froggy’s Brewster, NY
… froggys-brewster-ny/. Froggy’s Brewster, NY. 1620 NY-22, NY 10509. Hours of … Sandwiches. January, February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September …
Froggy’s Sandwiches
We specialize in NY-style “Deli” sandwiches. Our go to’s are the simple bacon, egg, and cheese on a NY style Kaiser roll for breakfast, and for lunch.
Froggy’s Sandwiches – Order Online
Sign in for a faster ordering experience. Only accepting scheduled orders. Froggy’s Sandwiches – Brewster, NY …
Reviews
Jonathan Gonzalez
This deli is fantastic. I’ve been stopping in on my lunch break for the last few months and I always get a great sandwich whether it’s off their breakfast menu or their signature lunch sandwiches. The staff and management are amicable and really pleasant even if you’re arriving a few minutes before they close. I usually get a lunch sandwich as a wrap but they’re also available as wedges or kaiser rolls
… moreAaron D
First time at this froggys location. I ordered a BEC on a roll and Home fries. Home fries were ice cold in the middle. Only the bottom and sides were “warm” meaning they microwaved them and not fresh. I included a picture of The sandwich. I don’t believe I’ve had any experience like this. They did reheat the homefries.
… moreFive-Star Fred
Revising my original review, and increasing to 4-stars.
Decent deli, good location. Clean and eat-in tables available.
Good quality food, not Boar’s Head meat, which in retrospect is probably a good thing these days
Make sure you get your froggy’s sandwich card!
My original complaint stands; limited selection of sides, only Joe’s Potato Chips and Doritos. It would be nice to have a bigger selection. What’s wrong with pretzels? You guys got something against potato sticks or plantain chips?
… moreDecent deli, good location. Clean and eat-in tables available.
Good quality food, not Boar’s Head meat, which in retrospect is probably a good thing these days
Make sure you get your froggy’s sandwich card!
My original complaint stands; limited selection of sides, only Joe’s Potato Chips and Doritos. It would be nice to have a bigger selection. What’s wrong with pretzels? You guys got something against potato sticks or plantain chips?
Joy Ruffin
Staff was amazing. Super friendly. The food is fresh and there are no words to describe how tasty the food is
… moreDavid Bongiovanni
Great stop for sandwiches on the way to Thunder Ridge. Expansive menu. Opens early.
… moreRhay D
Love the Gluten free cheese bread sandwiches!! So good!!
Do really like their regular coffee & iced coffee.
The orders came out wrong on 2 different occasions though when called to order at the Brewster location, but probably someone new still learning… They are also a really busy place at lunch time.
… moreDo really like their regular coffee & iced coffee.
The orders came out wrong on 2 different occasions though when called to order at the Brewster location, but probably someone new still learning… They are also a really busy place at lunch time.
Danny Milano
The highlight of my day. I got to Froggys in Brewster every morning on my coffee break. I order 2 to 6 breakfast sandwich on week days and 20 plus on weekend for the guys in the shop. Every day the sandwich’s are great and they nail the sometime very complex orders everyday. I can not say enough good thing about the great staff. The manger Chris is great and alway ensure the food is ready on time and of the highest quality. I will be a customer for life.
… moreRenee Cellio
I just discovered you guys on DoorDash recently and OMG. My new favorite deli in the world . I get the Philly cheesesteak bowl now weekly, because it is absolutely delicious. But I have also ordered sandwiches and sides and everything is delicious, fresh. I can’t say enough . So glad I found this place!
… moreJames Malaguit
Not really a fan of their new lunch card policy. It doesn’t work with breakfast sandwiches anymore, even though it used to. The funny thing is, it works with lunch items like a Philly cheese steak. But as soon as I add eggs to a Philly cheese steak, it doesn’t work anymore.
In response to the owner:
Every time I order from there, I always grab a variation of what used to be called the lanzadoodle on a wedge. Essentially a steak egg and bacon with a variation of cheese and vegetables. Since it’s not there anymore, I always do a custom order, but essentially always get the same thing. They always charge me somewhere between $12 and $15. But today, they told me that it is not something that can count towards the lunch card anymore. Only the Goliath, which is cheaper.
… moreIn response to the owner:
Every time I order from there, I always grab a variation of what used to be called the lanzadoodle on a wedge. Essentially a steak egg and bacon with a variation of cheese and vegetables. Since it’s not there anymore, I always do a custom order, but essentially always get the same thing. They always charge me somewhere between $12 and $15. But today, they told me that it is not something that can count towards the lunch card anymore. Only the Goliath, which is cheaper.
L M
Delicious food!! A must stop for lunch sandwiches in this area! Definitely recommend. Would love this place even more if they said “thanks for coming” as we left. But we are in NY. So they were awesome!
… more