Mary Fish
Easy to order online and got $3off the pickup. Took about 15 minutes longer than quoted but nbd. Staff was friendly. Wings were big and fresh and the Buffalo Garlic had a nice kick but not a lingering hot. Good amount of extra sauce to dip the pizza crust in. Decent price for wings nowadays. XL pizza is probably the equivalent of a sheet, feeds about 6-8 depending on your appetite. Pizza dough was baked just right and the crust was crisp and chewy. Sauce didn’t give me heartburn, big plus. Would have like two more blue cheese cups for 50 wings but not an issue, next time we know to ask. Overall good first time.
… moreTara Ellsworth
The food is awesome. Chicken alfredo may just be the best I’ve ever had.
Fried dough. YES!!
Note: Small= small pizza box
Large= a large pizza box
Staff ate good. No complaints.
Dined in once, probably won’t do that again. Its a small dining area, tables wernt wipped clean and this one fly made me crazy. Literally only 1 fly in the middle of summer. Im a frequent flyer at fratello’s, n that’s not gonna change!
… moreMichael Polak
We had traditional fish fries with macaroni salad & coleslaw. My food smelled so good I forgot to take pictures before I started eating. My wife had a side salad with Italian dressing and I had an order of onion rings for which they gave me some buffalo sauce for dipping. We both had diet pepsi. We were talking and all of a sudden we heard guitar music and realized there was a man walking around with an electric guitar singing songs over the sound system. He actually did a good job. Our auburn haired waitress was very polite, sociable & attentive to our needs. We enjoyed ourselves.
… moreSean Filkins
Paid 77.00 dollars for pizza with extra cheese and extra crispy wings. The pizza was under cooked with what seemed to be very little cheese and the wings well they definitely were not extra crispy. The wings were cooked like they were baked in an over. Lately it seems like their service and quality of an order is gone down hill with the price going up. I will not order from here anymore and that’s to bad because I sometimes order several times per week. I do not recommend this place to anyone and will not recommend this place to anyone anymore.
… moreTom and Traci Waters
My husband and I went to dinner last night and it was amazing! Staff was super friendly and the food was perfect. I had the lasagna which is the best I’ve ever had! Both my husband and my brother had chicken parm and eggplant layered with ricotta and greens. They both loved theirs too. We had more than half to eat for leftovers. You could easily get 3 meals out of 1. Great atmosphere. Can’t wait to go back! We were too full to try the chocolate strawberry cheesecake. Next time for sure!
… moreMary A
I ordered delivery so, unable to rate their atmosphere, but their pizza was the best I’ve had since NYC pizza!! Crisp, cheesy, foldable! Sauce, perfect!! If I could give them 100 stars, I wouldn’t hesitate!
… moreBilly Miller
Just got home from getting food from Fratello’s. Food’s usually good. Fries are not even cooked all the way. Got some loaded fries they’re smothered in cheese sauce and nothing else. Maybe 4 crumbles of bacon. Won’t be getting these again
… moreEdward LeFever
Ex large pizza was very good, but please be sure to double check delivery instructions when placing order, they went to legion in Herkimer when told specifically the legion on S. Litchfield st in frankfort causing 45min delay in delivery for event. Food was good tho,
… moreFat Giga
The Atmosphere is good and it has enough oxygen the food is good BUT the service was quit spiteful and She was a school “friend/aquantince” 1 star this her. All jokes aside this is great service and the food is grate and I love the lively ness
… moreChris Morgan
Fratello’s food is awesome, and the staff is great! The subs and pizza are better than most of the places in the area, and they offer a massive number of items on their menu. Everything i have tried has been excellent.
The restaurant is comfortable and nostalgic of the old pizza places from my youth. This is a great place, and I look forward to coming back!
… more