Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Friday | 4 PM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 4 PM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 4–11 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 209 3rd St, New Cumberland, PA 17070
Phone: (717) 774-4781
Website: http://fratellistownetavern.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fratelli’s Towne Tavern | Restaurant | New Cumberland, PA
We are open Monday thru Thursday 4pm -12am , Friday & Saturday 4pm – 1am & Sundays 4pm – 10pm. Our kitchen closes at 9:00pm Monday thru Saturday and 8:00pm on …
Fratelli’s – Updated 2026, Italian Restaurant in New Cumberland, PA
Fratelli’s Towne Tavern is New Cumberland’s home for a fun night out and great classic American fare, serving elevated pub grub in its relaxing atmosphere.
Fratelli’s Towne Tavern – Discover the Best Hometown Bar in New …
Fratelli’s Towne Tavern. 4.1 ( 308 reviews ). Open Now 04:00 PM – 12:00 AM See Hours. $10–20. 209 3rd St, New Cumberland, PA 17070, United States. +1 717-774- …
Reviews
Miss Val
We came here on a Friday night in November for live music and dinner. We had been wanting to try this place out and saw a musician we like was performing so we decided to finally come check it out.
We sat a the bar. The bartender was cool, she seemed to be very busy. I’m not entirely sure how big the place is, but it seemed like there was a separate dining area because she was constantly moving and cranking drinks out. They had plenty of domestic beers, if you like local craft beers there isn’t a lot to choose from. I didn’t see a drink menu, we weren’t offered one and I didn’t ask so I had a Troeg’s on draft.
We ordered two pasta meals that came with salads – the weekend special and grandmas gravy. I will say the portion sizes were very generous. We could have shared one and still taken home leftovers. Had I known it was going to be that much food I think we would have done that. Both were good and we did take leftovers home.
The atmosphere was that of a hometown bar, relaxed and casual. The music was in the bar area and it was loud but we could still hear each other. Prices were good especially considering the food portions.
We parked a half a block away on the street. I didn’t see a parking lot but there may have been one somewhere.
We had a good time.
… moreWe sat a the bar. The bartender was cool, she seemed to be very busy. I’m not entirely sure how big the place is, but it seemed like there was a separate dining area because she was constantly moving and cranking drinks out. They had plenty of domestic beers, if you like local craft beers there isn’t a lot to choose from. I didn’t see a drink menu, we weren’t offered one and I didn’t ask so I had a Troeg’s on draft.
We ordered two pasta meals that came with salads – the weekend special and grandmas gravy. I will say the portion sizes were very generous. We could have shared one and still taken home leftovers. Had I known it was going to be that much food I think we would have done that. Both were good and we did take leftovers home.
The atmosphere was that of a hometown bar, relaxed and casual. The music was in the bar area and it was loud but we could still hear each other. Prices were good especially considering the food portions.
We parked a half a block away on the street. I didn’t see a parking lot but there may have been one somewhere.
We had a good time.
Matt Bitner
Update 3: the vaping seems to have stopped which was great to see. The food was delicious as well.
Update 2: Vaping seems to be a bit rampant with the employees here. We noted one of the staff unable to remove their vape from their hand to serve our drinks and food. Another employee was taking breaks at the end of the bar to vape and check their phone with empty drinks at the bar. We did enjoy the loaded fries and the bar pie, but the open vaping from employees and customers, although legal, is very disturbing.
Update: they took the Nacho’s off the menu and that smell is still there, but all else is the same. There was a stuffed shell special that was very tasty, the pulled pork sandwich was as well. The Buffalo chicken wrap did leave something to be desired though.
I love coming to Fratelli’s. The homemade Italian dishes are great, but the Nacho’s are my favorite. Its the only Nacho’s I’ve ever had that need more chips, there’s so many toppings!! The entrees also come with some nice complimentary bread thats delicious. Only issue is there is a musty smell when you first walk in, but soon after you do not notice it. Service was great as well
… moreUpdate 2: Vaping seems to be a bit rampant with the employees here. We noted one of the staff unable to remove their vape from their hand to serve our drinks and food. Another employee was taking breaks at the end of the bar to vape and check their phone with empty drinks at the bar. We did enjoy the loaded fries and the bar pie, but the open vaping from employees and customers, although legal, is very disturbing.
Update: they took the Nacho’s off the menu and that smell is still there, but all else is the same. There was a stuffed shell special that was very tasty, the pulled pork sandwich was as well. The Buffalo chicken wrap did leave something to be desired though.
I love coming to Fratelli’s. The homemade Italian dishes are great, but the Nacho’s are my favorite. Its the only Nacho’s I’ve ever had that need more chips, there’s so many toppings!! The entrees also come with some nice complimentary bread thats delicious. Only issue is there is a musty smell when you first walk in, but soon after you do not notice it. Service was great as well
Michael Maxwell
I’ve lived in New Cumberland for 4 years and only learned about Fratelli’s a few days ago so my wife and I decided to go for the first time. I immediately loved the vide as soon as we walked in. Sunday night football so the bar was a little rowdy but that’s to be expected.
Unfortunately we didn’t catch the servers name but she couldn’t have been nicer. She was very welcoming and engaging. She seemed proud to work for such a cozy little place.
I got grandmas gravy and my wife got pizza. We were very pleased with our meal. The food is homemade and delicious!
Highly recommend and will definitely be going back!
… moreUnfortunately we didn’t catch the servers name but she couldn’t have been nicer. She was very welcoming and engaging. She seemed proud to work for such a cozy little place.
I got grandmas gravy and my wife got pizza. We were very pleased with our meal. The food is homemade and delicious!
Highly recommend and will definitely be going back!
D S
Great food and excellent service. Really cool small town tavern with friendly employees. The wings and pizza are best in the area. Burgers are perfectly cooked. Server was on top of her game all night. Never left an empty drink.
… moreDoug Blodgett
Went here in July 2025 after seeing a video online. This place is a hidden gem. The bar pie/pizza was absolutely amazing delicious. They make their own crust and sauce.The service was good and wait staff was excellent.
… moreKristina Carpenter
Best bar & Italian food in central PA! Pizza and pasta were absolutely delicious. My Fratty Patty was so tasty. Comedy night was awesome! Love this bar
… moreChristy Leedy
Great food, atmosphere, music,and service. The bartenders are awesome.They often have live music and events like Trivia Tuesday. Daily specials. Crowd is of all ages. Their bar pie/pizza is my favorite. Homemade dough and sauce. Toppings are a 1.50 each but it is very worth it.
… moreSharon Kreiser
Do yourself a favor and visit this amazing tavern in NewCumberland.The service was great. The what I think might have been the owner truly seemed to care that everything was perfect. The food is absolutely amazing and everything we ordered was so good and the portions were huge.Absolutely the best Italian food I had ever . Highly recommend eating there. I will definitely go back
… moreLarry Novak
Excellent!! Came back to Fratellies for a surprise bday celebration. The waitres was outstanding and she had numerous tables. The food was excellent (12 people). Thank you for making this once in a lifetime thing so wonderful.
… moreDarvin Burnside
Excellent food, stop in for someplace different. Sat at the bar, got the bar pie and wings. Everything was good, great service also. New Cumberland is such a nice town for dinner
… more