Fratelli’s is an independent, locally owned family business. We make our dough daily from scratch and cook our own sauces. We even blend our own salad dressings. The dishes that we make are not made ahead, but made to order. Our recipes come from family members who have pizza parlors in Brooklyn, NY and New Jersey for over 30 years.
No-frills eatery with a casual vibe & sports on TV, serving classic New York-style pizza & calzones.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 6890 Tylersville Rd, West Chester Township, OH 45069
Phone: (513) 777-5061
Website: http://www.fratellispizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fratelli’s | Fratelli’s Pizza
FRATELLI’S PIZZERIA WILL BE CLOSED 3/31/26-4/5/26 FOR OUR EASTER BREAK. Call … © Fratelli’s Restaurants of America 2023.
Fratelli’s Pizzeria 6890 Tylersville Rd. West Chester, OH 45069 513 …
Fratelli’s Pizzeria 6890 Tylersville Rd. West Chester, OH 45069 513-777-5061 fratellispizzeria.com Large 18″ The New Yorker Pizza (Pepperoni …
Fratelli’s Pizzeria, 6890 Tylersville Rd, West Chester, OH 45069, US
Fratelli’s Pizzeria is a family-owned establishment in West Chester, OH, offering a delectable selection of pizza and sandwiches.
Reviews
Ryan Gulley
If you are craving real NY style pizza but do not feel like hopping a flight, Fratellis Pizzeria has you covered. Their pizza is so authentically New York that I half expected it to greet me like an old friend.
The crust is thin, foldable, and has an undercarriage so perfectly crisp it deserves its own fan club. Seriously, this thing could support a small family. It is sturdy, golden, and somehow both crunchy and chewy in that magical way only true pizza wizards can pull off.
The sauce is bright and balanced. The cheese is generous without being chaotic. The whole slice is a beautiful triangle of happiness.
Fratellis does not just serve pizza. They serve moved NY style pizza, as in it clearly packed its bags, relocated, and brought all its best traits with it. And thank goodness, because my taste buds are better for it.
If you love great pizza with personality, this is your spot. If you do not love great pizza, I am not sure we can be friends.
… moreThe crust is thin, foldable, and has an undercarriage so perfectly crisp it deserves its own fan club. Seriously, this thing could support a small family. It is sturdy, golden, and somehow both crunchy and chewy in that magical way only true pizza wizards can pull off.
The sauce is bright and balanced. The cheese is generous without being chaotic. The whole slice is a beautiful triangle of happiness.
Fratellis does not just serve pizza. They serve moved NY style pizza, as in it clearly packed its bags, relocated, and brought all its best traits with it. And thank goodness, because my taste buds are better for it.
If you love great pizza with personality, this is your spot. If you do not love great pizza, I am not sure we can be friends.
Dwayne Baker
New York style pizza at its best! Whole pies or by the slice! Clean & casual atmosphere. We had a large cheese and bacon pie. We will definitely be back!
… moreJon Sawyer
Fratelli’s isn’t your average pizza joint. These guys do it right! I’ve tried pizza from the Atlantic to the Pacific and these guys are up on the top. By far the best pizza in the city! I recently picked up a large cheese and I’m ready to do it again. Highly recommend to anyone looking for some great pizza!
… moreAshley Shepherd
Fratelli’s has been my and my husband’s favorite pizza spot for a long time. We live about 40 mins away, but it’s SO worth the drive. Nice thin crust, delicious pizza, try the Craiger (ultimate meat pizza), you won’t regret it. Also, the staff is made up of mostly young people and they’re all phenomenal and very kind. Pay them a visit, you won’t regret it!
… morehighnightflyer
The first time I came here right before they went on vacation I thought how brilliant the pizza and service was! Traditional NY pizza that bent when you picked it up, crust was tender and taste was AMAZING! The staff was attentive and extremely helpful.
I not so patiently waited until they came back from vacation to try it again. First day they reopened I came back in and such a huge difference. The pizza dough was overworked and overcooked. It was so tough I could barely cut most of it with the knife they provided. Not one of the staff members came over to see how I was doing, offer me a box, or a refill on my drink. The music was so loud you couldn’t think and I typically don’t mind louder music but I definitely got a headache while sitting there.
I don’t know if the first time was the norm or today is but I won’t be rushing back after this experience which is sad because I thought I finally had found a wonderful place to get a good pizza around here.
… moreI not so patiently waited until they came back from vacation to try it again. First day they reopened I came back in and such a huge difference. The pizza dough was overworked and overcooked. It was so tough I could barely cut most of it with the knife they provided. Not one of the staff members came over to see how I was doing, offer me a box, or a refill on my drink. The music was so loud you couldn’t think and I typically don’t mind louder music but I definitely got a headache while sitting there.
I don’t know if the first time was the norm or today is but I won’t be rushing back after this experience which is sad because I thought I finally had found a wonderful place to get a good pizza around here.
Bre B
We ordered takeout, and the food traveled ok.
1. Garlic knots with cheese – great flavors, had we eaten there, I think the texture would have been better. (4/5 )
2. New York style – this was pretty good it needed to be reheated, but that’s expected of this style. Once reheated, it was pretty tasty slightly on the oily side. (4/5 )
3. Steak hoagie – overall great flavors. However, the bun was a little soggy from the travel. I suspect if we had eaten as soon as prepared, it would have been better. (4/5 )
Overall, it’s a great pizza place we will be ordering again for the New York style pizza.
… more1. Garlic knots with cheese – great flavors, had we eaten there, I think the texture would have been better. (4/5 )
2. New York style – this was pretty good it needed to be reheated, but that’s expected of this style. Once reheated, it was pretty tasty slightly on the oily side. (4/5 )
3. Steak hoagie – overall great flavors. However, the bun was a little soggy from the travel. I suspect if we had eaten as soon as prepared, it would have been better. (4/5 )
Overall, it’s a great pizza place we will be ordering again for the New York style pizza.
Jim Harrell (LarderRoom)
LarderRoom…Voted LarderRoom best New York Style Pizza of 2022…Fratelli’s Pizzeria. So of course we rang in the New Year with family and a few pies. Add some hot sauces and we brought in 2023 with heat! Love the Craiger, The Italian and the white pizza. Heck, I love all their Pizzas. Meatballs are awesome too! See you again soon.
… moreJames Light
You want authentic New York style pizza with real home made crust. the Sauce is so flavorful and the service is the best.. And did I mention real toppings plentiful. Mr Wonderful eats there on a regular basis.
… moreR Anderson
I ordered the large Hawaiian pizza to go. The service was polite and quick. The pizza though, was over cooked both by taste and by the fact that the crust did not bend – literally like a piece of cardboard. The toppings were also somewhat limited on the pizza.
… moreThomas Jay
This was very good pizza. We got one large meat pizza and one medium vegetable pizza and they were both as close to New York style as you can get without being in New York. I think the large tasted more like authentic New York style than the medium, but we were happy with both. Definitely coming back. Friendly staff, clean restaurant, & and reasonable prices.
… more