Welcome to Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant! We offer fine-dining Italian in a wonderful lakeside setting. We also have several party rooms for any event large or small. Stop by today or if you can not make it to us – no problem – we will come to you. You can now place your order online and we will deliver to your home or office.
Casual spot offering pizzas & basic Italian fare, plus a huge patio with Lake Mahopac views.
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 654 US-6, Mahopac, NY 10541
Phone: (845) 628-4404
Website: http://fourbrothersmahopac.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: fourbrothersmahopac.com
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza Mahopac, NY | Four Brothers
Welcome to Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant! We offer an fine dining Italian in a wonderful lakeside setting. We also have several party rooms for any event …
Restaurant Menu – Pizza Mahopac, NY | Four Brothers
Served in a vodka sauce. $14.95. Appetizer Sampler Mozzarella sticks, Buffalo wings & zucchini sticks. $17.50. Soup …
Locations | Four Brothers Pizza Inn
Dover Plains, NY 12522 (845) 877-3662. Since 1976. Hillsdale. 2828 Route 23. Hillsdale, NY 12529 (518) 325-7300. Since 1979. Mahopac. 654 Route 6. Mahopac, NY …
Last Updates
Reviews
Diana Mor
Absolutely delicious! I had the chicken Alfredo and it was on point.
Drinks were great. I told our waiter I liked fruity flavored drinks and he recommended me one that even my friends ended up ordering cause it was that good.
Our waiter was amazing, very attentive and made us feel so welcome.
Leave room for dessert. Best carrot cake we ever had along with the adult hot chocolate. These are a must try. Added to my favorites!
… moreDrinks were great. I told our waiter I liked fruity flavored drinks and he recommended me one that even my friends ended up ordering cause it was that good.
Our waiter was amazing, very attentive and made us feel so welcome.
Leave room for dessert. Best carrot cake we ever had along with the adult hot chocolate. These are a must try. Added to my favorites!
Gus Cruz
Had an amazing time with family, great food and drinks. Atmosphere was terrific.
… moreZafiro Acevedo
Preparation is essential to determine if food is delicious in a restaurant. This gorgeous Italian restaurant & bar has plenty of free parking, no reserved, wheelchair accessibility, and restroom. Excellent for large gatherings, couples, and private parties. Excellent bilingual staff, accommodations seating booth or table, overall an excellent vibe. Depending on the meal, all dishes come in medium to small portions. Dessert menus has plenty of options. Highly recommend.
… moreDaniel Donnelly
This is the ninth and final branch of Four Brothers which I review. By far this is one of the most charming locations, set alongside Mahopac lake. The food is exquisite, and the waitstaff friendly. The bathrooms are clean, and there is a full bar with about three beers on draft. In July 2025, former candidate for NY Governor Larry Sharpe appeared at this location.
… moreMildred vega
We would like to thank John and his staff for an successful wonderful time this is place for any occasion so far we have done our daughter college graduation and now my son’s engagement. The food was excellent. Can’t asked for anything more, your staff was beyond helpful. Again thank you and hope to see you soon.
… morenicholas yannaco
Tonight was a great dining experience. We were very fortunate to get Michelle as our server. She was attentive, precise and warm. I enjoyed the fresh ravioli and the homemade Russian dressing. The place had an excellent energy. Two thumbs up. We will be back.
… moreMia Rickenbach
We go here regularly personally but also use them to cater for business. All the food is so great. The best Caesar we’ve ever had. We order trays of it for meetings and it’s gone immediately. One time we ate so much and ordered another “emergency” large tray which they kindly made and ran it over to us so we could continue our meeting. Amazing family business.
… moreManuel Velez
Atmosphere excellent, beautiful visual and live music. Relaxed friendly patrons. The food was okay, not great, but not bad. The service was not strong. Wasn’t crowded and plenty of staff but not available nor looking at tables to see if anyone needed attention. Id still return for scenery and music…. I’ll push for service, and I’ll try diff food.
… moreFrances Gail Augustine
We’ve eaten here about 4 times over all when we’ve come to visit family here. It’s always been good. Today, I don’t know what happened but we went for lunch and we ordered 2 appetizers they both came out cold and the mozzarella sticks were still frozen inside. The waitress immediately apologized and took both appetizers back and came back with fresh hot ones. They were so good.
Our entrees came, and they were good but not great. My husband had ordered chicken parm, but they brought him eggplant parm. He did not tell the waitress because he felt bad that she was training and we had already sent the appetizers back.
I would definitely recommend this place. I just think it was an off day for the chef or whatever that was going on that day. The atmosphere of great too.
… moreOur entrees came, and they were good but not great. My husband had ordered chicken parm, but they brought him eggplant parm. He did not tell the waitress because he felt bad that she was training and we had already sent the appetizers back.
I would definitely recommend this place. I just think it was an off day for the chef or whatever that was going on that day. The atmosphere of great too.
Kay Cee
Edit: came here for dinner during a snowy day. They were able to sit a party of 5 relatively quick (thank you weather). We ordered multiple appetizers and drinks along with our main meals. Everyone enjoyed and our waiter was wonderful.
Four Brothers is one of the places to go in Mahopac to eat with a great view of the lake. The drinks and food were great. The salad I ordered is considered to be an individual portion, but could easily feed four people.
The service was the only reason for 4 stars instead of 5. We waited close to 20 minutes before my boyfriend grabbed the attention of a busser for a waiter to come to the table. It was understandable it was busy, but it felt as though we were forgotten. We still had great service from a new waitress once she came over.
… moreFour Brothers is one of the places to go in Mahopac to eat with a great view of the lake. The drinks and food were great. The salad I ordered is considered to be an individual portion, but could easily feed four people.
The service was the only reason for 4 stars instead of 5. We waited close to 20 minutes before my boyfriend grabbed the attention of a busser for a waiter to come to the table. It was understandable it was busy, but it felt as though we were forgotten. We still had great service from a new waitress once she came over.