Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 81 Main St, Farmingdale, NJ 07727
Phone: (732) 256-4633
Website: http://fourboysicecream.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
FARMINGDALE | My Site – Four Boys Ice Cream
Now closed! See you for the 2026 season! CONTACT. ADDRESSES. Englishtown Shop: 3 Tennent, Avenue, Englishtown, NJ 07726.
Four Boys Ice Cream
New Jersey based family ice cream business – Four Boys Ice Cream is your classic small-town ice cream shop!
Four Boys Ice Cream Farmingdale – Home | Facebook
Mentions ; . Page · Ice Cream Shop ; . 250 people checked in here ; . 81 Main Street, Farmingdale, NJ 07725.
Reviews
Chris S
Great spot for ice cream on a hot summer day! Perfect for a treat after getting dinner from Harvest right next door…
You’ll have some trouble with parking on some busy days but the ice cream makes up for it!
Pictured is the hard ice cream double fudge brownie flavor.. Portion sizes are also huge!
… moreYou’ll have some trouble with parking on some busy days but the ice cream makes up for it!
Pictured is the hard ice cream double fudge brownie flavor.. Portion sizes are also huge!
Chris Wagner
Terrible experience today. No employees to be found when I arrived around 4pm. Eventually a young lady wearing pajama bottoms and a hoodie came wandering to the window. Had to say hello to her twice before she responded. She then proceeded to make a poor excuse of a Sunday with hard as a rock “hot fudge”. Whipped cream was running down the side of the container with ice cream as well. She handed it to me without any napkins. I should have said no thanks. Would not waste my money or time here again. If you’re going to work in customer service you probably she have some social skills.
… moreSebastian Ortega
A great ice cream spot that always satisfies my cravings. We head here almost every weekend and the service is spot on. They come out with new flavors frequently and give huge portions. Their waffle boat is my favorite! If you have a sweet tooth, this is definetly the place to go!
… moreLeah
Great ice cream! About a 10 minute drive for me which is a bit long for ice cream but totally worth it. Staff is friendly and it’s some of the best ice cream around.
… moreJennifer
Four Boys Ice Cream shop just opened up next to the restaurant Harvest. The ice cream is really good! It’s home made ice cream, and they have lots of flavors to choose from. The ice cream is rich and decadent just how I like it. They give a generous amount for a reasonable price. I had the pumpkin pie and the double fudge brownie flavors. Both were DELICIOUS! I can’t wait to come back and try some more. I recommend Four Boys Ice Cream In Farmingdale!
… moreJoseph Ruggiero
10/17/25 8:58pm online it says open till 9:30pm girl inside said no we’re close. After acting like she didn’t see me at the window. Played yourself. I always leave a good tip.
… morePeter
Been here 5-7 times since they opened, thoroughly unimpressed everytime. Tonight was final straw (full pun intended). Somehow a large, hard vanilla milkshake tasted horrific, for the first time in my life, I threw it out after drinking like 10% of it. Like how does that get messed up?! The other times, ice cream was bland or icy or both
… moreNycidoitright Lucky
Absolutely perfect ice cream always! Excellent service and always perfect! Thank you Ladies
… moreJared Eagle
Went for a Sundae, they were out of whipped cream. No problem, but then ordered the Chocolate Peanut butter hard ice cream and they were also out of that. Settled for a waffle cone with soft ice cream. Ordered the vanilla/chocolate swirl but they don’t have that either, just separate machines for each flavor.
The girl working there was nice.
Overall just not a good experience for me. My wife however did really like it. Take that for what it is worth. Unlikely I would return.
… moreThe girl working there was nice.
Overall just not a good experience for me. My wife however did really like it. Take that for what it is worth. Unlikely I would return.
Sandeep Gunjotikar
We just love this place irrespective of season !! It’s right next to Thompson Park in Monroe, so location is absolutely perfect. I personally like Maple Walnut. Kids love Cookies and cream, Vanilla Fudge, Mint chocolate chips. Point is you can not go wrong. Don’t miss it, if you are in neighborhood!!!
… more