Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 169 Queen St, Lindsay, ON K9V 1H5, Canada
Phone: +1 705-878-8188
Website: http://lindsaypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Formerly Tony’s Pizza – The Best Pizza & Wings in Lindsay & Beyond
Formerly Tonys Daily Specials. Formerly Tony’s Best Pizza and Wings | 705-878-8188 169 Queen St., Lindsay, ON. Copyright © 2026 Formerly Tony’s Pizza. Call Now …
Tony’s Best Pizza & Wings | Lindsay ON – Facebook
Tony’s Best Pizza & Wings ; Details. . 92% recommend (59 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . 169 Queen Street, Lindsay, ON, Canada, K9V 1H5 ; Links. .
Formerly Tony’s, Kawartha Lakes, ON – Wanderlog
Formerly Tony’s, the renowned pizza joint in town, has earned a … 169 Queen St, Lindsay, ON K9V 1H5, Canada. Saturday: 11AM–11PM. SuMoTuWeThFrSa
Reviews
Parb Dasu
Went to Formally’s Tony Pizza with my family, including two kids, and had a great experience! We ordered a veggie pizza and some French fries—both were fresh and delicious. The garlic dipping sauce was a hit, and the cookies were warm, fresh, and super tasty. The atmosphere was family-friendly, and service was smooth. Overall, a really good experience and we’ll definitely be coming back!
… moreJamie Cooper
Everytime I go in for a slice for my kid u can tell its been sitting all day when ask for anything different than pizza or wings on the menu they cant do it or will take 40min so we decline got 2 lbs of wings recently cause my kid wanted pizza i live right beside it so for convenience we tried it again the wings were 5 seconds away from undercooked rubbery was so disgusted didn’t even want to eat wings after that 2lbs of wings and 2 slices 50bucks well now I know I wont be going back
… moreJeevana Premachandran
Best pizza I’ve had in a while! We ordered the deluxe and it was loaded with generous toppings. Every bite was packed with flavour!
… moreMatt houser
Pizza was decent. So was the panzeratti. Probably one of the better pizza places in Lindsay. If they made the pizza sauce in house id probably drop a 4 star.
… moreErick Thurston
This place makes such a delicious pizza I’ve made four take out orders within ten days of it reopening. My favourite pizza ever and it ain’t even close.
Toppings: plentiful, high quality and appropriately distributed. The pineapple had the right crunch, but wasn’t soggy. The bacon was healthy pieces, cooked to perfection. Ham chucks were diced finely enough that there was a little in every bite and they didn’t overpower either of the other toppings.
Crust: Goldilocks style – not too crispy, not too doughy, juuuust right. Not too thick, not too thin, it was the precise thickness required to give you a satisfying crunch without being burnt. Sturdy enough that when you hold it one handed it doesn’t flop all over. Look in my photos for how perfectly browned it was around the edges.
Sauce/cheese: this two things were joined together in a culinary harmony that only enhanced the other two aspects above. The ratio of the two was so precise across the pizza, I suspect a Ph.D student wrote a thesis on how to distribute them optimally.
What kinda madman writes a review this detailed about pizza? The type of fella who would divorce his wife and marry this restaurant.
All 22,367 citizens of this great City need to experience the euphoria. If you haven’t been in here, close your browser and get on the phone.
Check the photos, place your order and you too will be saving Formerly Tony’s under “Best. Pizza. Ever.” in your contacts.
… moreToppings: plentiful, high quality and appropriately distributed. The pineapple had the right crunch, but wasn’t soggy. The bacon was healthy pieces, cooked to perfection. Ham chucks were diced finely enough that there was a little in every bite and they didn’t overpower either of the other toppings.
Crust: Goldilocks style – not too crispy, not too doughy, juuuust right. Not too thick, not too thin, it was the precise thickness required to give you a satisfying crunch without being burnt. Sturdy enough that when you hold it one handed it doesn’t flop all over. Look in my photos for how perfectly browned it was around the edges.
Sauce/cheese: this two things were joined together in a culinary harmony that only enhanced the other two aspects above. The ratio of the two was so precise across the pizza, I suspect a Ph.D student wrote a thesis on how to distribute them optimally.
What kinda madman writes a review this detailed about pizza? The type of fella who would divorce his wife and marry this restaurant.
All 22,367 citizens of this great City need to experience the euphoria. If you haven’t been in here, close your browser and get on the phone.
Check the photos, place your order and you too will be saving Formerly Tony’s under “Best. Pizza. Ever.” in your contacts.
Guesse Kraig
Been coming here for years. When I lived in town it was the go to place to order. Order Extra Oregano and garlic on everything! Cause its free.
Now I live out of town, can’t justify driving in for a pizza, but will stop in for a slice when in town.
Love it.
… moreNow I live out of town, can’t justify driving in for a pizza, but will stop in for a slice when in town.
Love it.
Ash Wol
Best pizza and do I have to mention their wings are to die for!! Every time I go, the owner is so friendly and so nice. He always goes over and beyond to make sure I’m happy. 🙂
… moreDavid
Pretty good pizza, Lindsay is full of pizza chains and this one stands out. The prices are a bit higher but it’s worth the price if you want to support local.
… moreRicky MacQueen
Second time going there and I met the owners. Really nice people who make great pizza. Support local !
… moreCherissa Saulay
Ordered delivery from Formerly Tony’s. Food arrived on time, hot and it was delicious! The delivery driver was friendly and professional.
… more