Brittany
We ordered the largest meat pie and it was delicious. Stacked with toppings; they don’t skimp on the meats.
The bake time was unexpectedly long – 45 minutes. Staff aren’t super friendly and come off as annoyed with customers. As others have noted, it’s basically entirely self serve and buss so there isn’t much customers can bother staff with anyway? It’s also very loud with a mixture of younger people stopping for a beer and families with small children.
+ 1 Star for the Coke Freestyle machine. Wild to see one of those in a small restaurant.
… moreIsmael Diaz
If you like a really good slice of pizza with a great customer service well this is the place and let’s not forget the family originated feeling,had a very nostalgic experience with the pinball machines and Ms.Pacman thank you for the great experience.
… moreZak Jost
Brought the family here and loved it. Don’t come looking for fine dining, but the pizza far exceeded my expectations. I’m from the Midwest and it’s been challenging finding pizza we liked here. The vibe was great and reminded me of the old school pizza places I grew up with.
… moreBigMil
Came across this place just walking around the neighborhood. Once we got in it was warm nice and great music playing. You can order a personal, by the slice, small medium and large. We got 2 slices but definitely would have gotten 2 personals pizza. Pepperoni and cheese 2 classic.
Great pizza l, great crust and great flavor. Definitely will ho back
… moreNick
I am late to posting this review, but wanted to highlight the sweet effort the staff went to in relaying a message to my girlfriend from 1000 miles away! She loved the pizza and wings!
… moreMichael Ansolis
My wife ordered calzones for delivery from this place yesterday. I ate half of one calzone and almost broke my teeth on two unpitted olives. Who uses whole unpitted olives in calzones??? Well, I googled it, and apparently whole olives may be used for better taste and authenticity and at upscale restaurants. That’s great, but I wasn’t expecting this and ended up almost breaking my teeth on the olive pits. Someone should put a warning label on the box or something. The food is great, but I’m taking a star off for my bad experience with the olives.
… moreBobby Mills
10/10 Affordable, fun environment, bar area, ample games / signs / neon’s, friendly welcoming staff, fast, and most importantly DELICIOUS. I got a personal pan pepperoni, Basil, meat balls, cheese and red sauce. Crust is crunchy with chew still and dusted on the bottom, cook perfectly, sauce is flavorful and smooth. Nothing was too greasy or heavy. Perfect amount of tasty mozzarella
… moreShawna Williams
I’ve heard good things about this pizzeria so I decided to order through UberEats. I ordered the original thick crust pepperoni pizza and cheesy bread. The food arrived quickly. I was hoping the crust would be thicker but I like that there was a lot of pepperoni on the pizza, I didn’t have to order extra. Both items were smaller in size than I expected but the flavor was good. For the money I would stick with the other pizza places.
… morePeter Lekhakul
This was a nice place, the staff was super friendly. The beer on tap was fresh. Salad bar was good, not huge but good selection. We went there twice within a month. Both times we had the creamy pesto with added chicken and Combo 2. The first time it was amazing… the pizza was so good and flavorful, crust was perfect (4stars). However, the second time it was busier and the pizza was a bit overcooked and burnt. Disappointed after the first time, that’s why I dropped my review to 3 stars.
… moreBrian Gass
My mind is boggled by the many 5 star reviews this place has. This was honestly the worst pizza I have ever had. In a pinch I’ll crush a Tombstone or Red Barron frozen pizza from the grocery store like a dirty little shame goblin, but I couldn’t bring myself to eat more than a slice from Flying Pie. My expectations were low being that it’s family run pizza place in Issaquah with a cheesey cartoon logo, but I am impressively disappointed.
… more