Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Looking for the best pizza in Gainesville? Five Star Pizza delivers extremely delicious pizza, extremely fast—always fresh and handcrafted with care. We make our dough in-store daily and use premium ingredients like Wisconsin mozzarella, California fresh-packed tomatoes, real meat toppings, crisp veggies, and all-natural chicken wings. Whether you choose speedy delivery or easy pickup, our friendly Gainesville team is ready to serve you. Order today and taste the Five Star difference!
No-frills, counter-serve operation specializing in pizzas, pepperoni rolls & chicken wings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5001 NW 34th Blvd #j, Gainesville, FL 32605
Phone: (352) 378-9606
Website: https://www.fivestarpizza.com/gainesville-north-west-34th-pizza
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Gainesville Downtown | Five Star Pizza | FL
Discover downtown Gainesville’s favorite late-night pizza spot. Enjoy premium pies and speedy service at Five Star Pizza.
Five Star Pizza | FL
Experience fresh, hand-tossed dough and premium toppings at Five Star Pizza in Florida. Order now for fast delivery or carryout!
Gainesville Tower Rd | Five Star Pizza | FL
Five Star is our go-to pizza delivery spot and has been for decades now. Fast, tasty, and affordable. 5-12-2025. Previous Slide Next Slide. Menu Anchor.
Last Updates
Reviews
Kasee Castro
Nothing, and I mean nothing, beats Five Star Pizza.
Born and raised in Florida, and I grew up on this pizza. After moving away, I still have not found anything that compares. Anytime I come back to visit family and friends in Florida, my top priority is to plan when I will be having Five Star Pizza. It is my favorite food. A food group all in its own.
No matter what time of day, no matter what location, you will not be disappointed.
My go-to order is a Pepperoni Powerhouse (double cheese double pepperoni) and I’ll usually throw in the pepperoni rolls or garlic rolls. Absolutely delicious! Gooey, greasy, cheesy, thick, sweet, chewy – it’s perfect. If you’ve ever seen A Goofy Movie, then you know the part where Max and PJ are in the motel room eating pizza – well I always feel like I’m eating that pizza when I eat Five Star.
The consistency of quality, accuracy, flavor, and experience will ensure I will be a lifetime customer and Five Star’s biggest fan. I even stop by on my way to drive back up to Charlotte, NC so I can keep enjoying pizza even after I’m home!
If you’re having a large party, get the Piezilla!! I had a gathering of around 15 people and a Piezilla was actually perfect. Legend has it people still talk about the pizza from this party.
I cannot rave enough. I’ve turned many people into Five Star and changed lives. I’m a hero, if you will.
Anyways, support this place. It’s delicious, it’s quick, it’s consistent, and you won’t be disappointed.
… moreBorn and raised in Florida, and I grew up on this pizza. After moving away, I still have not found anything that compares. Anytime I come back to visit family and friends in Florida, my top priority is to plan when I will be having Five Star Pizza. It is my favorite food. A food group all in its own.
No matter what time of day, no matter what location, you will not be disappointed.
My go-to order is a Pepperoni Powerhouse (double cheese double pepperoni) and I’ll usually throw in the pepperoni rolls or garlic rolls. Absolutely delicious! Gooey, greasy, cheesy, thick, sweet, chewy – it’s perfect. If you’ve ever seen A Goofy Movie, then you know the part where Max and PJ are in the motel room eating pizza – well I always feel like I’m eating that pizza when I eat Five Star.
The consistency of quality, accuracy, flavor, and experience will ensure I will be a lifetime customer and Five Star’s biggest fan. I even stop by on my way to drive back up to Charlotte, NC so I can keep enjoying pizza even after I’m home!
If you’re having a large party, get the Piezilla!! I had a gathering of around 15 people and a Piezilla was actually perfect. Legend has it people still talk about the pizza from this party.
I cannot rave enough. I’ve turned many people into Five Star and changed lives. I’m a hero, if you will.
Anyways, support this place. It’s delicious, it’s quick, it’s consistent, and you won’t be disappointed.
Karon Walker
Best tasting pizza, service & more. I admire a local pizzeria that gives back to our community often. The staff is friendly & delivery super fast. Good, honest pizza. Not foo foo with weird flavored crust & glazes added to hide flavor. Love 5 star.
… moreTamara Scott
We Love Five Star pizza!!! They serve quality ingredients and always give you the right amount of toppings so you can taste them in every bite, I don’t know any other pizza place that does that! We appreciate how they take the time to make their own pizza crust, you can taste the difference of goodness and crispy crust edges when it’s homemade. Five Star has been the only pizza place me & my family order from!!!
… moreMuzzy Behning
Five Star Pizza is a solid late-night option when you need something quick and filling. The pizza is decent — not amazing, but reliable — and the menu has enough variety to cover basic cravings.
Quality can be a little inconsistent depending on the time and how busy they are. Sometimes the pizza is hot and fresh, other times it’s just okay. Prices are reasonable, especially for delivery, and service is usually fine but not standout.
Overall, it gets the job done. Good for convenience and late hours, just don’t expect gourmet pizza.
… moreQuality can be a little inconsistent depending on the time and how busy they are. Sometimes the pizza is hot and fresh, other times it’s just okay. Prices are reasonable, especially for delivery, and service is usually fine but not standout.
Overall, it gets the job done. Good for convenience and late hours, just don’t expect gourmet pizza.
Ms Undy01
I was very disappointed in my pizza, there was hardly any cheese, there was definitely not a cheese pull ☹️. The dough was very thick in certain areas, it was over cooked also there are young people working there and apparently there needs to be better training on how to correctly make a good cheese pull pizza. I love pizza and I decided to try them. I will not be going back. I ate a slice and plan on throwing the rest out in the garbage. I spent $17.42 on a small pizza, ham, pepperoni and sausage, it’s money waisted
… moreAngelo
Five Star is always solid! I order well done I get well done! It’s always my go to and their wings are good too!
… moreJoshua Warner
After paying for my food Online with coupon code they refused to give me my pizza and rolls, unless I went home and get the coupon. Nothing on the coupon says to bring in store and even has a code for online ordering. Manager also had a very long and un groomed beard and Hair! With no hair net or beard guard. Disgusting
… moreK
Always an excellent pizza. I’m very picky about pizza, and when I get a well done, thin crust from 5 star they always come correct. 10/10 on the pizza side. We also get their wings, which are executed well for being baked wings. I wish they had a an actual deep fryer though, which would be the only area I think could be improved. Still, 5 stars for 5 star pizza.
… moreYosbel Pupo Sartorio
I had never ordered in this place before, yesterday I made an order from the wed site and honestly I was surprised with the speed of the home delivery the pizza arrived very hot and the quality not to mention it very good the truth is rarely can you find a pizza of such good quality it is worth every penny
… moreEvan P.
Five Star rules, been eating their pizza for about 25 years. Always consistent and fast. Best pepperoni rolls too!
… more