Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Five Star we are passionate about our pizzas. But we couldn’t deliver the best pizzas without the best staff- the friendliest people to take your order, make your pizza, and deliver it faster than you thought possible! Our simple goal is to exceed your expectations each and every time you order and to make you as passionate about Five Star Pizza as we are. Come try a PIZZA! You will find we are BIGGER, BETTER, & FASTER!
No-frills, counter-serve operation specializing in pizzas, pepperoni rolls & chicken wings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 465 State Rd 13 N, St Johns, FL 32259
Phone: (904) 522-9555
Website: https://fivestarpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Five Star Pizza | FL
Experience fresh, hand-tossed dough and premium toppings at Five Star Pizza in Florida. Order now for fast delivery or carryout!
Five Star Pizza Delivery Menu | 465 State Rd 13, St Johns Saint Johns
Order delivery or pickup from Five Star Pizza in Saint Johns! View Five Star Pizza’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with …
Five Star Pizza 465 State Road 13 N – Order Online
Five Star Pizza. 465 State Road 13 N, St Johns FL 32259-2989, United StatesOnline ordering hours: 11:00 AM – 11:39 PM. 13 min. ready for pickup. Delivery
Last Updates
Reviews
José Gonzalez (GonzoEatz.Drinkz)
Love when you get those great deals/coupons from one of your favorite pizza businesses! Free 16″ cheese pizza with any purchase! Great customer service, great food and drinks always at Five Star Pizza! If you haven’t tried them out, hope you do soon!
Shoutout to Mr. Ryan, the owner who was on premise and helped me with my entire order today!
(This establishment is a take out only – no dining area to sit down and eat.)
… moreShoutout to Mr. Ryan, the owner who was on premise and helped me with my entire order today!
(This establishment is a take out only – no dining area to sit down and eat.)
john jenerou
Five star nailed it tonight, best pizza I’ve had in years. Look at all the toppings!!
… moreJessica Sea serpent
Coupon Chaos and a Rude Phone Experience
Two moms booked two separate orders of the big pizza for our cheer squad and tried to use a legit coupon that let two people use the
same discount, both under the pickup contact name. We double-checked by phone to make sure the pizzas would be ready by 3:30 since we’ve done big orders like this before and don’t want a repeat of past mix-ups.
What happened:
Two people used the same coupon, and both got the discount, with the pickup name showing as the contact.
I called to confirm pickup time and got a staff member who was incredibly rude, saying we shouldn’t be using the discount because we were “double dipping,” even though the policy seemed to allow it.
The whole thing felt like a slap in the face and made the pickup stressful.
The impact:
The rude reaction ruined what should have been a smooth, fun order for our big event.
I’ve always trusted this place for big parties around the city because the pizza is amazing, but this experience was a huge letdown.
What could help:
Be crystal clear about coupon rules publicly—can multiple people use the same coupon under one pickup name? any limits per order?
Train staff to handle coupon questions with some courtesy, especially for large orders.
Maybe rethink per-destination or per-order coupon rules to avoid confusion and keep things consistent for big groups.
Bottom line: disappointed by the service and attitude that day. Hope the management takes this to heart so future orders go smoothly and everyone’s treated better.
… moreTwo moms booked two separate orders of the big pizza for our cheer squad and tried to use a legit coupon that let two people use the
same discount, both under the pickup contact name. We double-checked by phone to make sure the pizzas would be ready by 3:30 since we’ve done big orders like this before and don’t want a repeat of past mix-ups.
What happened:
Two people used the same coupon, and both got the discount, with the pickup name showing as the contact.
I called to confirm pickup time and got a staff member who was incredibly rude, saying we shouldn’t be using the discount because we were “double dipping,” even though the policy seemed to allow it.
The whole thing felt like a slap in the face and made the pickup stressful.
The impact:
The rude reaction ruined what should have been a smooth, fun order for our big event.
I’ve always trusted this place for big parties around the city because the pizza is amazing, but this experience was a huge letdown.
What could help:
Be crystal clear about coupon rules publicly—can multiple people use the same coupon under one pickup name? any limits per order?
Train staff to handle coupon questions with some courtesy, especially for large orders.
Maybe rethink per-destination or per-order coupon rules to avoid confusion and keep things consistent for big groups.
Bottom line: disappointed by the service and attitude that day. Hope the management takes this to heart so future orders go smoothly and everyone’s treated better.
Anne Marie Toole
Always friendly staff and great pizza, particularly the white, gluten free pizza! Our favorite! And they offer some wonderful deals often! All the food is great at Five Star Pizza!
… moreJoshua
We have been a customer of Five Star consistently, once or twice a week, typically $75-$100 each order, for awhile now. We placed an order 24 hours ahead of time for a Halloween party, delivery at 5pm. By 6:45 we still had not received our order. We called 4-5 times during that time and every time we called, they told us that the order was out for delivery and would be there “in ten minutes or so”. We asked to speak with the manager after an hour and a half of not receiving our order and the manager/owner, told us that he would put a note on file for a credit of the amount of our order for the next time we ordered for the inconvenience as they were not sure what happened to the driver and were not able to get in contact with him the entire time we were waiting. Well, 4 weeks later, we called to order another large order for a party and were told by the young lady answering the phone that no note was on our file and she would have to speak with the owner. After putting us on hold, she back and said that the owner would only extend 50% credit because we got the pizza eventually. When we said that was unacceptable as we pre-ordered the day before and still received our order an hour and almost 45 minutes late and were frequent customers, the lady on the phone had a “careless” attitude and said that was it and we were given more than enough since we received the order, even if it was late. When I said we would take our business elsewhere due to the service that we have received the past few times we have ordered, which I know is our prerogative, she just said ok great and hung up. I am thoroughly disappointed in the service that we have received which is a shame. We enjoyed their pizza but will take our business to a place where they value their customers and can deliver (pun intended) on the service and product they promise.
… moreEllie Brand
The young lady who took my order over the phone was very pleasant and helpful. Pizza is ready in time posted. It’s always good. We order the large veggie and it is delicious, with plenty leftover.
… moreNoah Douglas
I originally gave this place a 5 star review, but something has happened in the past 3-4 months and the quality has gone down hill. The past 3 delivery orders have not been right. First order had pineapple on a pizza that should not have had pineapple on it. 2nd order did not come with the sides that I ordered. Last night’s 3rd order the buffalo chicken pizza had so much grease that the delivery driver was holding the box and grease was spilling out of the box onto my front porch and all the way in the house. The box was so soft from the grease and the pizza was soggy. To the management at Five Star, this was my last order with your business. You went from a 5 star review from me 4 months ago, to this 1 star review over the course of 3 separate orders. Its sad to have a good thing and have it turn sour.
… morereptile handler
Five star pizza is the best!!! very fresh. The crust is tender and fluffy. Ingredients are delicious. Thinly sliced flavorful. Always hot and tasty! I’ve joined the club so I get texted discounts often! Who doesn’t want a deal?!
… moreBrian Thacker
Five Star Pizza on 13 in Julington Creek has the best take out pizza around. We have compared it to others and they never disappoint us. If you’re looking to try out a new pizza spot and have never tried them before, give them a chance. You will be so glad you did.
… moreAndy Rockwell
These guys are really good! We’ve tried a lot of different pizza shops in Jacksonville but since discovering 5 Star we don’t go anywhere else. They’ve completely mastered their crust!
… more