Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
American restaurant with a warm rust-&-brown palette known for burgers made of freshly ground beef.
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Five Points Cafe: Home
1 Main Street Sayville, NY 11782 · Sunday – Thursday: 11:30AM – 9:00PM Friday – Saturday: 11:30AM – 10:00PM Closing Hours May Vary · · Tuesday: First Responders …
Five Points Cafe (@fivepointscafesayville) · Sayville, NY – Instagram
8oz Burgers Sandwiches & Wraps Salads Dessert Full Bar · Take out available 7 days a week for pick up or delivery on DoorDash ! · January ❄️☃️ …
Five Points Cafe | Sayville NY – Facebook
We’re proud to offer you THE best burger around. We use only 100% American Beef that is alwa… See more. American Restaurant · $$.
Reviews
Kristina Mextorf
I felt compelled to write this review as I’m so disappointed. We’ve been coming to five points since we moved to Bohemia since 2018. We have eaten here many many times and was always our go to spot. We noticed the past year it started changing for the worst. Tonight I door dashed for myself and family. We hadn’t gotten the food in over 6 months so i figured we would try it out again since the last time when we noticed it was going down hill. I ordered my
Usual Grilled chicken sandwich on a multi grain bun with onion rings. When I went to bite into it I noticed immediately the chicken was like rubber…. Thick rubber, not like the real taste of a piece of grilled Chicken. It was nauseating. I couldn’t even swallow it I spit it out. I’ve had this same sandwich for years because it was my favorite and the chicken has never been like this. Always thin and grilled and tasted FRESH. Not Artificial !
My daughter ordered a BLT and the rye bread was burnt. It’s really sad because we used to LOVE this place, I was able to get a Refund from door dash, but sadly we will never be back to five points. Wha happened to this place?
… moreUsual Grilled chicken sandwich on a multi grain bun with onion rings. When I went to bite into it I noticed immediately the chicken was like rubber…. Thick rubber, not like the real taste of a piece of grilled Chicken. It was nauseating. I couldn’t even swallow it I spit it out. I’ve had this same sandwich for years because it was my favorite and the chicken has never been like this. Always thin and grilled and tasted FRESH. Not Artificial !
My daughter ordered a BLT and the rye bread was burnt. It’s really sad because we used to LOVE this place, I was able to get a Refund from door dash, but sadly we will never be back to five points. Wha happened to this place?
SE
We decided to try this cafe restaurant because of its great location and the decent things we had heard, but it turned out to be a huge disappointment. The food was genuinely terrible. Everything we ordered was completely bland with no flavor at all. I would honestly be embarrassed if this was my restaurant. How are you going to have a pork chop special for $29 and then serve applesauce in a plastic cup? That alone says everything about the effort put into the food. Lazy and absolutely ridiculous. Not to mention the pork chop was boiled…with no seasoning. It even looks unappetizing.
The burgers were somehow both dry and flavorless. I have no idea how you manage to make a burger dry, but they did. There was no seasoning, no flavor, nada.
With such a prime location, you would think the food would be at least decent, so we came in with high expectations. I honestly don’t understand how this place stays open. Maybe the owner has strong connections in the community or this restaurant is just a front for something else because there is no way they are surviving off of selling food like that.
We will not be back. This was our first and definitely our last visit. We tried to eat as much as we could because we don’t believe in wasting food, but it was a struggle. I just want to warn other people before they waste their money here. Save yourself the disappointment and go somewhere that actually cares about what they serve.
… moreThe burgers were somehow both dry and flavorless. I have no idea how you manage to make a burger dry, but they did. There was no seasoning, no flavor, nada.
With such a prime location, you would think the food would be at least decent, so we came in with high expectations. I honestly don’t understand how this place stays open. Maybe the owner has strong connections in the community or this restaurant is just a front for something else because there is no way they are surviving off of selling food like that.
We will not be back. This was our first and definitely our last visit. We tried to eat as much as we could because we don’t believe in wasting food, but it was a struggle. I just want to warn other people before they waste their money here. Save yourself the disappointment and go somewhere that actually cares about what they serve.
Joseph D’Amico
This was our first visit. The food came fast and hot to the table. We enjoyed our lunch and will go back. Our server Jennifer was pleasant and helpful
… moreSue Ladue
My Boyfriend & I Went to Five Points Cafe today and was pleasantly surprised. They had a nice menu with a variety of selections. We had a Spin Chip App which was Delicious and I had a Steak Sandwich also Delicious, and my Boyfriend had a Steak Burger which he said was very good. Everything was cooked as we asked. Also the French Fries were really good. Our waitress was very nice and knowledgeable. 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️and I would return for another meal. Highly recommend.
… moreDavid H
We had lunch with a long lost relative today. We arrived around 12pm and were the only customers for at least 1/2 an hour.
This worked out good for us since we had a lot of catching up to do.
The food looked good and tasted fine.
The waitresses were nice so overall it was a pleasant experience. It’s just that nothing stood out that made it special.
But give it a try.
… moreThis worked out good for us since we had a lot of catching up to do.
The food looked good and tasted fine.
The waitresses were nice so overall it was a pleasant experience. It’s just that nothing stood out that made it special.
But give it a try.
Glenn
Nice local, live music, good for a Friday (end of week) dinner. Cozy and friendly, staff are all nice. Bartender serves drinks in any old clean glass, weather a beer or not….so probably should order a beer! Recommend and will be back.
… moreDee Palouse
This is my new place to eat. The food was so fresh and delicious. I had a hard time choosing what I wanted from the menu. Our server couldn’t be more attentive and sweet. My friend and I brought our dogs, so we sat on the patio.
… moreMichael Sanginario
Went for the first time today for lunch. It was not good. Chicken sandwich had massive bun with an extremely small piece of chicken. It was barely 4 oz. Mac and Cheese was basically boxed Velveeta shells. Advertised “topped with toasted breadcrumbs” but was actually just a sprinkle of bottled Parmesan cheese. Not worth the $50 check. Staff was pleasant. Do not recommend.
… moreBlanca
1st time I’ve eaten there and it was really good! There was a 30 minute wait at around 6:45 on a Saturday night so we sat at the bar. Selina, the bartender was attentive. Ordered the Cajun chicken sandwich with cheddar and a salad. The sandwich was very tasty and the sauce had a nice “kick.” The kitchen staff kept just kept pumping out orders (to go & dine-in). There was live music too.
… morePZ MED
Rating this on limited service. Went there with co-workers for Music Bingo. We didn’t eat but the drinks were good, strong enough, and at the right price. We saw the pretzel come out at another table and had to order it. It did not disappoint. Big, fluffy, with cheese and mustard as topping options. So good. The outdoor seating was shaded with a breeze, and the music bingo was an entertaining reprieve.
… more