Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2347 W Genesee Rd, Baldwinsville, NY 13027
Phone: (315) 303-0779
Website: https://firesidebytheriver.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fireside By The River: Approachable Dining, Events, Baldiwinville …
Steak and Seafood. Vegetarian options. Public & Private Events. Menu · Location · 2347 W Genesee Rd, Baldwinsville, NY …
Fireside By The River | Baldwinsville NY – Facebook
. 84% recommend (10 Reviews) ; . Closed now ; . 2347 West Genesee Rd, Route 370, Baldwinsville, NY, United States, 13027 …
Fireside by the River in Baldwinsville gets a fine dining …
Baldwinsville, N.Y. — The frosted glass windows by the front door still say The Fireside Inn, a last homage to Fireside by the River’s past life …
Last Updates
Reviews
Liz
Well, Thanksgiving eve, I wanted to take my sister who was visiting somewhere pretty upscale and someplace I’ve always wanted to dine at. We got dressed up and headed here because we were salivating at the steaks from Google photos! When we arrived we were seated promptly, no reservation needed and we greeted shortly after by our waitress. She wasn’t friendly, but she also wasn’t off putting. Just eh… we looked at the menu and was excited by the choices. I ordered a cranberry vanilla martini and my sis ordered a Shirley Temple. We then ordered their steamers weekly special and then our steaks- ribeye w/ black truffle butter and strip w/ garlic butter and whipped potatoes as our side. A Caesar for my sis and the seasonal zucchini veggies as our additional sides. Honestly, the steak wasn’t cooked to my sister’s liking and overall we were less than satisfied with our meal. Don’t get me wrong- my ribeye was huge, but for a pretty fine estsblishment- we loved the ambiance, we were deeply disappointed by our meal. Price wasn’t worth it, best part our meal was the creme brulee and my sister loved her salad..Will we go back again….eh to be determined.
… morejoy king
We went there for the Sunday Brunch to celebrate my birthday. Most of the food was delicious! The drinks were YUMMY! It wasn’t crowded, so our servers were attentive! The atmosphere was beautiful, inviting & warm/cozy. They brought out a slice of cake for my birthday. I look forward to going again.
… moreTravelers Narrative
The food was delicious and plenty. Live band plays on Friday night. The restaurant gets very busy but if you go early around 5 pm you can get sitting without reservations.
… moreKelly Morrison
Excellent all around. Our first time there.
There was no wait at about 5:45 on a Saturday night.
It was the ambience I was hoping for. The classy and quiet supper club/lounge vibe. Our server Makayla was so sweet, friendly, and professional. She gets 10000/10.
Took a bit for our drinks to get to us but we didn’t mind.
I could hear that they popped a fresh bottle of Prosecco for me. Love that.
We got the crab and shrimp dip. It was good. Not what I expected. I think I tasted a lot of celery. Good app for bar side dinner. I’d give it 7/10.
For entrees we got the stuffed haddock and the queen cut prime rib.
Let me tell you, I will be back for that prime rib.
Cooked perfectly. Juicy. Delicious.
The seasonal vegetable was green beans. Cooked perfectly al dente with butter and garlic.
I could’ve eaten my baked potato as an entree.
HUGE. Nice and crispy and salty skin. And tender inside.
I would give my entree 10/10.
Hubby gave his stuffed haddock 8/10.
We decided to disregard our full bellies and get the towering carrot cake.
That was delicious. The only negative is that the middle of the slice was still almost frozen. I’d give it 8/10.
We appreciated the owner/manager coming to say hello.
We will definitely be back.
… moreThere was no wait at about 5:45 on a Saturday night.
It was the ambience I was hoping for. The classy and quiet supper club/lounge vibe. Our server Makayla was so sweet, friendly, and professional. She gets 10000/10.
Took a bit for our drinks to get to us but we didn’t mind.
I could hear that they popped a fresh bottle of Prosecco for me. Love that.
We got the crab and shrimp dip. It was good. Not what I expected. I think I tasted a lot of celery. Good app for bar side dinner. I’d give it 7/10.
For entrees we got the stuffed haddock and the queen cut prime rib.
Let me tell you, I will be back for that prime rib.
Cooked perfectly. Juicy. Delicious.
The seasonal vegetable was green beans. Cooked perfectly al dente with butter and garlic.
I could’ve eaten my baked potato as an entree.
HUGE. Nice and crispy and salty skin. And tender inside.
I would give my entree 10/10.
Hubby gave his stuffed haddock 8/10.
We decided to disregard our full bellies and get the towering carrot cake.
That was delicious. The only negative is that the middle of the slice was still almost frozen. I’d give it 8/10.
We appreciated the owner/manager coming to say hello.
We will definitely be back.
Ellie
honestly, i was unimpressed. came for the brunch buffet, and the food was below par. the homefries were so burnt, they were pretty much inedible. the waffle was okay, and the best thing there was the cheesecake cubes… which weren’t even made by them. the green tea was from walmart. please, do yourself a favor and skip this place if in the area.
… moreAj Callahan
In all my years of being a paid high-level reviewer, this has been by far my favorite place to review. Partly because the owner says “They can’t stand reviews “. This honestly baffled me because this place as a whole sets the bar in every standard imaginable. The booking was easy to make. Upon our arrival the hostesses were friendly and cheerful.
The atmosphere is both inviting and Cozy. Our waitress was one of the most informative and attentive service staff we’ve had the privilege of having, especially after the pandemic when the service industry has drastically gone downhill. Her recommendations were fantastic and her personal best was my go-to dessert (Creme Brule) that she made herself and easily made my Second best in that department. Seriously, a MUST try. (Thank me later)
The entire meal was fantastic. Perfectly cooked, and abundant portions for the overall cost. The owner was extremely attentive rounding the tables and making sure everyone’s expectations were met. This is the kind of hospitality is what reviews are made for. The ones who go the distance and take great pride in the amazing experience they’ve created.
Five stars isn’t nearly enough for what they deserve. Phenomenal!
… moreThe atmosphere is both inviting and Cozy. Our waitress was one of the most informative and attentive service staff we’ve had the privilege of having, especially after the pandemic when the service industry has drastically gone downhill. Her recommendations were fantastic and her personal best was my go-to dessert (Creme Brule) that she made herself and easily made my Second best in that department. Seriously, a MUST try. (Thank me later)
The entire meal was fantastic. Perfectly cooked, and abundant portions for the overall cost. The owner was extremely attentive rounding the tables and making sure everyone’s expectations were met. This is the kind of hospitality is what reviews are made for. The ones who go the distance and take great pride in the amazing experience they’ve created.
Five stars isn’t nearly enough for what they deserve. Phenomenal!
Emily Rose Anderson
I felt compelled to sing this place’s praises as soon as I possibly could. My partner and I came here for a date tonight and our expectations were absolutely blown out of the water. Our server was incredibly sweet and attentive, and the owner was very kind and generous 🙂 We were given a complimentary baked brie on top of our appetizers, all of which were delicious and comforting. Later on, i was even given two extra scallops with my entree. The food is delicious, beautifully plated, and filling. I would rate this place 6 stars if I could, and we will be back soon!
(OH, and don’t even get me started on the amazing live music)
… more(OH, and don’t even get me started on the amazing live music)
Todd [email protected]
I go every few months. Baldwinsville lacks a good restaurant that doesn’t have “Angry” in the title. The food is always fantastic – I’ve never had a bad dish. Love the bar and the layout. Only drawbacks are it’s not a cheap date, and sometimes the live music is a little too loud and impairs conversation during dining hours. Seriously, it’s fine – I like the live music – just maybe turn it down a notch or three
… moreMichael LaBarbera
Fireside by the River was a great experience. The restaurant itself is beautiful, spacious and set up for big parties and by the looks of it holding all kinds of events.
The staff was incredibly friendly, accommodating and invested in us having a great dining experience.
Drinks were well made and there is a very solid selection.
The food was great to fantastic, with the whipped potatoes and warm brie being the ultimate highlights of our evening. Everything was delicious and the options were plentiful. It is expensive but in line to cheaper than other fine dining like experiences. The kicker, the portions were huge! Very impressed with them bucking the fine dining experience of less is more expensive. Delicious and plentiful is a I’ll be back for more combo.
Highly recommend getting your reservation now, Enjoy!!
… moreThe staff was incredibly friendly, accommodating and invested in us having a great dining experience.
Drinks were well made and there is a very solid selection.
The food was great to fantastic, with the whipped potatoes and warm brie being the ultimate highlights of our evening. Everything was delicious and the options were plentiful. It is expensive but in line to cheaper than other fine dining like experiences. The kicker, the portions were huge! Very impressed with them bucking the fine dining experience of less is more expensive. Delicious and plentiful is a I’ll be back for more combo.
Highly recommend getting your reservation now, Enjoy!!
Maureen Stabak
We went for the Thanksgiving buffet and were very disappointed. We had been for dinner on another occasion and were so pleased, we couldn’t wait to go back.
Unfortunately it was not good. We had to wait in a long line for the food and it was tasty but barely warm. I think if you are charging $50 a plate it should be hot and at that price we were surprised that the salad station had bagged lettuce. The rolls were also served cold.
We were VERY impressed with the staff and we will go back again when we can order from the regular menu.
… moreUnfortunately it was not good. We had to wait in a long line for the food and it was tasty but barely warm. I think if you are charging $50 a plate it should be hot and at that price we were surprised that the salad station had bagged lettuce. The rolls were also served cold.
We were VERY impressed with the staff and we will go back again when we can order from the regular menu.