Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 204 Blue Point Ave, Blue Point, NY 11715
Phone: (631) 363-0808
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Order Firehouse Deli – Blue Point, NY Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Firehouse Deli at 204 Blue Point Avenue in Blue Point. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Firehouse Deli Blue Point, NY (@firehouse_deli_bpny) – Instagram
Local Business. Homemade. 204 Blue Point Avenue Blue Point, NY 11715. We do NOT have a website. No DMs Please.
Firehouse Deli Delivery Menu | Order Online | 204 Blue Point Ave …
Order delivery or pickup from Firehouse Deli in Blue Point! View Firehouse Deli’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with Grubhub!
Reviews
Paula
1/2 dozen bagels on a pinky shake!
Let me explain please:
I’m not local to the area, I’ve been coming over to Bluepoint to house sit for my Sister.
Last week At 6:00 AM I went into the deli to purchase some bagels for my husband.
I reached into my bag and didn’t have my wallet.
The young man working there said it’s ok dear, I’ll give you the bagels anyway on a “Pinky Shake” and you can come back later and pay me.
All though I didn’t want to do it, I agreed “feeling obligated” to quickly pay I ran home across the island to retrieve my wallet so as to pay on our commitment.
The gentleman working there said Hun, you didn’t have to rush!
This is the way it used to be back in the late 60s and 70s when I was growing up. Trust was an openly accepted way of life back in those days.
Although I’ve patronized this deli before mostly breakfast and bagels which has always been over the top in taste and quality, to see that there are good caring people these days are a God send!
This Deli is by far the Deli I remember growing up that existed on Main Street America.
Thank you Firehouse Deli and thank you to that Handsome man who bailed me out as I was able to provide my husband with some of the best bagels available in this part of the island.
MDGA Make Deli’s Great Again!
… moreLet me explain please:
I’m not local to the area, I’ve been coming over to Bluepoint to house sit for my Sister.
Last week At 6:00 AM I went into the deli to purchase some bagels for my husband.
I reached into my bag and didn’t have my wallet.
The young man working there said it’s ok dear, I’ll give you the bagels anyway on a “Pinky Shake” and you can come back later and pay me.
All though I didn’t want to do it, I agreed “feeling obligated” to quickly pay I ran home across the island to retrieve my wallet so as to pay on our commitment.
The gentleman working there said Hun, you didn’t have to rush!
This is the way it used to be back in the late 60s and 70s when I was growing up. Trust was an openly accepted way of life back in those days.
Although I’ve patronized this deli before mostly breakfast and bagels which has always been over the top in taste and quality, to see that there are good caring people these days are a God send!
This Deli is by far the Deli I remember growing up that existed on Main Street America.
Thank you Firehouse Deli and thank you to that Handsome man who bailed me out as I was able to provide my husband with some of the best bagels available in this part of the island.
MDGA Make Deli’s Great Again!
Chris Russo
I came in to get something becuase I work outdoors. The gentleman was kind and was helping me but since i couldnt decide what i want a lady comes and goes “What do you need” when I hadnt come up with ehat to get. I work with customers. Its “How may I help you” or “What can I get you” she needs training. I left with just a tea instead of food.
… moreTom De
We’re new to the area and picked up lunch for our family while moving in. The prices were shockingly low which raised concerns about quality. We were delighted to find that all four of our dishes were both correct and delicious! Blue Point ahoy!
… moreErika Joy
Great food, friendly staff, and they have a wide variety of items. My go to stop before getting on the Sayville Ferry.
… moreRaymond Gibbons
The day of the local deli seems to be fading into the great beyond. But Blue Point Deli has remained one of the best for a many years as I can remember. Always clean and then food always fresh.
… moreLJ Doyle
It is not what I expected. Wen you first enter, you immediately notice the limited supplies and empty trays. The menu on the board looked good. I ordered a Caprese panini (chicken, fresh mozz, roasted peppers and pesto) and an egg sandwich. Service was quick. The egg sandwich was average nothing great, not worth writing about, but certainly not good enough to go back there a 2nd time. The panini, It is obvious they did not know what a panini is. The type of bread was cheap and has some slight grill marks on it. But the sandwich was not pressed, and served warm; it was cold and the bread was falling apart, and there was no pesto. I was hungry so I ate a few bites of the “panini” but then picked out the very cold chicken and cheese and tossed the bread. I was sick for over a day from eating there. although they were friendly, I do not recommend it.
… moreChuck Gardner
One of the best bacon egg and cheese sandwiches around!
… moreAnn-Marie Seldin
Delicious, clean, fast, and friendly. If pressed for time, you can call ahead and your sandwich(s)/order will be ready when you get there. My family loves Firehouse deli!
… more