Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 237 Main St, Amagansett, NY 11930
Phone: (631) 394-5654
Website: https://www.finipizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fini Pizza NYC in Amagansett, NY.
Fini pizza is from Brooklyn, NY. We offer a fresh take on the delicious and legendary NYC slice shops while honoring the past, embracing the present, …
Fini Pizza NYC slice shop in Brooklyn, NY.
Fini pizza is from Brooklyn, NY. We offer a fresh take on the delicious and legendary NYC slice shops while honoring the past, embracing the present, …
Fini Pizza Amagansett | Hours + Location
Fini pizza is from Brooklyn, NY. We offer a fresh take on the delicious and legendary NYC slice shops while honoring the past, embracing the present, …
Reviews
George Marneris
Fini Pizza is a great local pizza spot. Its pizza is unique, creative, and uses great quality ingredients.
The crust is what makes this pizza unique. It’s super thin crust, but a bit dense instead of your typical light and airy crust. It soaks up the olive oil nicely and is crispy.
The white slice, what brought us here after my wife heard a local rave about it on social media. Topped with lemon zest and served with a slice of lemon, it’s rich, bright, and flavorful. I think it could be taken to an even higher level with maybe just a touch of fresh basil or Italian parsley perhaps?
Cheese slice is solid as well, great undercarriage and good amount of sauce to cheese ratio. The “grandma” slice looked more of a Sicilian to me, a lot thicker than your typical grandma. But nevertheless, it was delicious, and the sauce was very fresh with chunks of fresh tomato and a little spicy, which I didn’t expect.
Great pizza split with friendly staff, and a nice dining area connected, or benches to enjoy outside on a nice day.
… moreThe crust is what makes this pizza unique. It’s super thin crust, but a bit dense instead of your typical light and airy crust. It soaks up the olive oil nicely and is crispy.
The white slice, what brought us here after my wife heard a local rave about it on social media. Topped with lemon zest and served with a slice of lemon, it’s rich, bright, and flavorful. I think it could be taken to an even higher level with maybe just a touch of fresh basil or Italian parsley perhaps?
Cheese slice is solid as well, great undercarriage and good amount of sauce to cheese ratio. The “grandma” slice looked more of a Sicilian to me, a lot thicker than your typical grandma. But nevertheless, it was delicious, and the sauce was very fresh with chunks of fresh tomato and a little spicy, which I didn’t expect.
Great pizza split with friendly staff, and a nice dining area connected, or benches to enjoy outside on a nice day.
Samia Pendleton
The pizza was delicious and the aesthetic is so good. I love eating from a pizza box that doesn’t look like a traditional pizza box.
… moreK G
You’re really ripping customers off. You’re charging $6.25 for just one slice of pizza. And it’s not even a proper slice—it’s tiny, more like half a slice. That’s shameful. Look, I’m putting a picture here. This is a pizza shop in Manorville, and I’m also posting their prices below. Their slices are bigger than yours, and they give you 2 slices plus a drink. You can’t overcharge people like this.
… moreAmleset Neguse
The white pizza with lemon was so refreshing never had anything like it. The pepperoni cheese pizza was a hit too. Service was excellent, felt like home dining here. When we return back to Sag Harbor we will be back for sure
… moreJune Stoyer
This is a hot spot in Amagansett! Very popular with the locals who gladly wait on a very long line for a slice, pie or both!
The staff is very friendly and hard working. There is a dining area next door. You can opt to sit on a stool and enjoy a slice of east end style pizza.
… moreThe staff is very friendly and hard working. There is a dining area next door. You can opt to sit on a stool and enjoy a slice of east end style pizza.
Justin Fields
Pizza here is top notch. One of my favorite white slices to date, the lemon takes it to the next level. There was actual lemon zest on the slice the first time I came here and not the second time. Feel like it should always be there in terms of making it a little more special. Either way it’s a must visit for pizza lovers driving through Amagansett.
… moremoses burdon
plain slice, pepperoni slice and a Coke, $16
that’s crazy!
it’s a good slice of pizza, obviously focused on quality ingredients. it’s thin crust bougie pizza. not anything I’ll go back for any time soon.
My total was $16.32 so I handed the girl at the counter the $21.50, she takes my 50 cents and puts it in the tip jar and tells me you know it’s only 16 right? I said yes it’s called exact change if you put $21.50 into the cash register it’s going to tell you to give me back $5 and change. eventually she asked someone else who worked there to do it.
… morethat’s crazy!
it’s a good slice of pizza, obviously focused on quality ingredients. it’s thin crust bougie pizza. not anything I’ll go back for any time soon.
My total was $16.32 so I handed the girl at the counter the $21.50, she takes my 50 cents and puts it in the tip jar and tells me you know it’s only 16 right? I said yes it’s called exact change if you put $21.50 into the cash register it’s going to tell you to give me back $5 and change. eventually she asked someone else who worked there to do it.
carter kabot
Stopped into a great pizza place in Amagansett in the downtown area. You walk in and order right at the counter and can order by the slice or full pie. There is some room to sit inside and also some seats outside if you’d rather sit there.
The cheese pizza had a delicious sauce and was very crisp and crunchy with a delicious crust. The white pizza had lemon zest on it which was very different but still great. We also tried the shallot pizza which was a bit spicy but that’s something I love! This was a great experience and would definitely go back!
… moreThe cheese pizza had a delicious sauce and was very crisp and crunchy with a delicious crust. The white pizza had lemon zest on it which was very different but still great. We also tried the shallot pizza which was a bit spicy but that’s something I love! This was a great experience and would definitely go back!
Geoff White
Worst pizza I ever had. Ordered half cheese and half pepperoni. The pepperoni had to have been very cheap because it was super greasy and tasted of rotten meat. I tossed half the pizza after three bites. I took three bites just to be sure. Tried to cheese side and the tomato topping was not up to par or even close. They use cheap ingredients, no doubt. The crust is thin, so that is fine for people who like thin crust. I do not really care about the crust. Thin or thick is fine with me as long as it is delicious. This crust was like cardboard and overly burnt. The place is super busy because it is the only pizza game in town. It is staffed by young kids with no direction, so the service is laughably bad. The atmosphere is fine because it is Amagansett. We tossed the $50 pizza and went back to our summer place to have sandwiches, being too hungry to go to another place to eat. So in the end, we had a great meal. I have only had one bad meal in town, and that was tonight. There was a very good pizza place, but it is gone now. We tried this one just on a whim. Never again.
… moreAmanda Oliver
Very good pizza, and the itialian ice is amazing. First time and ready to go back. He gave us 2 slices of white pizza to try and that was good. Loved the man’s energy and friendly.
… more