Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Fierro’s Pizzeria – Montauk Serving Great Pizza Since 1983 Fierro’s has been East Hampton’s village pizzeria for almost 40 years, and has now added a Montauk location! With multiple generations working to build its legacy, Fierro’s continues to grow and provide the community with a warm welcome and a hot slice all year long.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 54 S Erie Ave, Montauk, NY 11954
Phone: (631) 668-8084
Website: https://fierrospizzastore.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Fierro’s Pizza: Welcome
Using only the freshest ingredients and dough that is made daily, Fierro’s is your hometown Pizzeria with your favorite staples. … Erie Ave., Montauk, NY 11954.
Fierro’s Pizza – East Hampton & Montauk, New York (@fierrospizza)
Est. 1983, East Hampton Village. Est. 2024, Montauk Stop by for a warm welcome and a hot slice all year round. Uber Eats Door Dash Grub Hub …
Fierro’s Pizza Montauk – Montauk Chamber of Commerce
Fierro’s Pizza Montauk. Where to Eat > Restaurants · 54 S Erie Ave Montauk, NY · 631-668-8084. Fierro’s Pizzeria Serving Great Pizza Since 1983. Fierro’s has …
Reviews
Gerard M
Huge variety of excellent pizza. Grab a beer next door at Montauk Brewery, sit on a bench or one of their Adirondack chairs and let your cares melt away. BTW: very friendly staff and the pizza is very fairly priced. I went twice this week
… moremoses burdon
All the good pizza in East Hampton moved to Montauk when the bougie useless boutiques took over
… moreJacques Bertrand
Nice clean place. Pizza was good, but could’ve been cooked for a little longer which would’ve made it great. Crust was just undercooked. Would definitely come here again.
… morePaige Mahon
$60+ for two orders of penne alla vodka and an order of garlic knots. Btw an order of garlic knots only comes with 3… . The vodka sauce didn’t have any heavy cream so it was basically marinara. They have a cute seating arrangement but only if it’s nice outside.
… moreSebastien Blind
Ordered a Hawaiian pizza. This only comes w/ cheese, ham and some pineapple at this place. Too bad if you expect a Hawaiian pizza to come w/ at least some basic pizza red base/sauce on it.
This makes for a pretty dry pizza in the end and much less enjoyable than a classic Hawaiian pizza.
… moreThis makes for a pretty dry pizza in the end and much less enjoyable than a classic Hawaiian pizza.
Stefanie Salita
It’s so great to have another pizza option in Montauk! Especially right near the brewery it’s so needed when you just want to grab something quick. My husband I went there just this past weekend and it was delicious on top of the staff being very friendly. The place itself is very clean and smells like fresh food! It will be a new staple for when we go back. You can’t go wrong with good Pizza! Thank you for being there 🙂
… moreJillian
We ordered plain and Sicilian slices and both were delicious. Employees were very helpful and told us they can custom make a pie to accommodate an allergy I have. We will definitely be back!
… moreMarianne D. Dempsey
Charged for entree that was ordered but not included at pick up. Said they “threw away” the ticket and couldn’t find it – refused to verify order to determine if I was charged or not- but I was charged. Refused to refund for part of the order they didn’t provide.
… moreSushil Sinha
Best pizza ever! The Sicilian pizza was fluffy, spongy with the perfect about of crunch to the bread base topped with a delicious slightly sweet tomatoes sauce and perfect amount of cheese. Pepe’s Pizza has nothing on these guys.
… moreEd Simonetti
My wife and I grabbed a pie this evening to bring back to our campsite. Pizza was fresh. Sauce and crust were delicious. I would highly recommend to anyone to stop in and try it for yourself.
… more