Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
American classics & cocktails served in a relaxed setting with golf course views & patio seating.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1 Mayapple Dr, Carlisle, PA 17015
Phone: (717) 258-1800
Website: http://www.fiddlersbarandgrill.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fiddler’s Bar & Grill Menu – Carlisle – Mayapple Golf Club
You can now have your favorites delivered right to you! Check out our menus to make your next meal complete!
Fiddlers on the Green at Mayapple | Carlisle PA – Facebook
From all of us at Fiddlers Bar & Grill & Mayapple Golf Club, we extend our deepest gratitude to our Veterans — today and always. Thank you for your service. ❤️ .
Fiddler’s Bar & Grill – Cumberland Valley Visitors Bureau
… bar. Menu options include appetizers, soups, salads, sandwiches … Fiddler’s Bar & Grill. Visit Website. wave. 1 Mayapple Drive Carlisle, PA 17013.
Reviews
B K
I ordered the new arugula steak salad and it was very good. My friend had the prime rib wrap and he said it was delicious. We will be going back soon.
… moreToni Sterling
I stopped here for dinner while on the road. Plenty of parking. We sat down right away. The staff were very friendly. It’s laid out nice and very clean inside. I got the lobster ravioli, which was ok. I expected lobster to be inside the ravioli. It’s more like ravioli with lobster claw in the sauce. My husband really enjoyed his salmon and the butter fingers cheese cake.
… moreKristen Wilhelm
Let me start off by saying the service was great! Our waiter was attentive and tried to be helpful. It was pretty dead around 7:30 pm on a weekday. Lots of tables open inside and it looked like they have outside seating too.
Okay so – the food is very hit or miss. I would give it 2.5 stars if I could. It’s either really good or really, REALLY bad. No in between. Coconut shrimp and seafood soup of the day (cream of crab): tasty, just wish the soup came out hot. Cocktails: Bahama mama was great but orange creamsicle was gross and curdled.
Entrees: my husband’s seafood Alfredo was really good. The entree I wanted was not available so I got the Surf and Turf. BIG MISTAKE. I asked for a medium steak, which you can see was beyond well done and I could barely cut into it because it was like leather. Our waiter did come by to tell us that people always send this steak back since they added it to the menu, which I wish I knew when I ordered it. It was so bad – literally the worst steak I’ve ever gotten at a restaurant. Was going to send it back but it was closing time, so my dog will eat it (although even our dog eats better steak than this haha). The side of rice was also the worst I’ve ever had – it smelled and tasted horrible. The mashed potatoes were good and so were the au gratin scallops. The creme brulee dessert was amazing.
So – you might love what you had or hate it and never want to go back. You don’t get a discount or the meal removed from the check if it’s bad, even if it’s so bad that it literally shouldn’t be on the menu. Things sell out as they get close to changing their menu for the season. Take it as you will!
… moreOkay so – the food is very hit or miss. I would give it 2.5 stars if I could. It’s either really good or really, REALLY bad. No in between. Coconut shrimp and seafood soup of the day (cream of crab): tasty, just wish the soup came out hot. Cocktails: Bahama mama was great but orange creamsicle was gross and curdled.
Entrees: my husband’s seafood Alfredo was really good. The entree I wanted was not available so I got the Surf and Turf. BIG MISTAKE. I asked for a medium steak, which you can see was beyond well done and I could barely cut into it because it was like leather. Our waiter did come by to tell us that people always send this steak back since they added it to the menu, which I wish I knew when I ordered it. It was so bad – literally the worst steak I’ve ever gotten at a restaurant. Was going to send it back but it was closing time, so my dog will eat it (although even our dog eats better steak than this haha). The side of rice was also the worst I’ve ever had – it smelled and tasted horrible. The mashed potatoes were good and so were the au gratin scallops. The creme brulee dessert was amazing.
So – you might love what you had or hate it and never want to go back. You don’t get a discount or the meal removed from the check if it’s bad, even if it’s so bad that it literally shouldn’t be on the menu. Things sell out as they get close to changing their menu for the season. Take it as you will!
Brad Robison
Had lunch here… the food quality and quantity where perfect and the prices are great! As a chef. This place is a must go! Excited to try dinner!
… moreJeffrey Wilson
Service was really good. Their wings are really good. But, my mind filet mignon was cooked well, but was a terrible cut of meat that never should have been served. My fish and chips were good, but I found it odd to get a single huge fillet, not manageable pieces of fish. The fries were actually great, but the slaw had way too much onion for my taste. The Bloody Mary and Moscow Mule were both excellent.
… moreScott Gyenes
Outstanding menu and ambiance. Casual atmosphere, but upscale menu. I ordered the special: grilled Mahi-mahi and risotto was excellent. My wife loved her prime rib and she orders it many places lol.
… moreDiane Anderson
We were surprised to see how packed the restaurant was tonight. We had excellent service, food was delicious, and all of the waitresses and waiters along with assistant manager did an amazing job. Thanks. Looking forward to returning soon.
… moreMiss Val
We stopped in on a Sunday afternoon in July for lunch. The place was not very busy so many tables were open but we sat at the bar. The bartender was friendly and attentive. The food was good and prices were reasonable. The atmosphere was easy and laid back. The restaurant is on a golf course and It was a hot day on a holiday weekend so I am guessing that they just weren’t busy because people were vacationing or just not golfing because of the heat.
… moreEric Harker
My wife and I visited The Fiddlers for a company dinner, and this is an honest account of our experience.
We arrived at 6:30 PM to find that our reserved table was not ready. Despite the restaurant being mostly empty, we had to share menus due to a lack of available ones.
We started with appetizers and drinks, placing our main dish orders at the same time. The appetizers, including the blackened tuna, didn’t arrive until 7:15 PM. Unfortunately, the tuna was overcooked and tough, and the rest of the appetizers were mediocre at best.
The main dishes didn’t arrive until 8:00 PM, and all were missing their accompanying sides. We had to remind the staff of what we originally ordered. This issue affected everyone at our table.
When we ordered a second round of drinks, we were told the bar was backed up, despite there being only two patrons at the bar, no one left in the dining area, and no bartender in sight. My wife’s first drink, ordered early in the evening, didn’t arrive until 8:30 PM, just as we were preparing to leave.
As for the food, I ordered the seafood Alfredo, which was served cold and lacked flavor.
Overall, this was a disappointing experience, and I would not choose to dine here on my own.
… moreWe arrived at 6:30 PM to find that our reserved table was not ready. Despite the restaurant being mostly empty, we had to share menus due to a lack of available ones.
We started with appetizers and drinks, placing our main dish orders at the same time. The appetizers, including the blackened tuna, didn’t arrive until 7:15 PM. Unfortunately, the tuna was overcooked and tough, and the rest of the appetizers were mediocre at best.
The main dishes didn’t arrive until 8:00 PM, and all were missing their accompanying sides. We had to remind the staff of what we originally ordered. This issue affected everyone at our table.
When we ordered a second round of drinks, we were told the bar was backed up, despite there being only two patrons at the bar, no one left in the dining area, and no bartender in sight. My wife’s first drink, ordered early in the evening, didn’t arrive until 8:30 PM, just as we were preparing to leave.
As for the food, I ordered the seafood Alfredo, which was served cold and lacked flavor.
Overall, this was a disappointing experience, and I would not choose to dine here on my own.
Wanda Phillips
Ordered a new item on the menu. When it came it was not anything I imagined it to be. Not only that but a wrap should be formed. 3 leaves of lettuce and a few pieces of hard, dry, tasteless chicken thrown on a plate! When I asked what this was server said what you ordered. Attitude from the server and terrible presentation from the chef will keep us from returning!
… more