Tony Guzman
This was my first visit to this location because of the advertised NYC style pizza. I personally did not find it NYC style because the crust was way thicker than ones I’ve had in NYC. There was alot of cheese, slice pepperoni (not classic) and sliced sausage versus the broken up sausage. The pizza was just ok in taste/flavor. Might possible give the place another try for the italian dishes but unfortunately not the pizza. Staff were very friendly and customer focused.
… moreS S
The pizza was okay, but I was extremely disappointed with the salad. There were multiple pieces of old, brown lettuce mixed throughout it, which made it unpleasant to eat. Quality like that really matters, and overall the experience didn’t feel worth the money, making me unlikely to return.
… moreShawn Lewis
Food was decent, though it did take a long time for it to appear at our table. Lots to choose from on the menu; much more than just a pizza place. Big — BIG! — portions. Our server was excellent. The atmosphere needs help. Very dated.
… moreEmmanuel Williams
I have to give a shout out to AJ from South Jersey. He took my order and was a pleasure to have a conversation with. I ordered two meatballs and a XL Meatlovers pizza (please see photos below). This establishment has dine in seating and a great environment. Everyone was friendly, smiling and willing to answer any questions you may have. I didn’t know there was a difference in a “pizza” and a “pie.” My entire order was less than $40.00 and they do offer military discounts after verification. The pizza was very hot, cheesy and I could taste meat in every bite. That handmade and oven-baked crust will fill you up every time. The meatballs were humongous and not what I was expecting. The sauce and the seasoning that was added was very good. I am looking forward to my next visit and trying a different selection on the menu.
… moreBryan Wood
This was my first time trying this little place and it was really good! I got there a little late in the evening after things were starting to wind down, but they still seated me and waited on me and there were a few other people that came in after me. It’s not anything fancy, and it’s not very big. I didn’t get there till around 8:30.
I had the pasta Trio. That consisted of lasagna, stuffed shell, and manicotti. It was served with garlic rolls and a side salad. So to start with, the side salad was excellent and good portions! More than just your run of the mill side salad. Then the little garlic rolls were also excellent! I could have made a meal off of those. Then when my food came out, it was also excellent! It took a little long on the food so I guess that would be my only complaint but as I said, I got there late, so I will cut them some slack on that. I had a server named Kristen and she did an excellent job. I did not get a picture of the salad, but I did take a picture of the main course and the menu. Yes, I will go back! And I really want to try some of that good looking pizza next time!
… moreJoesph Monroe
Great Bronx style pizza pies, quality mozzarella, gravy is reserved, excellent carriage/presentation. 2.75$ lunch slices are very fairly priced at time of this review. Shown is a Ferrara house pie, similar to a supreme 27.99$ for an 18″ and it’s absolutely all of 18″. Firm crust not overdone yet chewy and very very fresh, little oily, toppings are generous. Not my personal favorite but I’m extremely difficult to please in regards to authentic NYC pies.
You’d be completely uninformed to pass this opportunity up, less extreme criticism would pass this palace as a solid nine out of ten for sure. You get what you pay for and this place delivers well for a fresh, flavorful pie that will justify the price point.
Cheers!
… moreKristen Greco
They do serve up a NY street slice! Get a pie for a fresh hot crispy pizza. We also tried the meatballs (moist) and the sausage (excellent) as sides. Sauce is a little sweet but good and fresh. I had the pasta fagioli and loved the heaviness of the garlic and beans. No alcohol due to church being in same lot but they have Pepsi products and of course sweet tea.
We will definitely go back, I want to try a pizza with sausage and mushrooms.
… moreCole M
Stopped in today with my boyfriend and friends and couldn’t say anything but GREAT things. The garlic knots and the garlic bread is phenomenal. The Alfredo sauce is amazing. Salads were great. Pizza was perfect and the spaghetti and meatballs were fantastic. Will definitely be back and spread the word. Kat was our server and she was so so so friendly and very on top of things.
… moreClinton Cunningham
Their pizza is as good as any you’ll find in the Columbia metropolitan area if you’re seeking that authentic NY tri-state area slice. Our server, Julie was friendly and attentive. Don’t miss out on this spot.
… moreChristine Dowd
This wonderful place serves excellent NY style pizza.
Generous slices and delicious flavor. Has friendly service. My husband and I usually order take out , but there is a nice little area set up for dining in.
… more