Joseph Sheffield
This place has great reviews. I felt cozy upon entrance with a homely couch and chair waiting area. Love the Bible scriptures everywhere and open Bible to read. Before I got the pizza I could tell why this place has great reviews. The service was great from Steven/ clear menu board/10-15min turn around time on food. Prices are fair. Not much sitting space and no place to sit in and eat here. No restroom. Not sold by slice, only medium, large and extra large. I assume most people call in the order since the menu is set and no diner area.
I always order the pizza with no cheese because I feel it’s a true way to test the quality of the pizza. My wife got the veggie pizza with cheese & added beef crumble and I got the veggie pizza with no cheese and added beef crumble. They have beef pepperoni in which I almost got. The garlic sauce on the side didn’t taste or look like garlic and more like liquid butter. The marinara sauce was basic.
The crust was crunchy on the edges (freshly made) and soft towards the middle which is great. They put seasoning on the edges but the whole pizza could’ve used more of the same seasoning. The beef crumble wasn’t as pronounced as I’d hoped. The beef disintegrated with every bite – wanted more meat on it and chunkier pieces. When chewing, I have to get the crust towards my strong teeth as the crust always bothers the roof of my mouth.
The wings were great flavor, bourbon peach dry rub (I thought would be sauced instead of dry rub). Unique! I don’t love the HUGE jumbo wings. I love the baked crispy air fryer taste. I finished off the leftover jumbo wings next day. If they were medium to small sized with french fries, tots or onion rings I’m sure the sales will go up.
Considering that my full order two large pizzas and 8 wings in bag was lightweight, I agree it was light as I cleared the whole thin pizza & a few wings in a few mins. I didn’t feel as full but I was content. The veggies were OK, flavor was OK. Sauce didn’t hit, wasn’t full, meat wasn’t enough is why I stuck to the four star even though I felt five star vibes. I believe my wife liked hers a bit more as cheese adds another element so remember mine didn’t have cheese and my judgment is based on that. She still had to add seasoning to it when we got home. Fedele Amicos Pizzeria family connection and love for God is evident with this restaurant and that says/means a lot. Check this place out-try dry rub bourbon peach wings.
… moreTiffany Copeland
We have ordered from here multiple times and it has always been great until tonight. Had to wait over an hour for the food, to top it off it was the wrong pizza and it was cold and they never gave us the garlic butter cups that I ordered either. Called the store and he said the only way they could replace was if we drove it back up there. The whole point of ordering delivery is to not have to get out. We ordered a deluxe and they sent us a veggie. We were going to just keep it and deal with it but the pizza was cold and the tomatoes and spinach was soggy and slimy. Husband had to end up taking it back to get the correct pizza. Needless to say, don’t do delivery if you do have to, go up there and get it if you can so you can check to make sure your order is correct. They didn’t even offer to comp part of the order or anything once my husband got there.
… moreDouglas Rambert
I have to be honest I am on my seventh Pizza since the new year started. I don’t know if that’s a good thing or a bad thing but this is one of The most addictive pizzas I think I’ve had in a long time
… moreAlene Morrison
Delicious fresh pizza served with a smile. I have heard all about this place on Facebook and decided to give it a try. Boy was i pleased. Pizza was fantastic and we got the Jamaican jerk wings–omg what a treat!!!! Give this place a try. You will be very happy.
… moreAshley Mooney
What a gem find. One of the best pizzeria/wing spots in the city. We tried a pepperoni and jalapeno pizza, a bacon cheeseburger pizza, honey garlic wings, and slap yo momma Cajun wings. Everything was so full of flavor and worth every penny. The wings were perfectly sauced and crisped and do NOT skip out on the ranch, theirs is some of the best! The pizza crust was perfectly baked and seasoned, the cheese on the pizza was oozy, and the toppings were fresh. The pricing here is great, the customer service was phenomenal, and the atmosphere was very cozy. We will be recommending this place to others and in the meantime, enjoying it for ourselves. We may have accidentally liked it so much we went back within the same week
… moreJoycelyn Givner
Highly disappointed. Normally I like their wings. These were not worth $13 for 8 pieces. The bourbon peach had no flavor. Very dry and not worth charging an extra $1 for.
… moreJ “Ms. D” D
1st NOTthe best pizza! I have no idea how this place has a 4.7 on reviews.No toppings, I paid 14.00 online for a pepperoni and bacon pizza and in the store probably would have been 10.00 if I was having to pay more online then at least give me some toppings. The flavor was ok at best however a grocery store pizza is DEFINITELY the better route. Me and my son at one slice and the rest in the Trash. This place probably was better in another year when the family actually cared about the business but this wasn’t worth the 25min drive or the 14 bucks spent!
… moreevertonm8t
Gotta say the pizza is really good and worth the money, pricing is fair. I think the sauce is what sells it for me, being someone that makes their own pizzas the sauce is always the key. I appreciate the fact you can really taste the balanced amount of oregano. No idea why I haven’t tried this place before after years of going to the barbershop (they’re good too) next door, I’m glad I did. Looking forward to the family trying it. I ordered take away online, using the Dine app, pizza was ready in less than 20 minutes, was a Thursday so I suspect Fridays and weekends may take a little longer. Great spot, great pizza it’s worth your time. Support your small businesses.
… morePrecious Holmes
Great great friendly & welcoming service as soon as you hit the door!!! Enough about that let’s talk gooooooood pizza!! Delicious thin yet cooked perfectly crust, premium fresh toppings, sauce delicious, crust on the back seasoned to perfection! We drove 50 minutes to try these pizza pies & they did not disappoint! Oh they have beef pepperoni too! You on the way yet? My only small thing I wish I could’ve sat and ate there cuz it’s too damn good to wait to get home!
… moreDavid Griffin
Damn good wings!! I love oven cooked wings as opposed to deep fried. And these wings were meaty, not scrawny wings like you see it a lot of places.
I finally ordered pizza. It was good and probably the best in Douglasville. They were a bit “skimpy” on toppings, however. Great flavor
… more