Fat Tony’s Pizza is a family-owned pizzeria in Fort Myers serving quality, handcrafted pies made fresh every day. We focus on simple ingredients, consistent flavor, and pizzas baked in traditional deck ovens for that perfect balance of crisp and chewy. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick slice, a full pie, or takeout for the family, Fat Tony’s delivers honest food, friendly service, and a welcoming local vibe.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 9390 6 Mile Cypress Pkwy, Fort Myers, FL 33966
Phone: (239) 990-6967
Website: https://fattonyspizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Fat Tony’s Pizza | Fort Myers FL – Facebook
Just opened in Fort Myers near the Walmart on 6 mile just south of colonial in front of BJ’s. @fat Tony’s The pizza was great both times and the meatball Parm …
Fat Tony’s Pizza – FORT MYERS, FL | Online Ordering – Clover
Fat Tony’s Pizza · Small 12″ Pizza · Large 16″ Pizza · Extra Large 20″ Pizza · Strombolis & Calzones · Appetizers · Salads · Paninis · Pasta. Sunday Gravy & …
New pizza joint brings its New York vibe to Fort Myers
Retired New Yorkers Marie and Steve Quaranta opened Fat Tony’s pizza place in Fort Myers. · The fast-casual restaurant specializes in New York …
Reviews
Nichole A
Every single time I place an order it’s never ready when I get there which is not the main issue, the issue is the cheese constantly balling up and pulling even after we let cool. We got a half and half pizza a few weeks ago to give this place a shot and when we got it I assumed my husband dropped it because of the appearance, the spicy vodka side was a disaster and 2 slices had no cheese on them since it was all over, last night we ordered a plain pizza literally just cheese and we let cool for 30 mins! This is what we got, never again, also those are dinner rolls not garlic knots.
… moreSandra Arriola
We’ve been to many pizza places around the area here in Fort Myers. We wanted to try this new place that just opened Fat Tony’s made our pizza.That first bite and It was really good. I’m originally from NY and been living in Florida for over 19 years. HE NAILED IT! The only suggestion that I mentioned, maybe add chicken wings to the menu. We will be frequent customers at our new pizza establishment.
… moreJoe Nop (JoeNop)
The garlic knots are good a little bit doughy could use more garlic. The hand tossed pizza is really good. I Prefer New York style a little bit thinner less bread.
Great atmosphere and great customer service. I will definitely be back. Welcome to the neighborhood!
… moreGreat atmosphere and great customer service. I will definitely be back. Welcome to the neighborhood!
Silkrode
Just stopped by tonight for dinner and the food was absolutely delicious. Best pizza ive had in Fort Myers by far! We ordered the Butcher’s shop pizza and a meatball panini, both were great. Staff was also very friendly! We will definitely be coming back!
… moreKelly Peluso
New restaurant in Fort Myers. Overall, not bad. Tomato sauce was sweeter than expected. Delivery through UberEats took over an hour. Quality of the food when it arrived wasn’t great but it wasn’t the restaurant’s fault. Not sure why it took the driver over an hour. We will try Fat Tony’s again, but in person. Their specialty pizzas are not available through UberEats. I am interested in trying The Bianca.
… moreJoseph Rios
Hey Fam!
I drove 150 miles to visit my niece, and this place happened to be just a short walk from her home. We decided to order dinner from here, and I was blown away by the quality of the food especially the unbelievably delicious garlic rolls.
Today I stopped by in person and had the pleasure of meeting Fat Tony himself. He’s a humble, welcoming man who runs a spotless, wholesome restaurant with real pride in his craft.
If you’re anywhere in the area, you must stop by, sit down, and enjoy a meal. You will not be disappointed.
… moreI drove 150 miles to visit my niece, and this place happened to be just a short walk from her home. We decided to order dinner from here, and I was blown away by the quality of the food especially the unbelievably delicious garlic rolls.
Today I stopped by in person and had the pleasure of meeting Fat Tony himself. He’s a humble, welcoming man who runs a spotless, wholesome restaurant with real pride in his craft.
If you’re anywhere in the area, you must stop by, sit down, and enjoy a meal. You will not be disappointed.
Heather Henry
Thank you for opening a decent spot around here!!! I ordered a small pepperoni pie well done and it arrived hot and fresh and the ingredients are quality. I can see the high quality flour and pepperoni and the sauce has great flavor. Premium cheese. You have a new customer!
… moreJason Leonard
Believe the 5 star reviews. This place has jumped into the top 5 in FTM. Do yourself a treat and go and eat it in the store when it’s best. You will be glad you did!!!! The garlic knots are the BEST and if you like your pizza on the well done side just ask. For just slices you also can’t go wrong!!!!
… moreJason
So glad this new spot arrived near my apartment. Crust is so perfectly thin and crispy. Comparable to NY/NJ pizza spots. Highly recommend
… moreChris Proudfoot
The best pizza my daughter and I have ever had! And the garlic knots were amazing as well! If I lived around here, I would be here all the time!
… more