Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4514 E Hwy 70, White Bluff, TN 37187
Phone: (615) 787-5181
Website: https://fatpappyspizza.net/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fat Pappy’s: Hand-Stretched Pizza, Oven-Baked Wings, and More!
We love our customers, so feel free to visit during normal business hours. Fat Pappy’s Pizza. 4514 Highway 70 E, White Bluff, Tennessee 37187, United States.
Pappy’s Pizza, 4514 Highway 70 E, White Bluff, TN 37187, US
Fat Pappy’s Pizza, located in White Bluff, TN, is your go-to destination for homemade, hand-stretched pizza and oven-baked wings.
Fat Pappy’s Pizza Restaurant in White Bluff, TN | Authentic Pizzas
Fat Pappy’s offers delicious, authentic pizzas in White Bluff, TN. Visit 4514 E Hwy 70 for a variety of flavorful options made with quality ingredients.
Reviews
Autumn Turner
Today I decided to stop by and eat here for lunch instead of dairy Queen cuz I was craving pizza my first time ever being here and oh my God is this the best pizza I have had I ordered a cheesy bread and a pizza and me and my boyfriend devoured it I think there’s maybe two slices left the atmosphere is great the tables are awesome the ladies inside were amazing it is a great place to come eat and especially if you’ve never tried it and you don’t know if it’s good or not trust me it is fantastic and it only cost us $25 for a medium Pizza a cheese bread and two drinks you can’t beat that deal y’all are amazing keep up the good work food is delicious
… moreSunshine Falls
Excellent, they have the best pizza I have tasted in a long while. It beats all the chains that are out there. It wasn’t greasy, and tasted delicious. When you walk in it’s like going back in time when things were simpler and quality was perfection. That’s one of the biggest draws. The over all quality is 100%. The staff was friendly and the menu has good variety. They also have good variety in sides like if you want bread sticks, onion rings, spicy cheese bites. They also have lasagna and chicken and ofc salads. Definitely worth the drive.
… moreJohn Green
Phone in order, pizza was fantastic. We called in an extra pizza on the way, they politely let us know it would be about 10min wait, no problem. Cheese, pepperoni and meat lovers were sooo good.
… moreMikeshia Davis
First mistake was trying BBQ Pulled Pork in a pizza joint and the homemade sauce tasted straight like Louisiana. BLT looked way better than it tasted. The quality of the bacon seemed very cheap and possibly microwaved.. As a Banana Pudding lover, I was excited to try it. But it was not exactly what I was looking for. The Coconut Cake was pretty decent. Absolutely loved the homey atmosphere though! And I will be returning to try some pizza.
… moreM Thomas
I had high hopes for “Fat Pappys” I really did.
Unfortunately, my hopes were dashed by multiple issues with my order for carry out.
1. We ordered 2 big boy salads one with double ham one with double bacon. The person on the other end of the phone read our order back to us correctly.
We in fact got one with something that appeared to be bacon and one with what was DEFINITELY NOT HAM.
Was it turkey? Was it chicken? Hard to really say.
What I CAN say is both salads were thrown away as they had almost a dishwasher / hot pepper flavor to them.
Not the kinda flavor we are used to when it comes to salad…..which brings me to the next issue.
2. We ordered a spaghetti plate and a lasagna plate..
The lasagna was the strangest tasting lasagna We have ever had hands down.
The Spaghetti? It was almost flavorless and both appeared to us to be factory produced though that may not be the case.
Regardless, they both were far FAR below expectations and certainly NOT WORTH ANYWHERE NEAR THE $60 plus price we paid for everything.
3. The “Texas Toast” were two tiny pieces of bread with cheese on them.
4. No one asked us what salad dressing we would like with the salad and the dressing we got smelled rank.
End result…. We paid $60 dollars for a meal that ended up in the garbage…….
There was only one family there when we picked up our food at 6:30 on a Saturday night.
That might ought to have been a warning.
Maybe they do pizza great?
We don’t know and to be honest will leave it to others to judge as we will not be back.
… moreUnfortunately, my hopes were dashed by multiple issues with my order for carry out.
1. We ordered 2 big boy salads one with double ham one with double bacon. The person on the other end of the phone read our order back to us correctly.
We in fact got one with something that appeared to be bacon and one with what was DEFINITELY NOT HAM.
Was it turkey? Was it chicken? Hard to really say.
What I CAN say is both salads were thrown away as they had almost a dishwasher / hot pepper flavor to them.
Not the kinda flavor we are used to when it comes to salad…..which brings me to the next issue.
2. We ordered a spaghetti plate and a lasagna plate..
The lasagna was the strangest tasting lasagna We have ever had hands down.
The Spaghetti? It was almost flavorless and both appeared to us to be factory produced though that may not be the case.
Regardless, they both were far FAR below expectations and certainly NOT WORTH ANYWHERE NEAR THE $60 plus price we paid for everything.
3. The “Texas Toast” were two tiny pieces of bread with cheese on them.
4. No one asked us what salad dressing we would like with the salad and the dressing we got smelled rank.
End result…. We paid $60 dollars for a meal that ended up in the garbage…….
There was only one family there when we picked up our food at 6:30 on a Saturday night.
That might ought to have been a warning.
Maybe they do pizza great?
We don’t know and to be honest will leave it to others to judge as we will not be back.
Linda Johnson
First time to stop here…leaving Nashville
..saw their store on way in. Nice inside..whiskey barrels ..set up nice. Service a little light…food came out fairly quick hot and fresh. Only couple choices for beer still ok. Flavor good for calzone, meatball sandwich needs maybe little more seasoning. I’m glad we stopped. Next time in Nashville area we will explore more on the menu. Try them when you’re in white bluff Tennessee.
… more..saw their store on way in. Nice inside..whiskey barrels ..set up nice. Service a little light…food came out fairly quick hot and fresh. Only couple choices for beer still ok. Flavor good for calzone, meatball sandwich needs maybe little more seasoning. I’m glad we stopped. Next time in Nashville area we will explore more on the menu. Try them when you’re in white bluff Tennessee.
Sean Grimes
Great little small town famoly shop. Very nice people. My wife and I came last night, we got the 8″ tomatoes basil (loved it). The only pizza I have ever eaten where I didn’t feel sluggish and weak after eating. Not greasy at all. The wall paintings were great, the t-shirts were funny.
The only advice I would give them is they should put up a sign that says “last order will be taken at (this time)” after we finished eating I went to go order a pizza to go and I was told they weren’t taking anymore orders. It was 10 minites before close, which is fine, but if I knew that I would’ve ordered my to-go order sooner.
Definitely would reccomend. Definitely will come again.
… moreThe only advice I would give them is they should put up a sign that says “last order will be taken at (this time)” after we finished eating I went to go order a pizza to go and I was told they weren’t taking anymore orders. It was 10 minites before close, which is fine, but if I knew that I would’ve ordered my to-go order sooner.
Definitely would reccomend. Definitely will come again.
Joseph C
Girlfriend and I decided to appeal to our craving for pizza here at Fat Pappy’s. We got fried pickles and two personal sized pizzas. One was buffalo chicken style, and the other was a pesto tomato style. The pickle fries were tasty, and each pizza maintained great flavors. Felt the pizza dough could have been a little crispier, but that’s nit-picking and personal preference. Overall, it was a good place to grab a pie and some apps. Heard their sandwiches are a must. Will go back to try them out. They also have an ice cream shop connected to the building.Oh, and the Seinfeld fans will love the easter egg.
… moreUSA Babe007
We stopped by after people told us to try it. We had calzones. They were great. It seemed to take awhile for it to be ready. I never complain about that as so many places don’t have the staff. Loved the tables they were so cool.
… moreLucky Blackwell
The pizza was very tough and didn’t have very much cheese, The waitress was Lame…
She was more into To go orders and never came by to check on us to see if we needed anything.
I’m a Top 10 Reviewer for Google Maps and I Don’t Recommend this Place.
… moreShe was more into To go orders and never came by to check on us to see if we needed anything.
I’m a Top 10 Reviewer for Google Maps and I Don’t Recommend this Place.