Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 939 Hulett St, Horseheads, NY 14845
Phone: (607) 846-3952
Website: https://fatcitybbq.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fat City BBQ
939 South Hulett Ave Horseheads, NY 14845. (607) 846 – 3952 · (607) 846 – 3952 · Home · Menu · Catering/Large Groups. More. Home · Menu · Catering/Large Groups.
Fat City BBQ | Horseheads NY – Facebook
Fat City is a quick service BBQ restaurant in Horseheads, NY. Our goal is to serve consi… See more. Barbecue Restaurant.
Fat City BBQ (@fatcitybbq) · Horseheads, NY – Instagram
Fat City is a quick service BBQ restaurant in Horseheads, NY. Open 11:30-7 Wed-Sat. Check out our fb page for more details and menu!
Reviews
Happy Customer
First time great experience! The girl that answered phone was kind and efficient! Super nice upon arrival! Food was bagged perfectly! Chicken sandwich was perfect ! The roll, coleslaw and pickle on the side is worth every cent! 10/10
… moreAntonino Giovenco
This is the second time I had to drive to Horseheads, NY for work and the 2 hour drive was worth it because I got to eat at Fat City again! The staff is amazing and I enjoyed my lunch of burnt ends, corn bread (definitely the best I’ve ever had, it was so moist that it tasted like cake!) mac & cheese, baked beans and apple pie, unfortunately they didn’t have the peanut butter pie which is to die for! I loved their bbq so much that I had to order a full slab of ribs with their incredible side dishes for my family to enjoy when I got back to Buffalo. Dinner was a hit, thank you Joe and all the staff at Fat City again!
… morePeyman Faghan
%100 recommended. Honestly there were 5 out of 5. I was driving from Princeton NJ to Toronto Canada and just I googled Brisket and I saw they are 4.9 star which they deserve to have 5 . Also thank you for google service to guide me here
… moreNYconcretejungle
Called and placed and order was greeted as I walked through the door by friendly staff. This is a nice little building on the edge of Elmira heights and horseheads/big flats. I ordered a Mac daddy platter it was very good and I will be back for it again. It also came with a side piece of cornbread it was very fresh and probably the best piece of cornbread I ever had. Overall 10/10 will be back again.
… moreThomas Hamilton
The ribs were fall off the bone amazing.
The chicken collard greens were flavourful and the corn bread was moist.
… moreThe chicken collard greens were flavourful and the corn bread was moist.
fia
the food is absolutely amazing, i have never had such good food in my life! the collard greens are phenomenal and i don’t think i can’t decide what meat is my favorite they are all smoked perfectly, the sauces are so amazing too i have never had a bbq quite like the apple bbq before. i highly recommend this place the employees are so kind and the place was cozy, from the cute decor to the delicious smell and friendly atmosphere!!
… moreBen Shaffer
They were sold out of the burnt ends when I ordered but the ribs did not disappoint. The ribs were falling off the bone, the pineapple BBQ sauce I got on them was fantastic. The apple coleslaw and corn bread were also great. I couldn’t rave more about the food, large portions and great service. I hope to be paying through Horseheads again so I can stop by.
… moreJamie Albucher
Heard good things so I had to check the place out. It’s small inside but incredibly clean! They clearly care about the quality of their food and establishment. The burnt ends and Mac and cheese I got were delicious, as well as the corn bread (it’s actually some of the best I’ve had!). Employees were polite, took my order quickly and got my food to me hot and fresh. Highly suggest this restaurant if you like good BBQ
… moreCharles Saunders
Amazing eatery!
Have been wanting to try this place for awhile, finally got a chance today.
Easy to get to, plenty of parking opportunities.
As soon as I opened the door, all I could smell was the delicious smoky scent of barbecue.
Small space inside, only two tables to eat at, but outdoor seating was also available.
Daily specials are posted, today happened to be smoked chicken wings, and a side cucumber salad was offered for an additional fee.
We ordered the Carolina Pork Platter and Pork Fat Platter with two sides.
The Carolina Pork Platter is dry rubbed, then wet mopped with a vinegar sauce, and comes topped with an apple slaw, which I wasn’t sure about at first but ended up being a delicious combination! Slightly smoky pork (perfectly prepared in my opinion) with the crunchy slaw and a side of the vinegar mop comes with the plate as did a warm piece of cornbread.
Portion was ample, better than I expected.
We ordered the Pork Fat Platter with two sides- macaroni salad and baked beans.
I’ve had many macaroni salads in my day, and generally they are all about the same, but I liked this version better than most for some reason. Not sure exactly how it is prepared, but it had boiled egg, anneli pasta, and celery.
The baked beans were above and beyond the usually supplied dish that is offered by others. There were cooked peppers included, and a sprinkling of bacon bits on top. Very well done!!!
Staff was SUPER friendly, and accommodating.
Will definitely return again!!!
… moreHave been wanting to try this place for awhile, finally got a chance today.
Easy to get to, plenty of parking opportunities.
As soon as I opened the door, all I could smell was the delicious smoky scent of barbecue.
Small space inside, only two tables to eat at, but outdoor seating was also available.
Daily specials are posted, today happened to be smoked chicken wings, and a side cucumber salad was offered for an additional fee.
We ordered the Carolina Pork Platter and Pork Fat Platter with two sides.
The Carolina Pork Platter is dry rubbed, then wet mopped with a vinegar sauce, and comes topped with an apple slaw, which I wasn’t sure about at first but ended up being a delicious combination! Slightly smoky pork (perfectly prepared in my opinion) with the crunchy slaw and a side of the vinegar mop comes with the plate as did a warm piece of cornbread.
Portion was ample, better than I expected.
We ordered the Pork Fat Platter with two sides- macaroni salad and baked beans.
I’ve had many macaroni salads in my day, and generally they are all about the same, but I liked this version better than most for some reason. Not sure exactly how it is prepared, but it had boiled egg, anneli pasta, and celery.
The baked beans were above and beyond the usually supplied dish that is offered by others. There were cooked peppers included, and a sprinkling of bacon bits on top. Very well done!!!
Staff was SUPER friendly, and accommodating.
Will definitely return again!!!
Taj Ismail
I do like this barbeque place but the food is hit or miss. The brisket is not always tender the burnt ends aren’t always tender. Today I got brisket and my husband got ribs. My brisket definitely could have been better, the macaroni salad was ok. my husband ribs were good and the brisket chili and greens he didn’t care for.
… more