Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4404 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43214
Website: https://fatarnies.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop | Sandwich Shop in Columbus, OH
Sandwich shop located inside a popular dive bar in Columbus, OH. We offer high quality sandwiches, shareables, weekly specials and a special late night menu …
Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop | Columbus OH – Facebook
Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop delivers on taste and customer service. I went to try their food after hearing so many great reviews on St Patrick’s day and the …
Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop (@fat_arnies_sandwichshop) – Instagram
4.4K+ followers · 160 posts · Follow our evolving menu! Located inside Rafters Beer Pub Wednesday/Thursday 5pm-9pm Friday/Saturday 11am-9pm Sunday 11am-7pm.
Reviews
JJ Crisostomo
A great find in Clintonville. The sandwich shop is inside the Rafter’s Beer Pub in Indianola. I love the classic pub vibe. Try their fried pork bellies as well as empanadas for something different with your beer. Fast and polite service, and lots of parking around the place. Highly recommended!
… moreAshley Andracki
WOW. there’s nothin like it in clitonville and im not sure Columbus. The sandwhich reminded me of being in Italy! Can’t wait to go back and try more!! Highly recommend. Owner is so sweet he gave us a free sandwich!! Support local!!
… moreColumbus Food Dude
Fat Arnie’s is the place to be on Saturdays! The fried pork belly chicharrones are dangerously good crispy, rich, and packed with flavor. I swear I went into a full food daze while inhaling every single bite.
But don’t wait… these sell out fast and once they’re gone, they’re gone. Tucked in the back of Rafters Beer Pub is a hidden gem of a kitchen just waiting for your order. Trust me, this is one you don’t want to miss.
… moreBut don’t wait… these sell out fast and once they’re gone, they’re gone. Tucked in the back of Rafters Beer Pub is a hidden gem of a kitchen just waiting for your order. Trust me, this is one you don’t want to miss.
Carrie Young
Delicious food, obviously made with lots of love and care. The chile rubbed chicken sandwich was insane, so juicy and flavorful. And the staff is so friendly and kind. Definitely worth a visit!
… moremexibilly75
Excellent food. Recommend highly. Well worth it….
2nd review
Lord…. Every time we come the food is excellent. Well worth trip. Rafters serving good drinks and Fat Arnie’s absolutely crushing with the food… You will not be disappointed.
… more2nd review
Lord…. Every time we come the food is excellent. Well worth trip. Rafters serving good drinks and Fat Arnie’s absolutely crushing with the food… You will not be disappointed.
Kelly Rowoldt
Fat Arnie’s inside of Rafters Beer Pub on Indianola is a must on the weekend! The chicharron melts in your mouth and comes with three sauces. We also had the beef and pork empanadas that were delicious! The pork has a pickled jalapeno for an added surprise.
… moreBrett zumFelde
Excellent new place recently opened inside Rafters. Really delicious burger and empenada. Highly recommend checking them out.
… moreMatthew Gonzalez
Incredibly good food. Excellent Italian sub, the chicharron were amazing and make sure not to pass on the empanadas. The service was also great, super friendly. Will definitely be coming back
… moreKevin Johnson
What a welcome addition to the neighborhood!
The burger was spot on. Perfectly held together until the last bite. All the components played well together. The salt level was on point.
The Arnie Verde was a fantastic veggie option. Thick chunk of cheese, tomato, arugula, and chimichurri on ciabatta.
Pretty excited to check out the rest of the menu and specials!
… moreThe burger was spot on. Perfectly held together until the last bite. All the components played well together. The salt level was on point.
The Arnie Verde was a fantastic veggie option. Thick chunk of cheese, tomato, arugula, and chimichurri on ciabatta.
Pretty excited to check out the rest of the menu and specials!
Mr2mat0o
Went for the chicharrón pork belly special on Saturday — it hit the spot. Super crunchy and porky. Also got The Apollonia, which was really good.
Update- I went back and got some empanadas. They were fantastic. So good that I got my Peruvian grandma asking for them. The Italian empanada in my opinion is what a pepperoni hotpocket wishes it was. Grandmas favorite is the Mojo Pork.
… moreUpdate- I went back and got some empanadas. They were fantastic. So good that I got my Peruvian grandma asking for them. The Italian empanada in my opinion is what a pepperoni hotpocket wishes it was. Grandmas favorite is the Mojo Pork.