Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3108 6 Mile Rd, Caledonia, WI 53402
Phone: (262) 456-2348
Website: http://everlysicecream.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
EVERLY’S ICE CREAM.COM
Discover the finest ice cream shops near you. Visit Everly’s Ice Cream for Paisley’s Premiums and more delicious ice cream flavors.
Everly’s | Racine WI – Facebook
From classic favorites to innovative creations, our menu is a celebration of creativity and taste. Ice Cream Shop · (262) 456-2348.
Everlys Ice Cream (@everlysicecream) · Caledonia, WI – Instagram
Photo by Everlys Ice Cream on March 13, 2025. ‼️ Flavor Alert ‼️ Pothole Mackinac Island Fudge now in stock. This is Dark Chocolate flavored ice cream blended …
Reviews
Ash
Omg the lady who works in the morning with blonde hair during the week is the nicest, sweetest bubbliest person, not only is she nice but she makes the best coffee drinks and muffins. The place is cute, fun, clean and pink! My child’s favorite is blue moon ice cream with cotton candy crunch
… moreMadeline Harrison
Such an adorable ice cream shop! Friendly staff, fast service & great atmosphere. The whole menu sounds amazing definitely will be back to try more
… moreChristine Rivers
This is a wonderful place to enjoy a delicious treat. They offer cookies, ice cream, coffee, ice cream cakes, and donuts, with dairy-free and gluten-free options available. The pictured treat also supported Veterans Outreach of Wisconsin.
… moreJustin kumorkiewicz
Super friendly and kind. This place is a community gem that we all need to support as they give so much back. The community events and outreach they do is so great. They offer food options for everyone’s taste. It does get pretty busy sometimes so make sure you’re not in a hurry but it’s always worth the wait.
… moreWhitney T. A.
My go-to coffee shop! Rival’s starbucks anyday of the week. High quality coffee beans and very tasty drinks! Plus, they are always coming up with new ice cream flavors! Even my dog gets excited when he sees me with these cups, since he gets the whip cream haha
… moreTaj Lane
The most delicious ice cream thing I’ve ever had and the only ice cream that doesn’t give me a headache and make me feel like crap after I eat it, so I’m guessing that’s because it’s better quality than other places.
… moreHUSK
Love this place, me and my bestie ride here all the time on our bikes, food is great, the atmosphere, everything, just a great place in general, I recommend going here (edit) I got the pumpkin sundae, so good!
… moreJD Rudd
Even if you’re not in the area, it’s worth the drive to check this place out. Friendly staff every time we’ve visited. Prices are great. And the ice cream is fantastic. Lots of different options to try as well.
If you’re wondering “is this place any good”…the answer is a resounding YES!
… moreIf you’re wondering “is this place any good”…the answer is a resounding YES!
Joanna Sarrett
The Big Muddie ice cream was delicious! Dark chocolate, brownie bits, and caramel swirl..The prices are very affordable too. It was a pleasure to support this local gem.
… morePaige Zinke
The menu is kind of overwhelming, so by the time I ordered I forgot that 1 topping is included. The employee who took my order did not remind me/ask if we wanted any toppings. I remembered after our order was already scooped and I felt weird asking for toppings at that point since the one who took our order wasn’t very friendly and neither was the one who scooped it. I specifically wanted to go there for their “playdough” (blue moon + cookie dough) that they just advertised on fb a few days prior, but that wasn’t an option and I didn’t see any cookie dough to add to the blue moon (also why I forgot we got toppings). The plain blue moon tasted like Cedar Crest, which isn’t bad, but I could just go to the store and buy it… The snickerdoodle cookies tasted freezer burned. Overall very disappointing experience.
… more