Laurel A
5 stars all the way around! It was so good that we went back the next day. The food definitely tasted like authentic Italian cuisine. Our servers were amazing and the atmosphere felt like we were in Grandma Evelyn’s home kitchen. Meravigliosa!
… moreMikyra Reign
This place has become a regular for me!!! We’re always treated like family and the food is absolutely Italian with the amount also being Italian, you never leave hungry and have some to bring home. Shout out to our new favorite waitress “Violet ” you made our day soooo much better . By the way the photo taken was “after” I shared 1/2 with my friend. BIG portions ,,,so enough to share
… moreSplendor Promised
This place has gone down severely since the death of Evelyn in 2019. In 2021 & 22, I ate in several times and enjoyed a quick quaint local place to get a nice bite with good table service. But the young men that work cooking food don’t seem to take their jobs too seriously nor care about the quality or presentation of the food or how well it’s cooked by health department standards.
The Veggie pizza slice had like warm large slices of vegetables piled high with no cheese at all. The crust was tough and tasted day old and the sauce was slopped onto the single slice.
I didn’t like the way the pizza slice was handed to me across the counter, nor how unpersonable and disinterested the young Hispanic person that made it seemed towards a customer.
I didn’t feel good about asking for it to be reheated/re-cheesed so I sat outside at a table and ate what I could. I took the rest home and oven reheated, seasoned and re-cheesed the sloppily garbage tasting replica.
The environment is clammy, dark and filled with pizza boxes in the front booths at the entrance, as to push customers to the rear of the restaurant to eat in one of the two eating sections. The place has gone down but I still see people placing large to go pizza orders of two or more pies. Beware of this place at times. I hate to have to write this but I have to live with myself, maybe your experience might be different. Good luck there.
… moresidney laws
This was my first time at Evelyn’s Big Italian and I have passed it many times going on Texas Street. I happen to be working the Farmers Market across the street and was just going in to use the restroom. When I walked in, the food smelled good and I decided to get a slice of pizza. I thought it was takeout only, but around the side there are 2 areas for dining in. The booths in the entry were full of pizza boxes, so I’m guessing they sell a lot of pizza. Customer service was great and it took about 15 minutes to get a slice of Vegetarian pizza with extra mushrooms and olives. It was so big that I sliced it up and split it. It was delicious and I will definitely go back to try other items.
… moreTom G.
Our server is Fantastic. Although it took some time for dinner to arrive. It was worth the time it took to make. They had a slight oven malfunction but. The Bianca Pizza. The best choice i could have made here at Evelyns. Coming back!
… moreMaria Mcintyre
Food was good. Service was average. It was good to support local restaurants rather than a franchise restaurant.
… moreLuis Canas
I’m always pleased with the quality of my order. The staff is awesome. Very friendly and courteous. My latest order was a New York Pizza Combo 16″ and my family loved it. Looking forward for my next visit.
… morejohn milligan
Never get the lasagna special. It’s like lasagna soup and not good tasting
Stoffers frozen lasagna way way better. No paper towels in the bathroom. Asked for another portion., please don’t make it like soup. Came like soup again. Terrible . Zero strars. Never. Never again
… moreKRISTIN
Evelyn’s serves the best pizza for a great price. You can actually get a huge slice of their delicious pizza for $6
If I lived in Fairfield I’d probably eat there all the time. Can’t wait for my next visit to Fairfield. The quaint ambiance and tasty food makes me want to come back and try their pasta.
… moreDan Lam
I was in the mood for pizza after our first option was a bust (closed for the evening). We were near Fairfield, CA, so my daughter recommended Evelyn’ Pizza. We all order the slice because the whole pizza take about 30 minutes to make. The slice still take about 10 to 15 minutes. We also Ordered an order of calamari. We finished the calamari before we got home in the car so no pic. It was delicious though . The pizza was the largest per slice I have ever since. It must came out from the 32 inches pizza you can ordered. The pizza was great and tasty . It was very good experience. Here are some pictures . The place is very tight but you can dine in if you want.
… more