Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Enzo’s Pizza We’re gonna make you a pizza you can’t refuse! We are a family-owned business, not a chain. Our dough is made and baked in-house daily and contains no seed oils. Our pizza sauce and salad dressings are made in-house. Our meats, cheeses, and vegetables are always fresh, never frozen or ultra-processed.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5909 Andrews Rd, Mentor, OH 44060
Phone: (440) 290-0377
Website: https://www.enzospizzashop.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Enzo’s Pizza
See our latest menu, find our hours, and order online directly from us. Locations in Mentor, OH.
Enzo’s Pizza | Mentor OH – Facebook
Enzo’s Pizza is open 11am-9pm daily! 5909 Andrews Rd. (440) 290-0377 www.enzospizzashop.com Reminder: deliveries must be ordered through the website as our …
Enzo’s Pizza Menu Mentor-on-the-Lake – Postmates
5909 Andrews Road, Mentor, OH 44060 $$ • Pizza • American • Italian x $0 delivery fee Other fees x Enter address to see delivery time.
Last Updates
Reviews
Jason Green
I’ve been wanting to write about my food experience, since the night I got my food, was just to tired and have been very busy, but I got time now. Yeah, so either the people saying this place is amazing have had a different experience then me, or they’re friends with the owner or something. First ording the pizza online, not a single clue of what extra toppings cost, honestly still don’t I’ll post a picture of my receipt. Okay so the pizza, for some odd reason it did not look burnt at all, the bottom was a little dark, but not burnt, but for some reason every bite tasted like it was. I had requested extra sauce on the pizza, which in return they bearly put any on, again I’ll post a pic. The meatballs were cut in half which at first found odd, but upon trying them, they were drier then a granola bar, and tasted microwaved, and honestly on the verge of spoiled. The chicken salad, the chicken was honestly worse then jerkey, it was so incredibly dry and hard, thought i almost broke a tooth on my first bite, and not joking the salad was, if not more 3/4s tomatoes and onions, this sadly I did not get a picture of, because of the tooth incident i threw it right in the garbage, where everything ended up honestly minus 2 pieces of pizza I choked down cause I just spent $51 and was starving. On the menu they say a 3×3 pice of cheese cake, welllllll I’m being generous here 1.5 x 1.5, it wasn’t horrible, but was kinda warm and tasted like it had been sitting out awhile and was kinda melted over. About an hour give or take I’d say of eating this, the heavens opened up and spent most of the night back and forth to the facilities. So like I said either it was an off night, which still isn’t acceptable for $51 or the people raving about this place are friends or something else. Advice go get a frozen pizza it’s a tenth of the price and 100% better, unless you like throwing your money in the trash can like I did, which I’m still super angry about. This is the first review I’ve ever had to write and hopefully the last. Ohh yeah, just remembered uploading these pics, also dont know how much I was charged per topping, but there was like almost no pinapple on there!! Okay so uploading this reciept from my email, I finally see what i was charged for these toppings and also extra sauce haha now I’m even more pissed off!!!!
… moreTina DeGeorge
This was my fIrst time trying Enzo’s, and I’ve been wanting to for awhile, especially seeing all the positive reviews. I had delivered a pizza with one topping.
– Didn’t like the sauce- it was thick and tasted mostly like tomato paste.
– It was pretty cheesy. Had ordered the ‘fresh mozzarella’. I wasn’t sure what that meant, as menu didn’t explain it, but I thought I would try it. It was good, no complaints there, not sure it’s worth the up charge though. Would have to compare it to just regular cheese to decide.
– The real issue was that it was ALL crust! The sauce and toppings were spread and baked mostly in the middle. Whoever made it didn’t bring the ingredients out towards the outer rim of the pizza, so the crust was huge. Who likes that much crust? You’re just eating a large amount of baked, dry flavorless dough.
Overall, very disappointing. The pizza was moderately priced in my opinion, so to get 1/3 of it as crust, was definitely not worth it. I’m not picky on pizza, I like most of them, but this one I didn’t care for. Taste-wise it just wasn’t very good, between the sauce taste and nothing-but-dough of the pizza overall.
… more– Didn’t like the sauce- it was thick and tasted mostly like tomato paste.
– It was pretty cheesy. Had ordered the ‘fresh mozzarella’. I wasn’t sure what that meant, as menu didn’t explain it, but I thought I would try it. It was good, no complaints there, not sure it’s worth the up charge though. Would have to compare it to just regular cheese to decide.
– The real issue was that it was ALL crust! The sauce and toppings were spread and baked mostly in the middle. Whoever made it didn’t bring the ingredients out towards the outer rim of the pizza, so the crust was huge. Who likes that much crust? You’re just eating a large amount of baked, dry flavorless dough.
Overall, very disappointing. The pizza was moderately priced in my opinion, so to get 1/3 of it as crust, was definitely not worth it. I’m not picky on pizza, I like most of them, but this one I didn’t care for. Taste-wise it just wasn’t very good, between the sauce taste and nothing-but-dough of the pizza overall.
Mitchell Heller
Met the owner other evening so gave it a try. Pizza was excellent, nice size, plenty of sauce and cheese. Cinnamon rolls and antipasto salad were very good as well. Everything fresh. Would definitely recommend giving them a try
… moreChris Rehner
Ordered for the 1st time for delivery on Feb. 21st 2026. I am always looking for a good pizza place. This by far is the best in the area. Would highly recommend. I ordered the carnivor pizza and it was delicious. Will definitely be ordering from here again. They have a very nice selection on their menu!
… moreMar G
The store itself is so clean with amazing cohesive branding, modern design & everyone behind the counter were so welcoming and nice! We’ve been looking for a new pizza place, since it seems like other local places have been less quality & poor service, but Enzo’s is exactly what we’ve been waiting for! Food was 10/10 delicious! We now have our weekly pizza spot, and the location is so nice too! Thank you team for giving the locals a better option for homemade, quality food with amazing service and decent prices!
To the person who thinks my review is fake: I appreciate your compliment, and I went opening day and I still stand by my review, their pizza is delicious!
… moreTo the person who thinks my review is fake: I appreciate your compliment, and I went opening day and I still stand by my review, their pizza is delicious!
Danielle Davis
Was curious if this place was good, they had a special for lunch. 2 slices of pizza and a can of pop so I decided to try it. I’m so glad I did! Pizza is great and I’m a real pizza fanatic. 10/10 will definitely try other pizza flavors for sure. (Only 1 pizza shown because I ate the other one lol)
… moreD K
Pretty good pizza I can’t complain. Price isn’t bad. Tasty and fresh. Good customer service. Clean on the inside of the pizza shop. The pizza rolls are great as well. I would recommend trying this place out if your in the nearby area.
… moreAriona Campbell-washington
Ordered a pizza online and went to pick it up. I didn’t mind the wait because I placed it 30 minutes before closing but when I got home, all of the toppings slid off my pizza and it was barely any sauce. I’m out of a meal now. I know this place is new so hopefully it will get better with time
To reply to the owner: I’m not removing my review. To purposely scrape cheese and toppings off of a pizza is crazy. I never tip the pizza over or anything. I picked it up and it slid off . Everything that I said in my review is honest if you can’t take one bad review and use it as a learning lesson to improve your business than that is on you. I never once said anything bad about your business. I would actually come back and try it again, but to tell me to delete my review, based off of me lying is unprofessional. Everybody has a right to their opinion, and that is mine. I truly wish your business nothing but success.
… moreTo reply to the owner: I’m not removing my review. To purposely scrape cheese and toppings off of a pizza is crazy. I never tip the pizza over or anything. I picked it up and it slid off . Everything that I said in my review is honest if you can’t take one bad review and use it as a learning lesson to improve your business than that is on you. I never once said anything bad about your business. I would actually come back and try it again, but to tell me to delete my review, based off of me lying is unprofessional. Everybody has a right to their opinion, and that is mine. I truly wish your business nothing but success.
Matthew F
Ordered Enzos for delivery, thought i would try it out. Since moving out of the Heights to Lake County I have yet to find even decent pizza. It’s like there is a law against decent pizza in this county. I’ve tried many, it’s shameful. I gotta say, Enzos is really freaking good.
Crust has a decent flavor, it’s got a tougher chewy exterior and soft inside. Sauce is good, not over powering but a really good compliment. Decent amount of quality cheese and they don’t skimp on toppings.
To say I’m excited about finding good pizza would be an understatement. Definitely found my new go to.
… moreCrust has a decent flavor, it’s got a tougher chewy exterior and soft inside. Sauce is good, not over powering but a really good compliment. Decent amount of quality cheese and they don’t skimp on toppings.
To say I’m excited about finding good pizza would be an understatement. Definitely found my new go to.
A’Ric DeShay-Scott
I got the Meat pizza and it was DELICIOUS. Crispy yet fluffy crust. Toppings in every bite. Good sauce. Not a super long wait.
… more