Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
No-frills option for pies, slices, wings & subs served over the counter, plus late-night delivery.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1870 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY 14210
Phone: (716) 362-8750
Website: http://emergencypizza.net/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Great Food Emergency Pizza Delivery South Buffalo
Emergency Pizza has all night delivery! CALL NOW: (716) 362-8750 Order subs, tacos, wings, pizza, and dinners and more.
Emergency Pizza – Buffalo, NY – 1870 Seneca St – Hours, Menu, Order
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Emergency Pizza in Buffalo, NY. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Emergency Pizza – 1870 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY 14210 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Buffalo, NY! Emergency Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy your …
Reviews
Scott Levergood
Disappointed by the pricing inconsistency and overall experience.
I’m writing this to document exactly what happened and to encourage clear pricing transparency. I am attaching two photos for clarity :
• A photo of the printed in-store menu
• A screenshot of the Google menu listing showing $17.99
I ordered a large pepperoni pizza for pickup after seeing $17.99 listed on Google. When I arrived, I grabbed a 2-liter from the fridge and went to the counter. I was told my total was $34 and change.
That immediately confused me because:
• Google lists $17.99 for a large one-topping
• The printed in-store menu lists $24.99 for a large one-topping
Even accounting for a soda and tax, the total quoted did not clearly align with those numbers.
When I said I wouldn’t purchase it at that price, I was told they would “give it to me for what it says on there.” During the conversation, staff acknowledged they are aware the Google pricing is incorrect and claimed someone else created the listing and they cannot access it to fix it.
I even took time to show them on my phone how they could use tools like ChatGPT to look up how to regain access to their Google Business account and correct the issue so this doesn’t continue happening to customers. The staff member read it and thanked me , and another employee stated they would give me the 2-liter for free.
However, after saying they would honor the online price and that the soda would be free, the total then shifted again and was quoted around $28.
If the price was being adjusted to $17.99 and the soda was free, the math still did not make sense.
At that point, I explained that the only reason I ordered was because of what it said online and that I only had $25 available. They then agreed to take the $25. I chose not to continue pressing the issue further, as the interaction had already become uncomfortable and tense.
I ultimately paid $25 and left feeling uneasy. The shifting totals and the acknowledgment that the Google listing is known to be inaccurate contributed to that feeling.
Separately, the pizza quality did not match the pricing being discussed.
I’m not writing this out of anger. I’m writing it so future customers confirm pricing before pickup and so public listings reflect accurate information. Clear and consistent pricing protects everyone.
… moreI’m writing this to document exactly what happened and to encourage clear pricing transparency. I am attaching two photos for clarity :
• A photo of the printed in-store menu
• A screenshot of the Google menu listing showing $17.99
I ordered a large pepperoni pizza for pickup after seeing $17.99 listed on Google. When I arrived, I grabbed a 2-liter from the fridge and went to the counter. I was told my total was $34 and change.
That immediately confused me because:
• Google lists $17.99 for a large one-topping
• The printed in-store menu lists $24.99 for a large one-topping
Even accounting for a soda and tax, the total quoted did not clearly align with those numbers.
When I said I wouldn’t purchase it at that price, I was told they would “give it to me for what it says on there.” During the conversation, staff acknowledged they are aware the Google pricing is incorrect and claimed someone else created the listing and they cannot access it to fix it.
I even took time to show them on my phone how they could use tools like ChatGPT to look up how to regain access to their Google Business account and correct the issue so this doesn’t continue happening to customers. The staff member read it and thanked me , and another employee stated they would give me the 2-liter for free.
However, after saying they would honor the online price and that the soda would be free, the total then shifted again and was quoted around $28.
If the price was being adjusted to $17.99 and the soda was free, the math still did not make sense.
At that point, I explained that the only reason I ordered was because of what it said online and that I only had $25 available. They then agreed to take the $25. I chose not to continue pressing the issue further, as the interaction had already become uncomfortable and tense.
I ultimately paid $25 and left feeling uneasy. The shifting totals and the acknowledgment that the Google listing is known to be inaccurate contributed to that feeling.
Separately, the pizza quality did not match the pricing being discussed.
I’m not writing this out of anger. I’m writing it so future customers confirm pricing before pickup and so public listings reflect accurate information. Clear and consistent pricing protects everyone.
Jennifer Gawron
I just received my food and I’m honestly absolutely disappointed for my $65. I order the family pack LG pizza and 20 wings. It was my bad that I had an ancient menu so the price issue is my own fault. I never order out so today was a splurge day… wish I hadn’t. The wings were supposed to be medium they were barely sauced and MB mild. I think all the sauce was at the bottom of the box under the foil. The pizza was undercooked and bland but the bright part was I ordered onion on it and if u like onions it was covered in them. It’s been a while since I ordered from them and it use to be great so I’m quite surprised. I honestly wished I would’ve sent it back like I was going to. The delivery guy and the guy who answered the phone were really nice and eager to please so I give them a . Everything else not so much.
… moreCrysti Golpl
This was our second time ordering here and once again, we’re very impressed! The gentleman checking the online orders actually called us to verify the sub ingredients, and I’ve never gotten that attention to detail any time I forgot to add the extras we wanted on our food. Much appreciated, very kind and very professional. The delivery man was very pleeasant, and called to say he was here, which was great because it saved our dog from going crazy lol. Most importantly, our 2 subs and onion rings were absolutely delicious! Please keep up the great work!
… moreAngela Barbuto
This is what we got for a double chicken finger dinner there was maybe 4 whole fingers and all these little hard bits for 40 dollars were very disappointed because our food is usually well prepared and delicious
… moreJayna Drury
I grew up in the northtowns and when I moved to south buffalo it was quite the journey to find decent pizza. Emergency is by far the best in south buffalo. Cooked to perfection everytime. Consistent and delicious. The pictures on my shitty camera don’t do it justice.
… moreMike Raczkowski
Had the fish fry. Was very good. I will definitely order it again. Very fast service
… moreAngel Hartman
Way too overpriced considering the lack of quality but even if it was really good I’m not willing to pay $29 for one small pepperoni pizza with nothing else to be delivered that’s absolutely insane never againnnn :((
… moreZAK DELONG
Pizza is delicious got a party pizza for my dad first time getting from here and Jim the owner is an absolute delight to talk to. Jim you know what you did thank you sir!
… moreStructure Ism
Hands down some of the best food in the pizza and wings sector of this wonderful City.
The pizza is stunning fresh and portions are awesome.
The wings are absolutely amazing jumbo and perfectly sauced.
I have tried a number of the specialty items as well, that you typically don’t find in many pizzerias ….
The house made jumbo meatballs are stunning whether you get them with the spaghetti or on a sub.
—
The barbecue ribs are perfect juicy falling off the bone and melt in your mouth.
—
The Friday fish fry is one of the best I have had anywhere in the city.
—
DeVille parmesan and chicken parmesan are also absolutely stunning. Large portions and perfectly seasoned with plenty of cheese and herbs.
—
The eggplant parmesan was a big surprise it was absolutely bursting with flavor and a very nice portion size.
—
I have had a few of their subs over time always super fresh , flavorful with hefty portions of meat that I’m told are sliced fresh … that must be the case because these are some of the best subs in the city.
—
And the best thing about this restaurant is that they are open until 2:00 a.m. !!!!!!
Not many options at all after 10:00 p.m. in Buffalo anymore.
—
The only downfall is they add a 4% charge on orders after 10:00 p.m. which makes no sense to me at all.
Also , their hefylty delivery charge is between three and five dollars depending on your distance from the location.
… moreThe pizza is stunning fresh and portions are awesome.
The wings are absolutely amazing jumbo and perfectly sauced.
I have tried a number of the specialty items as well, that you typically don’t find in many pizzerias ….
The house made jumbo meatballs are stunning whether you get them with the spaghetti or on a sub.
—
The barbecue ribs are perfect juicy falling off the bone and melt in your mouth.
—
The Friday fish fry is one of the best I have had anywhere in the city.
—
DeVille parmesan and chicken parmesan are also absolutely stunning. Large portions and perfectly seasoned with plenty of cheese and herbs.
—
The eggplant parmesan was a big surprise it was absolutely bursting with flavor and a very nice portion size.
—
I have had a few of their subs over time always super fresh , flavorful with hefty portions of meat that I’m told are sliced fresh … that must be the case because these are some of the best subs in the city.
—
And the best thing about this restaurant is that they are open until 2:00 a.m. !!!!!!
Not many options at all after 10:00 p.m. in Buffalo anymore.
—
The only downfall is they add a 4% charge on orders after 10:00 p.m. which makes no sense to me at all.
Also , their hefylty delivery charge is between three and five dollars depending on your distance from the location.
Abisai Cañedo
This was some good pizza. Got the party pizza for 6 of is and a few kids and it was a lot.
Person that took our order was nice and helpful.
Wings were fresh and tasty…pizza was really good, really cheesy…
… morePerson that took our order was nice and helpful.
Wings were fresh and tasty…pizza was really good, really cheesy…