Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Greek-style pies, cold-cut subs & basic Italian pastas served in a stalwart counter-serve joint.
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 625 Maple Hill Ave, Newington, CT 06111
Phone: (860) 666-4649
Website: https://www.elmhillpizza.com/our-menu/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Our Menu – Elm Hill Pizza
Home · Our Menu · About Us · Gallery · Directions · Contact. CALL US NOW(860) 666-4649. Pizza Restaurant in Newington, CT.
Order Elm Hill Pizza – Newington, CT Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Elm Hill Pizza at 625 Maple Hill Avenue in Newington. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Elm Hill Pizza | Newington CT – Facebook
Details. . 98% recommend (32 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . 625 Maple Hill Ave, Newington, CT, United States, 06111 ; Links. . elmhillpizza.com ; Contact …
Reviews
Daze Xvenom
The pizza and wings are delicious. We had half special and half buffalo chicken and vegetable. The wings were spot on. Jane and the whole crew where awesome.
… moreKristina Warnaar
One of my all time favorite pizza places! They’re always busy, but they are always right on time with when they say the order will be ready. We always get a pepperoni and a buffalo chicken pizza. The buffalo chicken pizza is AMAZING. Red sauce but still with a great buffalo flavor. And breaded chicken… Last time we dined in and were taken such good care of. Forever suggesting this place to people! Usually our pizza is square cut (which we prefer), but wasn’t done this way on the medium.. maybe it’s just the size we ordered but square cut >>>
… moreLauren Easterby-Jackson
Lovely little pizza/grinder shop. The service is excellent and the eggplant grinders are out of this world. They load them up with fried eggplant, sauce, and pepper strips on a toasted roll. One order of friends is enough for two people and they are cooked to perfection. Generous portions, friendly staff, highly recommended.
… moreDoug Miller
Greek style pizza that is always consistent and delicious. My go-to is the house special. Pastrami grinder never disappoints. If you dine in be sure to get one of their salads, served in a large bowl.
… moreC Kroeber
Ordered take-out. Pizza was hot and ready right on time. Service was fast and friendly. Its greek style, so if you like that sort of Pizza then you’ll probably enjoy it. Not my favorite, but thats persinal preference. Specify pie cut or you’ll end up with a Pizza ruined by the Greek style of hacking up a round pie into abject horrror.
… morePronetoRome
Who knew I needed to experience Greek style pizza? Traveling from coast to coast for work, having tried pizza everywhere in between… this pizza is whole heartedly top 5 best pizza I’ve ever had. The crust absolutely blew my mind, it was light and crispy. I ordered half pineapple and ham and half buffalo chicken. I meant to take half of it home, it did not make it out of the pizzeria. The crust along with being so light and crispy in the outside and soft and light in the inside , has a hint of buttery goodness that hovered around my olfactory senses for the next hour. This place is an absolute gem. As I ordered and sat to eat, I saw multiple people come in, each one was greeted by the family that owns and runs this joint with their first name, genuinely happy to see them. This pizza joint makes me wish I grew up close by, the food, people and culture is fantastic.
… moreLou Soteriou
Elm Hill Pizza has the best Pizzas and Grinders and etc on the planet earth:
I highly recommend you purchasing your future Pizzas and Grinders, etc. at Elm Hill Pizza the two brothers have exceptional customer service skillsa also the two brothers Nick and George are excellent cooks they’re very passionate about their food. Nick and George treat everyone like they were their family members period.
Loui-what we do in life goes to eternity so make it count with Jesus.
Me and my wife, Sheila are doggy lovers in this review they’ll be some portraits of our doggies.
… moreI highly recommend you purchasing your future Pizzas and Grinders, etc. at Elm Hill Pizza the two brothers have exceptional customer service skillsa also the two brothers Nick and George are excellent cooks they’re very passionate about their food. Nick and George treat everyone like they were their family members period.
Loui-what we do in life goes to eternity so make it count with Jesus.
Me and my wife, Sheila are doggy lovers in this review they’ll be some portraits of our doggies.
J Ouellette
Best roast beef grinder around. And Stateline potato chips too – which are the absolute best chips in the world. A+
… morenikor lopez
I called this place to order and ask if they deliver… I JUST moved to this location so I asked the simple question of whether they deliver or not and the person on the phone was so rude and disrespectful for NO REASON!!! She started mocking me “do we deliver? You want pizza come and get it” and kept on going. Well I know we’re all humans and she might stress but if she can’t answer a simple question without snarky comments then she shouldn’t answer the phone.
… moreAJ Belanger
We had a meatball pizza, mozzarella sticks, garlic wings, tuna melt, everything was excellent. Fair prices, great food, friendly owner family operated. Order at the counter, self service. Small place but there’s 4-5 booths, comfortable atmosphere, clean, busy with take out. Thankful a friend recommended it.
… more