Billy Sherlin
We have been wanting to stop here for over a year and we finally made it tonight. It did not disappoint! I had the Italian sub and Angie had the baked Lasagna. We also got a side of pepperoni pizza garlic bread. Very good with nice portions. Friendly service although it took a little long for our food, but not unreasonably long for how busy they were. We will be back!
… moreFlores Tree Services -Lucinda
We (Jose and I)stopped in to try out the Pizza. It was delicious!! The service was excellent and the host was very polite and helpful. The bathrooms and dining area was extremely clean. It didn’t look like anything I remembered 25 years ago when I was a a server and cook on the side of the road diner. I would recommend Elliot’s Pizzeria to anyone. The pizza was made with love and perfection.
… moreEric Thomas
We love Elliott’s Pizzeria! Pizzas and sandwiches are great. I’m a big fan of the Cave Run Supreme pizza and the Italian Sub sandwich. The staff is very friendly and attentive. We always dine in, but takeout and delivery are available as well. If you’re in the Cave Run, Farmers, Saltlick, or Sharkey area give them a try, you won’t be disappointed.
… moreJames Allison
We carried out from Elliott’s this past weekend while on a camping trip at Cave Run Lake. I am glad that we finally got around to trying it after driving past it many times and vowing to check it out one day. I will happily be back in the future!
We carried out two pizzas, a small regular crust and a medium thin crust. Both were great! Great flavor and composition. While I liked the regular crust and will get it again – this genuinely might be one of the best thin crust pizzas I have ever had anywhere. We had some leftover that we snacked on through the weekend and continued to talk about how much we enjoyed it. Great place and I’m looking forward to visiting again when we are back out that way!
… moreLevi Rayburn
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“Moving back home to open my own local business has brought a lot of surprises — but none better than gaining the BEST local business neighbors. These folks literally dropped off a pizza to us on our anniversary. Who does that?! ❤️
And don’t even get me started on the Spillway BBQ pizza… I’m fully obsessed. Like, ‘thinking about it while I’m supposed to be working’ obsessed. Now I’m drooling just writing this.
If you haven’t tried them yet, run. Don’t walk. This place is everything a hometown spot should be — delicious food, incredible people, and community at its core.”
… moreHeidi Honea
Found the place on Google maps. First we called to see if dogs were allowed and the hours, it was about 7:30 pm. Drove in left of the entrance and parked to the left of the food service entrance. First time diner here. Walked in and heard what didn’t seem to be rerun music. Saw a blind, walked towards it and peaked behind, awesome bar and live band. Not sure what the women said but only heard that’s a broken window behind the blind and a facial expression that reflected I was a two year old being scolded. I explained this was our first time here, and I didn’t know and then was completely ignored moving forward. I then went next door (behind the blind) and waited patiently by the bar not to acknowledge or be given a smile. The music was so loud, in such a small space the waitress had the audacity to act offended that she wasn’t heard when asked about the beer selection or to repeat. Once returned to the other side to place an order, I stood in line while a worker looking out the window at the covered patio asked whose dog was that to another coworker, not having acknowledged my presence at any point and I stated that’s my dog (who was my partner). Then I addressed the same lady who scolded me which was dressing down the salad bar, how it worked. She stated they closed the bar an hour before closing and walked away. Said they had served way too many salads any way and I thought how did that apply to me standing in front of her and my question? Once I waited another five minutes while associates bustled around, the woman who was on the phone having not once said anything to the other line to which she was holding the phone or acknowledged my presence finally took my order. I was told the order would then be delivered where we sat. More than 15-20 minutes passed and my partner came to me and said he thought the order had been sitting inside on the table for some time. Sure enough it had. Four stars is for the fact there is live music. The sub we ordered was small and would feed a senior adult. My partner went to the truck for a small pickle and another handful of pretzels. The calzone was just right but with no sauce inside (I ordered cheese and mushroom) the side of sauce just wasn’t enough.
Completely separate from the restaurant the traffic speed is completely inappropriate! I’m not even from here and unless you post the expectations of the round about which is a few yards away from the restaurant you are going to have, heavy feet pissed off locals gunning it from anger. Slow down the speed or an innocent child is going to get creamed.
… moreDrew “Airborne” Delalla
What a great family pizza joint! You couldn’t find a nicer staff anywhere like this! Every single person in that business was constantly caring for customers! In my military experience that is because this is a very well trained staff! Food was fast with 100% regard to quality! When you find your target pizza place you stick with it! If you eat this crust and you walk away not impressed then YOUR tastebuds are dead! The Elliot’s Philly pizza was amazing! The ingredients tasted fresh! This place will soon be a neighborhood treasure! The atmosphere inside our out is pretty cool! Just one veterans opinion!
… moreJ Silva
Salad bar has homemade ranch! Pizza was excellent, crust well cooked with gooey cheese and toppings we ordered. We enjoyed the option to have a beer with our dinner.
… moreD Keeton
My husband, adult son and myself went today around 3 pm. The food was pretty good – but the customer service was what set it apart. There was a man and two women working and the man who was taking orders, refilling drinks and delivering food was amazing! He kept our drinks full, was kind and made the visit great! He deserves a raise!
… moreBrittany “Sadie B.” Mabry
Gave Elliott’s another try and they were so excellent! Perfect pizza sub, toasted and seasoned just perfect!
… more