Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 224 Edgartown Rd, Edgartown, MA 02539
Phone: (508) 627-7770
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Edgartown Pizza Edgartown, MA
Open for Lunch & Dinner 10:30am – 9pm 224 Edgartown Road At the tip of the Triangle, where Beach Road from Oak Bluffs meets Edgartown Road.
Edgartown Pizza – Edgartown, MA – 224 Edgartown Rd – Hours …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Edgartown Pizza in Edgartown, MA. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Edgartown Pizza – Facebook
Details. . 86% recommend (46 Reviews). . $. . Closed now. . 224 Edgartown Vineyard Haven Rd, Edgartown, MA, United States, 02539 ; Links. . edgartownpizza.
Last Updates
Reviews
Debbie J
Delicious pizza with vegan cheese always available. Friendly staff; funky, casual vibe. We go back every time we’re on the Vineyard.
… moreniks
I have ordered X large pizza for out, for my friends, the staff was very convient to handle, they give you all needed information and preferences. I realy liked the perfect how it was said time for waiting, 20 minutes usually for pizza. I didnt eat, but friends were delighted.
They have pizzas, sandwiches for breakfast, teriyaki, chicken fingers, mozzarela sticks, and bunch of different food. It isnt very healthy meals option restaurant but it is very good pizzeria and fast, quick, big portions food.
… moreThey have pizzas, sandwiches for breakfast, teriyaki, chicken fingers, mozzarela sticks, and bunch of different food. It isnt very healthy meals option restaurant but it is very good pizzeria and fast, quick, big portions food.
Olivia Braaten
I walked out pretty upset, actually (but…stay tuned). We ordered for a pre-sunset pick-up on our way to South Beach. We received notification that it was ready at 5:28 — perfect! Walked in. Actually not ready. Due to an unexplained “mistake” in the kitchen, we had to wait 30 minutes, and with six little children sitting in the car, and sunset at 6:10, this wasn’t ideal. It would have been a nice touch to offer something to make up for it, but other than “it’ll be a few more minutes,” nobody said anything. Sitting in an empty restaurant watching the clock is no fun.
So did I expect to be posting a 1-star review? Yeah. But I’m not, because, honestly, the pizza is ridiculously good. So good, that frankly, it’s worth the wait. We got a GF pepperoni (heads up, that comes in small — the Instacart menu didn’t indicate, so we thought it was going to be bigger) and Talia’s Choice (artichoke, garlic, mushroom, pesto). Quite possibly the best pizza I’ve ever had, and I would try it again.
… moreSo did I expect to be posting a 1-star review? Yeah. But I’m not, because, honestly, the pizza is ridiculously good. So good, that frankly, it’s worth the wait. We got a GF pepperoni (heads up, that comes in small — the Instacart menu didn’t indicate, so we thought it was going to be bigger) and Talia’s Choice (artichoke, garlic, mushroom, pesto). Quite possibly the best pizza I’ve ever had, and I would try it again.
Emma Martinez
We ordered the XL Brazilian Pizza and it was amazing. Really delicious. Crispy on the edges and soft delicious middle!
Excellent customer service.
Great price!
Will definitely come again!
… moreExcellent customer service.
Great price!
Will definitely come again!
Drew Kravitz
I ordered it well done she repeated so. Picked it up, opened it to has that nice well done look. I was happy, got it home and the bottom was soggy & barely cooked. I did not think I had to ask for the bottom to be well done also.
… moreKatie Boudreau
Delicious pizza spot with a cool casual interior. We were looking for a simple, non-seafood meal during October and came across this pizza restaurant.
The outside isn’t fancy and a little unassuming, but inside it’s warm and inviting.
I got a small pepperoni pizza, and had a few slices left over. Two people with a small appetite could probably share it fine. The pepperoni was nice and crispy, and the cheese and sauce were tasty!
… moreThe outside isn’t fancy and a little unassuming, but inside it’s warm and inviting.
I got a small pepperoni pizza, and had a few slices left over. Two people with a small appetite could probably share it fine. The pepperoni was nice and crispy, and the cheese and sauce were tasty!
MVPizza
Out of 10 times you may order here they’ll get your order right once. Out of 20 times you may order here it’ll be edible once. Be wary ordering any specialty pizzas online as they actively scam buyers and try to dispute eligible refunds. Pizza is almost never cooked all the way through and will get stuck to/ rip off on the cardboard between the pizza and box.
… moreM&V S
Giving 3 stars because the woman on the phone was very nice. However I must warn other vegans, their pizza dough is NOT vegan. They have vegan cheese but the dough has eggs in it so, sadly, they DO NOT have vegan pizza. Which is super weird and unnecessary, pizza dough does not typically have eggs. Just because a restaurant offers a vegan item does not mean the item is actually vegan. As someone with allergy to eggs I find this misinformation very dangerous.
… moreLis Bluford
Edgartown Pizza has such an extensive menu – we tried their chicken alfredo pizza on cauliflower crust, chicken sandwich, chicken Caesar salad, teriyaki steak tips, meat lovers pizza. We enjoyed every dish and were pleased with the quantity and portions and the food for the price. Great customer service from their owner, Danny! Would definitely return. Reviewed by @MVacay.
… moreGrace Rehak
We decided to change it up from Gios, and We had high hopes, but all 5 of our pizzas were almost brown and way over cooked, and rock hard it was difficult to eat. Lack of flavor as well. Will not be ordering again unfortunately.
… more