Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 169 S Plank Rd, Newburgh, NY 12550
Phone: (845) 561-3333
Website: http://eddiesgourmetnewburgh.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Eddie’s Gourmet Pizza – Newburgh, NY – 169 S Plank Rd – Hours …
Come and visit us at 169 South Plank Road, Newburgh – right next to Tarsio Lanes Bowling Alley. Catch up with Eddie’s Gourmet Pizza on Facebook, Instagram and …
Eddie’s Gourmet Pizza – 169 S Plank Rd, Newburgh, NY 12550 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Newburgh, NY! Eddie’s Gourmet Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
Eddies Gourmet Pizza | Newburgh NY – Facebook
Good food, relaxing night, and the weekend ahead. Military & Veterans receive 10% OFF every day 845-561-3333 169 S Plank Rd, Newburgh #FridayNightPizza # …
Reviews
Maxx Basso
We have tried almost every pizza place in Newburgh, and this is by far the best. The dough, sauce, cheese combo? Perfect. The customer service is always so nice. We literally love this BBQ chicken pizza so much that we crave it and have no option but to order one. Seriously, if you’re looking for a BBQ chicken pie, this is it.
… moreVirginia aka Ginger
I asked for a eggplant Parm dinner little sauce little cheese ricotta on top ask for penne on the side and the pictures below is what I got the manager said I’m sorry for mix up is it okay if I credit you or dinner I said yes call tonight to get it and I can’t get it the way I want it I have to get it exactly how it comes not fair not what I was looking for he said the girl read the instructions back to me and I okayed it that is exactly what I asked for and did not receive I will show you the pictures somebody would have to be crazy the eggplant was greasy hard and burnt you will see in the pictures tried to give him a chance to rectify it but they do not want to do it my way what I paid for
… moreCam
DONT LET BIG JUSTICE FOOL YOU! Most expensive wings around and they are NOT good. Next to raw and absolutely disgusting to even look at. 0 BOOMS
… moreElizabeth Bertotelli
Chicken bacon ranch pizza never had ranch on it. BBQ chicken pizza didn’t even taste like BBQ at all. Buffalo pizza came with ranch on it and I asked for no ranch. The Italian combo was spoiled the salami was discolored, ham tasted bad, and it had basalmic vinegar not oil and vinegar. A few coworks got sick and hour after eating.
… moreRich Barry
One day I was still in laundry. Thought maybe it was Eddie cuz I was parked behind their restaurant didn’t even know I was parked behind the restaurant. I just ordered delivery from them as I’m staying in the hotel down the road. Very nice service and the pizza is amazing the Mac bites are have not tried the cannolis but I’m sure they’re good just like every other place is. I would rate these guys 5 out of 5 10 out of 10. Will definitely order from them this thanks for the great food and service.
… moreLivelove Laugh
Hands down the best pizza in town! Also, the new owner is friendly & has great customer service. Will be returning and spreading the word.
… moreToshi
Eddie’s Gourmet Pizza came through in a pinch! I ordered food last min the day before my daughter birthday. He was so pleasant and helpful on the phone! I got 4 pies, tray of penne, meatballs and sausage & peppers. He even got rolls for me and they were so soft! All so delicious! And the meatballs are to die for! I also was to pick the order up the next day and was not able to. I called them 2 hours before the party to ask if they could deliver it and there was no hesitation they said yes. The delivery guy was so nice and sweet. He helped bring everything in and even asked if I needed anything else! Eddie’s will be my go to for every party!
… moreanthony leoce
I have been going to Eddie’s since Eddie was making pizza. All the recipes have stayed the same ever since. My go to order is the Bourbon St. spicy Cajun chicken, hot peppers and onions. Honestly, I’ve had it all. Wings, garlic knots, calzones and their homemade lasagna. All of it delicious. The employees work hard to make you experience pleasant.
… moreHeather Vigrass
Always a great atmosphere and cleanest pizza shop in the area hands down! The owner and staff are pleasant and get my orders perfect every time. Just recently had a grad party catered as well and food was top notch with all my guests raving!
… moreTamara Steinhaus
Me and my family have been eating here for over 20 years! Thank you for all the years of EXCELLENT pizza and the service you guys always provide with a SMILE !!! ❤️ AND THANK YOU FOR MAKING IT AFFORDABLE WITH THE EVERDAY SPECIALS!! GOD BLESS YOU ALWAYS!
… more